Selecting the right art paints depends on your specific project needs, whether you are a beginner looking for a complete kit or a professional seeking a specific tube size. The options in this comparison range from compact 2-ounce bottles to large 250ml tubes, with color counts varying from single shades to extensive 50-color palettes.
Each product in this list offers distinct advantages, such as matte finishes for crafts or satin finishes for studio work. By examining the bottle sizes, surface compatibility, and included accessories, you can find the acrylic paint that best fits your creative workflow and storage space.
Our pick: TMOL 24-Color Acrylic Set with Brushes. The TMOL set includes 24 paints and 12 brushes, providing all the necessary tools for a new artist to begin painting immediately.
Our 3 picks for different needs
Shuttle Art 50-Color Acrylic Set
The 50-color Shuttle Art set offers the widest range of shades, including fluorescent and metallic options, for artists needing diverse pigments.
Read the details
TMOL 24-Color Acrylic Set with Brushes
The TMOL set includes 24 paints and 12 brushes, providing all the necessary tools for a new artist to begin painting immediately.
Read the details
Liquitex BASICS 250ml Titanium White
The Liquitex BASICS 250ml tube offers a thick, creamy consistency that retains brush strokes, suitable for those learning color mixing.
Read the detailsAll products, in detail
TMOL 24-Color Acrylic Set with Brushes
This all-inclusive kit provides 24 vibrant 60ml bottles alongside 12 high-quality acrylic brushes, making it a ready-to-use starter pack. The paints are described as non-toxic and compliant with ASTM D4236 standards, offering a safe entry point for beginners. The set is designed for versatility across canvas, wood, and fabric, with a fast-drying formula that allows for immediate layering.
It is a practical choice for those who need both pigments and tools in a single purchase.
- Includes 24 paints in 60ml bottles and 12 brushes
- Non-toxic formula adhering to ASTM D4236 standards
Apple Barrel 16-Color Vibrant Spectrum Set
The Apple Barrel Vibrant Spectrum Collection offers 16 assorted matte colors in 2-ounce bottles, focusing on bright, bold shades like Flag Red and Parrot Blue. These paints dry to a brilliant matte finish, which is ideal for crafts and decorative projects. The set is manufactured in the USA and is designed for easy application on surfaces such as wood, plaster, and terra cotta.
Cleanup is straightforward with soap and water while the paint is still wet, making it a user-friendly option for casual crafting.
- 16 matte-finish colors in 2 oz bottles
- Proudly manufactured in the USA
Apple Barrel 8-Ounce Titanium White
This single 8-ounce bottle of Apple Barrel acrylic paint is a versatile staple for basecoating and large-scale stenciling. The paint dries to a matte finish and is formulated as a non-toxic, water-based product suitable for all ages. It is designed to work on a wide variety of substrates, including wood, paper, canvas, and paper mache.
For artists who need a large quantity of a specific color for background work or DIY projects, this larger tube provides ample coverage without the need for multiple small bottles.
- 8 oz tube size ideal for basecoating
- Non-toxic, water-based formula
Shuttle Art 36-Color Set with Palette
The Shuttle Art 36-color set includes highly pigmented paints in 2oz bottles, featuring classic metallic gold and silver options. It comes with 12 brushes and a palette, allowing users to start painting immediately upon arrival. The paints are described as creamy and easy to blend, providing consistent shades for detailing and texturing.
The packaging is a strengthened cardboard box that doubles as an organizer, and the paints are certified non-toxic and acid-free for safe use by kids and adults.
- 36 colors including metallic gold and silver
- Includes 12 brushes and a palette in a sturdy box
Apple Barrel 2-Ounce Black
This 2-ounce bottle of Apple Barrel black acrylic paint is a convenient addition to any craft kit. It dries to a matte finish and is suitable for a variety of surfaces such as wood, paper, and canvas. The paint is easy to apply with brushes, stamps, or sponges, and cleanup is simple with soap and water.
As a single-color option, it is ideal for artists who already have a palette but need to replenish a specific shade or add a bold contrast to their projects.
- 2 oz bottle of matte black paint
- Suitable for wood, paper, and canvas
Artkey 24-Color Professional Acrylic Set
The Artkey 24-color set features professional artist quality paints in 2oz bottles with a butter-like consistency that glides smoothly. The bottles are tightly packed to prevent leaking or drying out, and each is marked with a color name for easy identification. The paints are certified safe and non-toxic for people and pets, making them suitable for a wide range of users.
This kit is packaged in a sturdy box and is intended for ages 12 and up, offering a balance of quality and safety for serious hobbyists.
- 24 bottles with tight-seal caps to prevent drying
- Certified safe and non-toxic for people and pets
Shuttle Art 50-Color Acrylic Set
This extensive 50-color set from Shuttle Art provides a wide range of options, including fluorescent and metallic shades, all in 60ml bottles. The paints are water-based with a creamy texture that is easy to mix and layer, offering great coverage for various artistic techniques. The set is certified to U.S.
ASTM D-4236 and EN71-3 standards, ensuring it is non-toxic and acid-free. It is a comprehensive choice for artists who want a broad palette for painting on glass, rocks, walls, and other surfaces.
