Home & Kitchen

Cake Pop Pans: 8 Silicone and Metal Options Compared for 2026

This post contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.

Product details come from Amazon listings. Compare the specifications that matter to you, and check the current price and availability on Amazon before buying. How we compare

Choosing the right cake pop pan depends on whether you prefer the flexibility of silicone or the durability of metal. Silicone molds are generally nonstick and easy to clean, while metal pans offer even heat distribution and a different texture for your treats.

This guide compares eight options, ranging from electric makers to multi-pack silicone trays. We look at cavity counts, included accessories, and material properties to help you find the tool that fits your baking style and party needs.

AT A GLANCE

Our 3 picks for different needs

Babycakes Cake Pop Maker & Mold, Bakes 12 Pops, Includes Stand & 50 Sticks
02Electric Baking

Babycakes Cake Pop Maker & Mold

The Babycakes maker is the only electric option, baking 12 pops automatically with a nonstick surface.

Read the details
Nordic Ware Formed Donut Hole and Cake Pop Pan, Aurora Green
04Durable Metal

Nordic Ware Formed Donut Hole and Cake Pop Pan

Amazon Prime

The Nordic Ware pan is a two-piece aluminum set made in the USA, offering a sturdy alternative to silicone.

Read the details
Silicone Cake Pop Molds, 20 Cavity Lollipop Molds with 100pcs Cake Pop Sticks 100pcs Candy Treat...
08Complete Packaging

SOV 20-Cavity Silicone Cake Pop Mold Kit

The SOV kit includes 100 sticks and 100 bags, providing ample packaging for the 20-cavity mold.

Read the details

All products, in detail

Ocmoiy Cake Pop Mold Set of 262 | Including 20 Cavities Silicone Cake Pop Molds, Cake Pop Sticks...
01

Ocmoiy 20-Cavity Silicone Cake Pop Mold Set

This Ocmoiy set includes a 20-cavity silicone mold, 60 sticks, 100 wrappers, and 100 silver ties. The mold is made of food-grade, BPA-free silicone and produces 1.5-inch diameter pops. It withstands temperatures from -40°F to 446°F, making it safe for ovens, freezers, dishwashers, and microwaves.

A decorating pen with four tips is included for adding details. This kit is ideal for bakers who want a complete packaging and decorating solution in one purchase.

  • Includes 60 sticks, 100 wrappers, and 100 silver ties
  • Made of food-grade, BPA-free silicone
Babycakes Cake Pop Maker & Mold, Bakes 12 Pops, Includes Stand & 50 Sticks
02Electric Baking

Babycakes Cake Pop Maker & Mold

The Babycakes maker is an electric appliance that bakes 12 round, 1.25-inch cake pops. It features a nonstick surface, power indicator light, and non-skid feet. The kit includes a decorating stand that doubles as a cooling rack, a dipping fork, and 50 six-inch sticks. This option is suited for bakers who prefer a countertop appliance that handles the heating process automatically, offering a hands-off baking experience for parties and holidays.

  • Electric maker bakes 12 cake pops at a time
  • Includes a stand, dipping fork, and 50 sticks
Tosnail 2 Pack of 20-Cavity Silicone Cake Pop Mold - Great for Hard Candy, Lollipop and Party...
03

Tosnail 2-Pack 20-Cavity Silicone Cake Pop Mold

This Tosnail pack contains two 20-cavity silicone molds, totaling 40 cavities. Each mold measures 9 inches by 7 inches by 2 inches, with 1.5-inch diameter cavities. The premium food-grade silicone is free of BPA, PVC, and phthalates. The molds are freezer and dishwasher safe, with a heat tolerance up to 450°F.

This double-pack is useful for bakers who need to produce larger batches or want a backup mold while one is in the oven or cleaning.

  • Pack of 2 molds for a total of 40 cavities
  • Free of BPA, PVC, and phthalates
Nordic Ware Formed Donut Hole and Cake Pop Pan, Aurora Green
04Durable Metal

Nordic Ware Formed Donut Hole and Cake Pop Pan

Amazon Prime

The Nordic Ware pan is a two-piece aluminum set with interlocking halves. It makes 12 items at a time, each 1.6 inches in diameter. The formed aluminum conducts heat evenly and features a premium nonstick interior. The set includes 24 cake pop sticks. This pan is made in the USA and is designed for bakers who want a durable metal option that can also be used for donut holes, offering a different texture and finish than silicone.

