Choosing the right allspice depends on whether you need ground or whole berries, the size of the container, and your specific culinary goals. Allspice offers a warm, complex flavor profile with notes of cinnamon, nutmeg, and clove, making it a versatile addition to both sweet and savory dishes.
This guide compares eight allspice options, ranging from small 0.9-ounce containers to bulk 16-ounce packages. Whether you are baking holiday pies, pickling vegetables, or seasoning Caribbean-style meats, these selections cover a variety of forms, certifications, and sizes to fit your pantry needs.
Our 3 picks for different needs
Badia Allspice Whole 12 Oz
The 12-ounce whole allspice is ideal for pickling recipes and allows you to grind fresh for desserts.
Read the details
Badia Ground Allspice Seasoning 16 Oz
The 16-ounce ground allspice is a bulk option well-suited for pies, cakes, and jerk seasoning.
Read the details
365 by Whole Foods Market Organic Ground Allspice 1.83 Oz
The 1.83-ounce organic allspice is USDA certified organic, non-GMO verified, and certified kosher.
Read the detailsAll products, in detail
Amazon Grocery Ground Allspice 2.5 Oz
This 2.5-ounce bottle of ground allspice offers a peppery and sweet flavor profile. It is a convenient addition to sweet potatoes, squash, chili, meatballs, and BBQ sauce. The Amazon Grocery brand focuses on providing everyday favorites for great-tasting meals in a single shopping trip. This option suits shoppers who want a standard ground spice for versatile savory and sweet applications without needing a bulk container.
- 2.5-ounce bottle of ground allspice
- Peppery and sweet flavor profile
365 by Whole Foods Market Ground Allspice 1.73 Ounce
Sourced from premium whole berries, this 1.73-ounce ground allspice delivers a warm, complex flavor with notes of cinnamon, nutmeg, and clove. It is well-suited for baking, marinades, and seasonal recipes. The brand emphasizes rigorous quality testing to ensure optimal freshness and sources from trusted growers committed to sustainable practices.
This small container is ideal for bakers who want a high-quality ground spice for specific holiday or dessert projects.
- 1.73-ounce ground allspice
- Sourced from trusted growers committed to sustainable practices
365 by Whole Foods Market Organic Ground Allspice 1.83 Oz
This 1.83-ounce organic ground allspice is made with premium allspice and is USDA certified organic. It is non-GMO verified and certified kosher, making it suitable for a wide range of dietary preferences. The listing highlights its utility for both baking and cooking. Shoppers seeking certified organic and kosher spices for everyday meals or specific dietary requirements will find this small, versatile container a practical choice for their pantry.
- USDA certified organic and non-GMO verified
- Certified kosher
McCormick Ground Allspice 0.9 Oz
This 0.9-ounce container of McCormick ground allspice is always ground from whole allspice berries. The spice is hand-picked for its peppery sweetness and spicy aroma, containing the sweet and warm flavors of cloves, cinnamon, and nutmeg. It adds a spicy-sweet taste to pumpkin pie, cake, and molasses cookies, as well as savory Cincinnati chili and Swedish meatballs.
This compact size is perfect for occasional bakers or those who want to try a new spice without a large commitment.
- 0.9-ounce container
- Hand-picked for peppery sweetness and spicy aroma
Badia Allspice Whole 12 Oz
This 12-ounce container of Badia whole allspice provides a rich and warm aroma with notes of cinnamon, nutmeg, and clove. It is versatile for cooking, baking, and pickling, allowing users to grind it fresh for desserts or use it whole in spice rubs and marinades.
The bulk-size package ensures you have allspice on hand for seasoning meats, brewing spiced tea, or creating holiday treats. This option is best for home cooks who frequently use whole spices for pickling or who prefer to grind their own for maximum freshness.
- 12-ounce container of whole allspice
- Ideal for pickling, spice rubs, and marinades
Badia Ground Allspice Seasoning 16 Oz
This 16-ounce container of Badia ground allspice features a warm, sweet, and slightly peppery flavor with notes of cinnamon, nutmeg, and cloves. It is commonly used in baking, marinades, savory dishes, and spice blends, and is integral to Caribbean cuisine. The large size is suitable for frequent bakers or those who use allspice in a variety of sweet and savory dishes.
This bulk ground option is a practical choice for households that use allspice regularly in pies, cakes, and meat dishes.
- 16-ounce container of ground allspice
- Integral to Caribbean cuisine and jerk seasoning
Simply Organic Allspice 2.57 Ounce
This 2.57-ounce organic ground allspice from Simply Organic combines cinnamon, nutmeg, and cloves for a warm, aromatic spice. It is perfect for pies, cookies, stews, and savory marinades, adding depth and complexity to both sweet and savory dishes. The brand works directly with sourcing partners to pay fair prices and maximize the grower's return.
This option is ideal for shoppers who prioritize organic certification and direct sourcing practices in their spice purchases.
- 2.57-ounce organic ground allspice
- Simply Organic works directly with sourcing partners
McCormick Gourmet Organic Ground Allspice 1.5 Oz
This 1.5-ounce container of McCormick Gourmet Organic Ground Allspice adds warm notes of nutmeg, cloves, and cinnamon to sweet and savory dishes. The allspice comes from the cured, unripe berries of a tropical evergreen tree and is certified organic and non-GMO. It is a must-have for holiday baking in gingerbread, pumpkin pie, and spice cookies, as well as essential to Caribbean cuisine in meat stews and Jamaican jerk seasoning.