- 50 colors including fluorescent and metallic shades
- Certified to ASTM D-4236 and EN71-3 standards
Liquitex BASICS 250ml Titanium White
The Liquitex BASICS Titanium White comes in a 250ml tube and features a thick, creamy consistency with a satin finish. It has a good pigment load and retains peaks and brush strokes, making it ideal for learning color theory and mixing. This paint is intermixable with Liquitex Professional Acrylic Paint Colors and Mediums, offering flexibility for artists who may upgrade their supplies later.
It conforms to ASTM D4236 and is safe for educational use, providing a reliable foundation for studio work.
- 250ml tube with satin finish and good pigment load
- Intermixable with Liquitex Professional colors
Head-to-Head Comparisons
Shuttle Art 36-Color vs 50-Color Sets
Both Shuttle Art sets offer highly pigmented, non-toxic paints in 60ml bottles, but they differ in scope and included accessories. The 36-color set includes 12 brushes and a palette, making it a more complete starter kit for those who need tools. The 50-color set provides a broader range of shades, including fluorescent and metallic options, but does not list included brushes in its primary features.
If you already own brushes, the 50-color set offers more variety; if you are starting from scratch, the 36-color set provides a more all-inclusive experience.
Apple Barrel 8-Ounce vs 2-Ounce Bottles
These two Apple Barrel products share the same matte finish and non-toxic formula but differ significantly in volume. The 8-ounce bottle is designed for basecoating and large-scale stenciling, providing ample paint for covering broad surfaces. The 2-ounce bottle is more convenient for small projects or for artists who want to try a color without committing to a larger quantity.
Choosing between them depends on whether you need a large supply for background work or a smaller amount for detailed accents.
Artkey 24-Color vs TMOL 24-Color Sets
Both the Artkey and TMOL sets offer 24 colors in approximately 2-ounce bottles, but they differ in their included accessories and safety certifications. The TMOL set includes 12 brushes, making it a ready-to-use kit, while the Artkey set focuses on the paint quality with tight-seal caps to prevent drying.
The Artkey set is certified safe for pets and is intended for ages 12 and up, whereas the TMOL set is marketed for a wider age range including kids. The choice depends on whether you prioritize included tools or specific safety certifications for pets.
Buying Guide
Color Count and Variety
The number of colors in a set determines the scope of your projects. Sets with 16 to 24 colors are suitable for general crafting and beginner painting, providing a solid foundation of primary and secondary shades. Larger sets with 36 to 50 colors offer more nuance, including metallics and fluorescents, which are useful for advanced techniques.
If you are a beginner, a smaller set may be less overwhelming, while experienced artists may prefer the extensive range of a 50-color kit.
Bottle Size and Volume
Bottle size affects how long your paint will last and how much you can use at once. Smaller 2-ounce bottles are ideal for detailed work or for trying out new colors without waste. Larger 8-ounce or 250ml tubes are better for basecoating, large canvases, or projects that require a significant amount of a single color.
Consider your typical project size when choosing between compact bottles and larger tubes to ensure you have enough paint for your needs.
Surface Compatibility
Most acrylic paints in this comparison are suitable for a wide range of surfaces, including canvas, wood, paper, and ceramic. However, some brands emphasize specific uses, such as Apple Barrel for stenciling and paper mache, or Liquitex for studio work where brush strokes are retained.
Check the specific surfaces you plan to paint on to ensure the paint adheres well and dries to the desired finish, whether matte or satin.
Safety and Age Appropriateness
Safety standards are important, especially when painting with children or in shared spaces. Many of these paints are non-toxic and conform to ASTM D4236 standards, making them safe for educational use. Some sets, like the Artkey kit, are certified safe for pets and intended for ages 12 and up, while others are marketed for all ages.
If you are painting with young children, look for washable options or sets with clear safety certifications to ensure a safe creative environment.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are these acrylic paints washable?
Most of the paints listed are water-based and can be cleaned with soap and water while wet. However, once dry, acrylic paints are generally permanent and waterproof. For washable options, you may want to look specifically at kids' paint kits designed for easy cleanup.
Can I mix these paints with other brands?
Acrylic paints are generally intermixable with other acrylic brands. The Liquitex BASICS paint is specifically noted as intermixable with Liquitex Professional colors and mediums. Mixing different brands is usually possible, but results may vary depending on the specific formulations.
Do these sets come with brushes?
Some sets include brushes, such as the TMOL 24-color set and the Shuttle Art 36-color set. Other products, like the single Apple Barrel bottles and the Liquitex tube, are sold as paint only. Check the specific product details to see if brushes or palettes are included.
What is the difference between matte and satin finishes?
Matte finishes, like those found in Apple Barrel paints, dry to a non-glossy, flat surface that is ideal for crafts. Satin finishes, such as the Liquitex BASICS, have a slight sheen and retain brush strokes better, which is often preferred for studio art and color mixing.
This article is part of our complete guide Arts, Crafts & Sewing — browse all our comparisons and buying guides.
Last update on 2026-11-18 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API