  • Two-piece aluminum pan with interlocking halves
  • Made in the USA
Yomvzake Donut Hole Baking Pan Set of 2, Mini Cake Pop Round Sphere Baking Mold Semi Sphere Tray...
05

Yomvzake 2-Pack Donut Hole Baking Pan

This Yomvzake set includes two 12-cup carbon steel pans. Each cavity is 1.75 inches in diameter, and the pans measure 10.2 inches by 7.75 inches by 1 inch. The heavy-duty carbon steel is rust-resistant and sturdy. The rounded bottom design is suitable for mince pies, tarts, and cake pops.

Greasing or spraying the pan is recommended for long-lasting service. This is a good choice for bakers who prefer a traditional metal tin for a variety of small baked goods.

  • Made of heavy-duty carbon steel
  • Each cavity is 1.75 inches in diameter
AKINGSHOP 20-Cavity Silicone Cake Pop Mold Set With Lollipop Sticks, Treat Bags, Twist Ties - For...
06

AKINGSHOP 20-Cavity Silicone Cake Pop Mold Set

The AKINGSHOP set features a 20-cavity silicone mold designed for cake pops, lollipops, hard candy, and chocolate. The listing highlights the mold's toughness and reusability, noting it is hard to deform. It is sold with lollipop sticks, treat bags, and twist ties. This kit is suitable for bakers who want a flexible silicone option for a variety of confections, with the added convenience of packaging supplies included in the box.

  • 20-cavity silicone mold
  • Includes sticks, treat bags, and twist ties
Rbenxia Silicone Cake Mold 20-cavity Half Circle Lollipop Party Cupcake Baking Mold Cake Pop Stick...
07

Rbenxia 20-Cavity Half Circle Silicone Mold

This Rbenxia mold is a 20-cavity half-circle tray made of food-grade silicone. It measures 9 inches by 7.3 inches, with 1.6-inch diameter circles. The kit includes 25 sticks that are 2.8 inches long. The nonstick surface allows for easy release after cooling for 10 to 15 minutes.

This option is good for bakers who want a simple, durable silicone tray for creating cake pops or lollipops, with a focus on the mold's flexibility and ease of use.

  • 20-cavity half-circle design
  • Includes 25 sticks
Silicone Cake Pop Molds, 20 Cavity Lollipop Molds with 100pcs Cake Pop Sticks 100pcs Candy Treat...
08Complete Packaging

SOV 20-Cavity Silicone Cake Pop Mold Kit

The SOV kit includes a 20-cavity silicone mold, 100 sticks, 100 candy treat bags, and 100 gold ties. The mold is made of 100% pure food-grade silicone and is safe for temperatures from -40°F to 446°F. It is dishwasher safe and resistant to deformation. This set is ideal for bakers who want a large quantity of packaging supplies to match the 20 cavities, ensuring they have enough sticks and bags for multiple batches.

  • Includes 100 sticks, 100 bags, and 100 gold ties
  • Safe for temperatures from -40°F to 446°F

Head-to-Head Comparisons

Babycakes Electric Maker vs Ocmoiy Silicone Set

The Babycakes maker is an electric appliance that bakes 12 pops at a time, while the Ocmoiy set is a manual silicone mold with 20 cavities. The Babycakes option includes a stand and 50 sticks, focusing on the baking process. The Ocmoiy set includes 60 sticks, 100 wrappers, and a decorating pen, focusing on finishing and packaging.

If you want the machine to do the heating, choose Babycakes. If you prefer a flexible mold that you can use in your own oven and want more packaging supplies, the Ocmoiy set is a better fit.

