Choosing the right candle making scents depends on the aroma profile you want to achieve and the volume of oil you need for your projects. Whether you prefer warm, spiced notes or fresh, floral aromas, the concentration and bottle size of the oil will impact how many candles you can make from a single purchase.
This comparison looks at eight different fragrance oil collections and single oils. We examine the specific scents included, the bottle sizes, and the intended uses for each product to help you find the best fit for your DIY candle making, soap making, or diffuser needs.
Our 3 picks for different needs
Bakery Essential Oils Set
This set offers ten 5ml bottles of sweet, bakery-inspired aromas like Pumpkin Pie and Cinnamon Sugar Donut.
Read the details
MAYJAM Essential Oils Set
With twenty 5ml bottles, this collection provides a broad range of scents from Fresh Linen to Leather for beginners.
Read the details
Majestic Pure Lavender Essential Oil
This 4 fl oz bottle of 100% natural lavender oil is a versatile option for those who want a pure floral aroma.
Read the detailsAll products, in detail
P&J Fragrance Oil Autumn Set
This P&J collection offers six 10ml bottles of autumn-themed scents, including Brown Sugar, Apple, and Harvest Spice. The oils are highly concentrated and developed by IFRA certified master perfumers. Each bottle features an amber shade with a euro dropper cap for easy dispensing. This set is suitable for candle making, soap making, and diffuser applications.
It is a good choice for crafters who want a cohesive seasonal theme in a compact format.
- Includes 6 x 10ml bottles of autumn scents
- Formulated by IFRA certified master perfumers
Bakery Essential Oils Set
This set contains ten 5ml bottles of dessert-inspired fragrances such as Pumpkin Pie, Gingerbread, and Cinnamon Sugar Donut. The oils are described as highly concentrated and versatile for candle making, diffusers, and bath bombs. The packaging is designed as a gift set for bakers and crafters.
It provides a wide variety of sweet, bakery-style aromas for those who want to create cozy, dessert-like home scents.
- Includes 10 x 5ml bottles of bakery scents
- Features scents like Pumpkin Pie and Red Velvet Cake
P&J Trading Spice Set
The P&J Spice Set includes six 10ml bottles of warm, spiced aromas like Apple Cider, Cinnamon, and Coffee Cake. These oils are designed for candle making, especially with soy wax, and are also suitable for soap and diffuser use. The brand notes that the formulations are cruelty-free and phthalate-free.
This collection is ideal for buyers seeking a classic spice profile for fall or winter candle projects.
- Includes 6 x 10ml bottles of spice scents
- Oils are cruelty-free and phthalate-free
P&J Fragrance Oil Farmhouse Set
This P&J collection features six 10ml bottles of rustic, farmhouse-style scents including Old Books, Butterscotch, and Honey. The oils are highly concentrated and come in amber bottles with euro dropper caps. They are suitable for candle making, soap making, and other DIY applications. This set is a good fit for crafters who prefer warm, nostalgic, and cozy aromas for their home fragrance projects.
- Includes 6 x 10ml bottles of farmhouse scents
- Sourced and manufactured in the USA
Majestic Pure Lavender Essential Oil
This single 4 fl oz bottle of lavender essential oil is 100% natural and suitable for aromatherapy, candle making, and soap making. It comes in an amber glass bottle with a dropper to reduce light exposure. The oil is noted for its soft, floral aroma and ability to blend well with other essential oils like bergamot and cedarwood.
It is a versatile option for those who want a single, pure floral scent for their DIY projects.
- 4 fl oz bottle of 100% natural lavender oil
- Blends well with bergamot, cedarwood, and rosemary
MAYJAM Essential Oils Set
This MAYJAM set includes twenty 5ml bottles of diverse scents, ranging from Fresh Linen and Sea Breeze to Forest Pine and Leather. The oils are described as highly concentrated with long-lasting fragrances. The collection is designed for diffusers, candle making, and soap making. It offers a wide variety of hotel-inspired and seasonal scents, making it a good starter kit for beginners exploring different aroma profiles.
- Includes 20 x 5ml bottles of varied scents
- Features hotel-inspired scents like Fresh Linen and Sea Breeze
MAYJAM Vanilla Essential Oil
This 30ml (1.01 fl oz) bottle of vanilla essential oil provides a warm, sweet, and comforting aroma. It is suitable for diffusers, candle making, and soap making. The oil is bottled in amber glass with a premium quality glass dropper for precise dispensing. It blends well with other scents like lavender, sandalwood, and cinnamon.
This is a good choice for those who want a single, versatile sweet scent for their DIY projects.
- 30ml (1.01 fl oz) amber glass bottle
- Blends well with lavender, sandalwood, and cinnamon
Wtrcsv Essential Oils Set
This Wtrcsv set contains fifteen 5ml bottles of steam-distilled or cold-pressed essential oils. The collection includes globally sourced botanicals like Bergamot from Italy and Jasmine from Egypt. The oils are packaged in FrostProtect bottles to ensure stability for over 24 months. This set is ideal for those who want a wide variety of pure, chemical-free aromas for diffusers, skincare, and candle making.
