Selecting the right bathtub drain depends heavily on the existing mechanism in your bathroom. Whether you have a traditional lift-and-turn stopper, a tip-toe design, or a trip lever system, the replacement must match the internal plumbing to function correctly.
This comparison covers eight distinct options, ranging from full assembly kits to simple strainer inserts. By identifying your current drain type and measuring the drain shoe, you can choose a product that ensures proper water flow and easy maintenance.
Our 3 picks for different needs
Artiwell Universal Tip Toe Bath Drain Stopper (Brushed Nickel)
The Artiwell Brushed Nickel stopper installs by dropping into the drain shoe, eliminating the need to remove the old drain or use plumber putty.
Read the details
Artiwell Tub Drain Linkage Assembly with Trip Lever
The Artiwell Linkage Assembly is specifically designed to repair worn-out trip lever drains, including the internal linkage and face plate.
Read the details
Ohtomber 2PCS Stainless Steel Bathtub Drain Strainer
The Ohtomber Stainless Steel Strainer is a simple, tool-free insert that catches hair and debris to prevent clogs in various drain sizes.
Read the detailsAll products, in detail
EZ-FLO Lift-n-Turn Bath Drain Assembly Kit
This assembly kit is designed for standard lift-and-turn mechanisms, featuring a durable brass construction with a chrome finish. It includes a 1-1/2 inch coarse thread body, a 2-7/8 inch flange, and a tapped washer. The intuitive lift and turn mechanism allows for easy operation, while the adjustable brass clevis ensures a universal fit for most drains.
This option is suitable for buyers replacing a worn-out lift-turn stopper who prefer a traditional, robust brass build.
- Features a durable brass construction with a chrome finish
- Includes a 1-1/2 inch x 11.5 coarse thread body and 2-7/8 inch flange
Artiwell Universal Tip Toe Bath Drain Stopper (Brushed Nickel)
This stopper and cover is designed to replace lift-and-turn, tip-toe, and trip lever drains without requiring the removal of the old drain. It uses a drop-in installation method that eliminates the need for plumber putty or professional tools. Constructed from solid brass with a tarnish-free brushed nickel finish, it completely covers the existing drain.
This is a practical choice for homeowners seeking a simple, tool-free installation to update their bathroom decor.
- Installs by dropping into the drain shoe without removing the old drain
- Made from high-quality solid brass with a brushed nickel finish
Artiwell Universal Tip Toe Bath Drain Stopper (Chrome Plated)
Similar to the brushed nickel variant, this chrome-plated stopper offers a drop-in installation that bypasses the need to remove the existing drain. It is designed to replace lift-and-turn, tip-toe, and trip lever mechanisms, allowing for easy clearing of hair and debris. The solid brass construction provides strength and a tarnish-free finish.
Buyers who prefer a bright chrome look to match their existing spout will find this a straightforward replacement option.
- Features a drop-in design that does not require removing the old drain
- Constructed from solid brass with a chrome-plated finish
Eastman Tip-Toe Bath Drain Assembly Kit
This kit features a push-and-pop design with a rubber seal, offering a different operation style from lift-turn mechanisms. It includes a high-quality zinc body that is corrosion-resistant, along with a 1-1/2 inch coarse thread, a 2-7/8 inch flange, and a drain washer. The sleek chrome finish blends with contemporary faucet decor.
This assembly is ideal for buyers who prefer the tactile feedback of a push-and-pop stopper and want a complete replacement kit with all necessary hardware.
- Utilizes a push-and-pop design with a rubber seal
- Includes a zinc body, 1-1/2 inch coarse thread, and drain washer
Ohtomber 2PCS Stainless Steel Bathtub Drain Strainer
This two-pack of drain strainers is designed to catch hair and debris without requiring tools for installation. The small but deep basket design features 0.08 inch holes that allow liquid to flow while blocking clogs. Made from stainless steel with a mirror surface, these strainers are dishwasher safe and easy to clean.
They fit drain holes between 1.75 and 2.79 inches, making them a versatile accessory for preventing clogs in bathtubs, sinks, and laundry areas.
- Fits drain holes between 1.75 and 2.79 inches in diameter
- Includes two stainless steel strainers with a mirror finish
Artiwell Tub Drain Linkage Assembly with Trip Lever
This full repair assembly is specifically designed for trip lever bath tub waste and overflow drains. It includes the linkage, a chrome trip lever face plate, and a strainer done cover with matching screws. The height is adjustable from 13-1/4 to 15-1/4 inches, fitting standard 14 to 16 inch drains, with an optional extension rod for taller drains.
This is the correct choice for buyers whose trip lever mechanism is broken and requires a complete internal linkage replacement.
- Includes linkage, face plate, and strainer cover for trip lever drains
- Adjustable height fits 14 to 16 inch standard trip lever drains
LEKEYE Tub Stopper with Strainer
This 2-in-1 device combines a pop-up plug with a basket filter to solve drainage and blockage issues simultaneously. When filling the tub, the stopper blocks drainage; when draining, the basket traps hair and debris. It is made from rustproof zinc alloy and brass, designed to remain shiny without corrosion.