This small organic option is well-suited for holiday bakers and fans of Caribbean flavors.
- 1.5-ounce certified organic and non-GMO ground allspice
- Essential to Caribbean cuisine in meat stews and Jamaican jerk seasoning
Head-to-Head Comparisons
Badia Whole vs. Badia Ground Allspice
Both Badia options offer a warm, aromatic blend of cinnamon, nutmeg, and clove notes, but they differ in form and size. The 12-ounce whole allspice is ideal for pickling, spice rubs, and those who prefer to grind their own for maximum freshness. The 16-ounce ground allspice is ready to use in baking, marinades, and savory dishes, and is noted as integral to Caribbean cuisine.
If you frequently pickle or want the flexibility of grinding, choose the whole berries. If you use allspice primarily in baked goods or pre-made spice blends, the ground version is more convenient.
365 Organic vs. Simply Organic Allspice
Both 365 by Whole Foods Market and Simply Organic offer certified organic ground allspice, but they differ in size and specific certifications. The 365 option is 1.83 ounces, non-GMO verified, and certified kosher, making it suitable for specific dietary requirements. The Simply Organic option is 2.57 ounces and highlights direct sourcing practices with growers.
If you need a kosher-certified spice, the 365 product is the clear choice. If you prioritize a slightly larger container and direct sourcing ethics, the Simply Organic option may be a better fit for your pantry.
McCormick Standard vs. McCormick Gourmet Organic
McCormick offers two small ground allspice containers: the 0.9-ounce standard version and the 1.5-ounce Gourmet Organic version. The standard 0.9-ounce option is hand-picked for peppery sweetness and is great for occasional use in chili or cookies. The 1.5-ounce Gourmet Organic version is certified organic and non-GMO, and is highlighted as essential for holiday baking and Caribbean cuisine.
If you want a very small trial size, the standard 0.9-ounce bottle is appropriate. If you prefer organic certification and a slightly larger quantity for holiday baking, the Gourmet Organic option is the better choice.
Buying Guide
Ground vs. Whole Allspice
Decide whether you need ground or whole allspice based on your primary use. Ground allspice is ready to use in baking, marinades, and spice blends, making it convenient for everyday cooking. Whole allspice is ideal for pickling, spice rubs, and those who prefer to grind their own for maximum freshness and aroma.
If you frequently pickle or want the flexibility of grinding, choose whole berries. If you use allspice primarily in baked goods or pre-made spice blends, ground is more practical. Consider keeping both if you use allspice in a variety of ways.
Container Size and Frequency of Use
Match the container size to how often you use allspice. Small containers, such as the 0.9-ounce and 1.5-ounce options, are suitable for occasional bakers or those who want to try a new spice without a large commitment. Larger containers, such as the 12-ounce and 16-ounce options, are better for frequent users who use allspice in a variety of sweet and savory dishes.
If you bake regularly or use allspice in Caribbean-style cooking, a larger container may be more economical and convenient. Check current prices on the live product cards to compare cost per ounce for different sizes.
Organic and Dietary Certifications
If you have specific dietary requirements, look for certifications such as USDA organic, non-GMO, or kosher. The 365 by Whole Foods Market organic allspice is USDA certified organic, non-GMO verified, and certified kosher. The McCormick Gourmet Organic allspice is certified organic and non-GMO. The Simply Organic allspice is also organic and highlights direct sourcing practices.
If you follow a kosher diet, the 365 product is a clear choice. If you prioritize organic certification and direct sourcing, the Simply Organic option may be a better fit. Always check the label for specific certifications that align with your dietary needs.
Culinary Applications and Flavor Profile
Allspice offers a warm, complex flavor with notes of cinnamon, nutmeg, and clove, making it versatile for both sweet and savory dishes. It is commonly used in baking, such as pies, cakes, and cookies, as well as in savory dishes like chili, stews, and Caribbean-style meats.
If you are primarily a baker, look for options that highlight baking uses. If you cook Caribbean or pickling recipes, consider whole allspice or options that emphasize savory applications. Pairing allspice with fresh herbs or other spices can enhance its flavor in various dishes. Explore different recipes to find the applications that suit your taste.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between ground and whole allspice?
Ground allspice is ready to use in baking and cooking, while whole allspice is ideal for pickling and grinding fresh. Choose ground for convenience and whole for maximum freshness and aroma in spice rubs and marinades.
Is allspice suitable for vegan and vegetarian diets?
Yes, allspice is a plant-based spice and is suitable for vegan and vegetarian diets. It is commonly used in both sweet and savory dishes, making it a versatile addition to plant-based recipes.
How should I store allspice to maintain freshness?
Store allspice in a cool, dry place away from direct sunlight. Keep the container tightly sealed to preserve the aroma and flavor. Whole allspice may retain its freshness longer than ground allspice.
Can I use allspice in savory dishes?
Yes, allspice is commonly used in savory dishes such as chili, stews, meatballs, and Caribbean-style meats. It adds a warm, spicy-sweet flavor that complements rich sauces and marinades.
This article is part of our complete guide Grocery & Gourmet Food — browse all our comparisons and buying guides.
Last update on 2026-11-18 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API