Nordic Ware Aluminum Pan vs Tosnail Silicone Pack

The Nordic Ware pan is a two-piece aluminum set that makes 12 items, while the Tosnail pack includes two 20-cavity silicone molds for a total of 40 cavities. The Nordic Ware pan is made in the USA and features a premium nonstick interior. The Tosnail molds are made of food-grade silicone free of BPA, PVC, and phthalates.

The aluminum pan offers a sturdy, traditional baking experience, while the silicone pack offers higher capacity and flexibility. Choose Nordic Ware for durability and USA manufacturing, or Tosnail for higher volume and silicone convenience.

SOV Kit vs AKINGSHOP Set

Both the SOV and AKINGSHOP sets are 20-cavity silicone molds that include sticks, bags, and ties. The SOV kit includes 100 sticks, 100 bags, and 100 gold ties, and specifies a temperature range of -40°F to 446°F. The AKINGSHOP set includes sticks, treat bags, and twist ties, and highlights the mold's toughness and reusability.

The SOV kit provides a specific count of 100 for each accessory, while the AKINGSHOP listing does not specify the exact quantity of sticks or bags. If you need a large quantity of packaging, the SOV kit is a clear choice.

Buying Guide

Material Choice: Silicone vs Metal

Silicone molds are flexible, nonstick, and often dishwasher safe. They are easy to release cake pops from and can be used in ovens, freezers, and microwaves. Metal pans, like aluminum or carbon steel, conduct heat evenly and are durable. They may require greasing to prevent sticking.

Consider your preference for ease of release versus heat distribution when choosing a material. For more shaping options, see Food Sculpting Tools.

Cavity Count and Batch Size

Most silicone molds in this comparison have 20 cavities. The Babycakes maker has 12, and the Nordic Ware and Yomvzake pans have 12 each. If you are baking for a large party, a 20-cavity mold or a multi-pack like the Tosnail 2-pack will save time.

If you are baking for a small group, a 12-cavity pan is sufficient. Match the cavity count to the number of treats you need to make in one batch.

Included Accessories

Some kits include sticks, wrappers, and ties, while others include only the mold. The Ocmoiy and SOV kits include a large quantity of sticks and bags. The Babycakes maker includes a stand and dipping fork. If you already have sticks and bags, a mold-only option may be sufficient.

If you are new to cake pops, a complete kit with packaging supplies can save you from buying separate items. For storage, consider Toothpick Holders.

Temperature and Cleaning

Check the temperature range of your pan. Silicone molds often withstand temperatures from -40°F to 446°F or 450°F. Metal pans are generally oven safe but may have different limits. Most silicone molds are dishwasher safe, which makes cleanup easy. Metal pans may require hand washing or specific care to maintain the nonstick surface.

Ensure your pan is safe for your oven and cleaning method.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are silicone cake pop molds dishwasher safe?

Yes, most silicone molds in this comparison are dishwasher safe. The Ocmoiy, Tosnail, and SOV kits all list dishwasher safety as a feature. This makes cleanup quick and easy after baking. Always check the specific product listing for care instructions.

How many cake pops does each pan make?

The cavity count varies by product. The Babycakes maker and Nordic Ware pan make 12 pops each. The Ocmoiy, Tosnail, AKINGSHOP, Rbenxia, and SOV molds have 20 cavities each. The Yomvzake pan has 12 cups. Choose based on the batch size you need.

Do I need to grease the pan?

Silicone molds are nonstick and usually do not require greasing. Metal pans, like the Yomvzake carbon steel pan, may benefit from greasing or spraying to ensure easy release. Check the manufacturer's recommendations for your specific pan to maintain the nonstick surface.

Can I use these pans for other treats?

Yes, many of these pans are multipurpose. The Nordic Ware pan can make donut holes. The Yomvzake pan is suitable for mince pies, tarts, and brownies. The silicone molds can be used for lollipops, hard candy, and chocolate. This versatility makes them useful for various baking projects.

Last update on 2026-11-18 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Was this article helpful?

Thanks for your feedback!

Thanks — we'll work to improve this article.

Kylan Shields

Kylan Shields

Kylan Shields is the editorial byline of Tossions. Comparisons published under this name are compiled from Amazon listing data (specifications, customer ratings and availability), not from hands-on testing.