It fits drain holes between 1-1/2 and 1-3/4 inches with a minimum depth of 1 inch, offering a compact solution for preventing clogs.
- Combines a pop-up plug and a basket filter in one unit
- Fits drain holes between 1-1/2 and 1-3/4 inches in diameter
Artiwell Tip-Toe Bathtub Drains Trim Set
This trim set includes a tip-toe stopper, a two-hole overflow faceplate, and a brass threaded adapter bushing. The adapter allows the drain to fit both 1-1/2 inch coarse and 1-3/8 inch fine thread drain shoe sizes. It is constructed from brass, zinc, and ABS, with a chrome finish available in seven color options.
The kit includes a rubber gasket and illustrated instructions for a quick do-it-yourself installation.
- Includes a brass adapter bushing for coarse and fine thread compatibility
- Features a two-hole overflow faceplate and tip-toe stopper
Head-to-Head Comparisons
EZ-FLO Lift-n-Turn vs Eastman Tip-Toe: Mechanism and Material
The EZ-FLO kit uses a lift-and-turn mechanism with a brass body, while the Eastman kit features a push-and-pop design with a zinc body. Both include a 1-1/2 inch coarse thread and a 2-7/8 inch flange, making them compatible with similar drain shoe sizes. The primary difference is the user interaction: the EZ-FLO requires lifting and turning, whereas the Eastman uses a push-and-pop action with a rubber seal.
Buyers should choose based on their preference for the stopper's operation style and the material they prefer, as brass and zinc offer different durability profiles.
Artiwell Drop-In Stopper vs Artiwell Trim Set: Installation Complexity
The Artiwell Brushed Nickel stopper is a drop-in design that covers the existing drain without requiring its removal. In contrast, the Artiwell Trim Set is a full replacement that includes a tip-toe stopper, overflow faceplate, and a brass adapter bushing. The drop-in option is simpler for those who want to update the look without plumbing work, while the trim set is for those replacing the entire drain assembly.
The trim set also offers flexibility with its adapter bushing for both coarse and fine threads, whereas the drop-in stopper relies on a universal fit over the existing drain.
Ohtomber Strainer vs LEKEYE Stopper: Functionality and Fit
The Ohtomber strainer is a passive accessory that sits in the drain to catch hair, fitting holes between 1.75 and 2.79 inches. The LEKEYE stopper is an active 2-in-1 device that functions as both a plug and a strainer, fitting holes between 1-1/2 and 1-3/4 inches.
The Ohtomber is a simple insert for clog prevention, while the LEKEYE replaces the stopper function entirely. If you need to stop water flow, the LEKEYE is the appropriate choice; if you only need to catch debris while keeping your existing stopper, the Ohtomber is the better fit.
Buying Guide
Identify Your Drain Mechanism
Before purchasing, determine if your tub uses a lift-and-turn, tip-toe, or trip lever mechanism. Lift-and-turn stoppers are operated by lifting and rotating, while tip-toe stoppers are operated by pressing down with your foot. Trip lever drains are operated by a lever on the overflow plate.
Matching the mechanism is critical for a functional replacement.
Measure the Drain Shoe
Measure the diameter of the drain shoe where the stopper sits. Most standard drains are 1-1/2 inches, but some are 1-3/8 inches. Check if the product supports both coarse and fine threads. For strainers, measure the opening of the drain hole to ensure the strainer fits securely without falling through.
Consider Installation Requirements
Some products, like drop-in stoppers, install without removing the old drain, saving time and effort. Others, like full assembly kits, require removing the old drain and using plumber putty or gaskets. If you are not comfortable with plumbing, a drop-in cover or a simple strainer may be a more manageable project than a full assembly replacement.
Match the Finish to Your Decor
Bathtub drains are visible fixtures, so the finish should complement your faucet and other bathroom hardware. Chrome is a standard choice that matches most modern fixtures, while brushed nickel offers a softer, contemporary look. Ensure the color of the new drain matches your existing spout to maintain a cohesive bathroom aesthetic.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I use a strainer with my existing stopper?
Yes, strainers like the Ohtomber model are designed to sit inside the drain opening alongside your existing stopper. They catch hair and debris to prevent clogs without replacing the stopper mechanism itself.
What is the difference between coarse and fine thread?
Coarse and fine threads refer to the screw pattern on the drain shoe. Coarse threads have wider spacing, while fine threads are tighter. Some adapters, like the one in the Artiwell Trim Set, allow compatibility with both types.
Do I need a plumber to install a bathtub drain?
It depends on the product. Drop-in stoppers and strainers can be installed by homeowners without tools. Full assembly kits may require basic plumbing skills to remove the old drain and secure the new one with a gasket.
How do I clean a bathtub drain strainer?
Most strainers are made from stainless steel or brass and can be cleaned by running water over them. Some models, like the Ohtomber strainer, are dishwasher safe, making it easy to remove trapped hair and debris regularly.
This article is part of our complete guide Home & Kitchen — browse all our comparisons and buying guides.
Last update on 2026-11-18 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API