- Includes 15 x 5ml bottles of steam-distilled oils
- Packaged in FrostProtect bottles for 24+ month stability
Head-to-Head Comparisons
P&J Autumn Set vs P&J Spice Set: Seasonal Profiles
Both the P&J Autumn Set and the P&J Spice Set offer six 10ml bottles of warm, cozy aromas. The Autumn Set includes scents like Brown Sugar, Apple, and Snickerdoodle, focusing on a more sweet and harvest-themed profile. The Spice Set features Apple Cider, Cinnamon, and Coffee Cake, leaning into a classic spiced and baked goods theme.
Both sets are developed by IFRA certified master perfumers and are suitable for soy wax candle making. Choose the Autumn Set if you prefer sweeter, dessert-like notes, or the Spice Set if you want traditional warm spices.
Bakery Set vs MAYJAM Set: Sweet vs Diverse
The Bakery Essential Oils Set and the MAYJAM Essential Oils Set both offer a large number of small bottles, but with different scent focuses. The Bakery Set includes ten 5ml bottles of dessert-inspired scents like Red Velvet Cake and Blueberry Muffin. The MAYJAM Set includes twenty 5ml bottles of a wider variety of scents, including Fresh Linen, Sea Breeze, and Leather.
If you are specifically looking for sweet, bakery-style aromas, the Bakery Set is a focused choice. If you want to explore a broader range of hotel-inspired and seasonal scents, the MAYJAM Set offers more variety.
Majestic Pure Lavender vs MAYJAM Vanilla: Single Oils
The Majestic Pure Lavender Essential Oil and the MAYJAM Vanilla Essential Oil are both single-scent options for DIY projects. The Lavender oil comes in a 4 fl oz bottle and is 100% natural, suitable for aromatherapy and blending. The Vanilla oil comes in a 30ml (1.01 fl oz) amber glass bottle and is described as a highly concentrated liquid derived from vanilla fruits.
The Lavender oil offers a larger volume and a floral profile, while the Vanilla oil offers a smaller volume and a sweet, warm profile. Choose based on whether you prefer a floral or sweet base scent and the volume you need.
Buying Guide
Fragrance Oil vs Essential Oil
Fragrance oils are often highly concentrated and designed for strong scent throw in candles, while essential oils are derived from plants and may have a softer aroma. Fragrance oils like the P&J and MAYJAM sets are often phthalate-free and cruelty-free. Essential oils like the Majestic Pure Lavender and Wtrcsv set are steam-distilled or cold-pressed.
Choose fragrance oils for maximum scent intensity in candles and essential oils for a more natural, plant-based profile.
Bottle Size and Yield
The size of the bottle determines how many candles you can make. Sets like the P&J Autumn Set and Spice Set offer 10ml bottles, which are good for small batches. The MAYJAM Set and Wtrcsv Set offer 5ml bottles, which are ideal for testing different scents.
The Majestic Pure Lavender oil comes in a 4 fl oz bottle, which is a larger volume for those who want to make many candles. Consider your project size when choosing a bottle size.
Scent Profile and Theme
Decide on the aroma profile you want to achieve. The Bakery Set offers sweet, dessert-like scents. The P&J Farmhouse Set offers rustic, cozy scents like Old Books and Honey. The MAYJAM Set offers a wide variety of hotel-inspired and seasonal scents. The Wtrcsv Set offers globally sourced botanicals.
Choose a set that matches the theme of your candles, whether it is cozy, fresh, or floral.
Compatibility with Wax
Most fragrance oils are designed to work with soy wax and paraffin wax. The P&J sets note that their oils work well with soy wax candle making. The MAYJAM and Wtrcsv sets are also suitable for candle making. Check the specific product listing to ensure the oil is compatible with the type of wax you are using.
Some oils may be better suited for specific wax types, so it is important to verify compatibility before purchasing.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are these oils safe for skin contact?
Some of the oils listed, such as the P&J sets and the Majestic Pure Lavender oil, are described as suitable for skin and personal care formulations. However, always check the specific product listing for safety information and perform a patch test before using any new oil on your skin.
Can I use these oils in diffusers?
Yes, most of the oils listed are suitable for use in diffusers. The P&J sets, MAYJAM sets, and Wtrcsv set are all described as suitable for diffuser applications. Essential oils like the Majestic Pure Lavender oil are also ideal for diffusers.
How many candles can I make from one bottle?
The number of candles you can make depends on the size of the bottle and the amount of oil you use per candle. A 10ml bottle is good for small batches, while a 4 fl oz bottle can make many more candles. Check the specific product listing for the bottle size and recommended usage rates.
Do these oils come in gift packaging?
Yes, several of the sets listed, including the P&J Autumn Set, Spice Set, and Farmhouse Set, as well as the MAYJAM and Wtrcsv sets, are described as coming in elegant gift boxes. This makes them a good choice for gifting to friends and family who enjoy DIY crafts.
This article is part of our complete guide Arts, Crafts & Sewing — browse all our comparisons and buying guides.
Last update on 2026-11-18 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API
