Choosing the right ceramics glaze depends on your firing method and desired finish. Kiln-fired glazes like Mayco and Sax offer durable, glossy results for traditional pottery, while air-dry glazes provide a protective seal for craft projects that do not require high heat.
This comparison covers eight options, ranging from multi-color kits for beginners to single-color specialty glazes for experienced potters. Whether you are painting bisque, sealing air-dry clay, or seeking unique crystal effects, these products offer distinct features to match your creative needs.
Our pick: Creative Hobbies Mayco Stroke & Coat Kit 1. The Creative Hobbies Mayco Stroke & Coat Kit 1 provides a comprehensive set of 12 low-fire glazes that are food safe and easy to apply to wet clay or bisque.
Our 3 picks for different needs
Creative Hobbies Mayco Stroke & Coat Kit 1
The Creative Hobbies Mayco Stroke & Coat Kit 1 provides a comprehensive set of 12 low-fire glazes that are food safe and easy to apply to wet clay or bisque.
Read the details
Aukney 100ML Air Dry Clay Glaze
The Aukney 100ML Air Dry Clay Glaze offers a waterproof, high-gloss finish that protects air-dry clay from cracking and scratches without requiring a kiln.
Read the details
Penguin Pottery Floating Blue 16 oz
Penguin Pottery Floating Blue is a 16-ounce mid-fire glaze that delivers a glossy, opaque blue finish with a watercolor effect for cone 5 and 6 firings.
Read the detailsAll products, in detail
Creative Hobbies Mayco Stroke & Coat Kit 1
This kit includes twelve 2-ounce squeeze bottles of Mayco Stroke and Coat glazes, which are low-fire cone 06 glazes. The set features colors like Blue Yonder, Moody Blue, and Tuxedo. These glazes are designed to be applied to wet clay or ceramic bisque and fire to a glossy finish.
The kit is AP Certified Non-Toxic and food safe, making it suitable for functional pottery. It includes a booklet on how to paint pottery, which helps new users understand the application process. This option is ideal for beginners who want a comprehensive color range in a single package.
- Includes 12 colors in 2-ounce squeeze bottles
- Low-fire cone 06 glazes that are food safe
Sax Crystal Magic Glazes Set of 12
Sax Crystal Magic Glazes come in 4-ounce jars and feature a unique crystal effect. The set includes assorted colors and designs in various transparencies, including transparent, semi-transparent, opaque, and semi-opaque. Tiny crystals in the glaze melt and move during firing, causing colors to bloom and produce different results with every application.
These glazes are AP certified and lead-free. They are well-suited for art classes, adult crafting groups, and anyone seeking unpredictable, artistic outcomes. The firing results are specified for cone 6, though the glazes may appear different before firing.
- 4-ounce jars with assorted crystal effects
- Fires at cone 6 with blooming colors
Aukney 100ML Air Dry Clay Glaze
This 100ml air dry clay varnish is designed to protect air-dry clay projects. It serves as a protective shield that prevents crazing and provides waterproof protection. The varnish dries to a transparent, high-gloss finish and is scratch-resistant. It is suitable for a variety of surfaces, including clay, ceramics, oil paintings, wood, and plaster.
The product is not suitable for food or dishwasher use. It requires a specific application process involving a white acrylic primer and color layers before the glaze is applied. This option is best for crafters working with air-dry clay who need a durable, glossy sealant.
- 100ml high-gloss varnish for air-dry clay
- Waterproof and scratch-resistant finish
Mayco Elements Glaze Set of 12
The Mayco Elements Glaze Set includes twelve 4-ounce jars of earth, wind, fire, and air-inspired glazes. These high-quality semi-opaque and opaque glazes are ideal for cone 06/05 firings, though they can be set in higher cone temperatures. The crystals in the glaze are easy to apply and spread out during firing to create a burst of color.
The set is non-toxic and made in the USA. These glazes can be used in combination with other glazes or as accents. This option is suitable for potters who want a cohesive, nature-inspired palette with reliable firing performance.
- 12 jars of 4-ounce earth-inspired glazes
- Semi-opaque and opaque finish for cone 06/05
Penguin Pottery Floating Blue 16 oz
Penguin Pottery Floating Blue is a 16-ounce mid-fire glaze formulated for cone 5 and 6. It features rich blue tones blended with lighter sky and navy shades, creating a dynamic, watercolor-like effect. The finish is glossy and opaque, providing solid, even color that fully covers the clay body.
The glaze includes subtle speckling and a thin, warm brown band near the rim. Penguin Pottery manufactures this product responsibly in the USA and offers a lifetime warranty. This single-color option is ideal for potters seeking a specific, high-quality blue finish for mid-fire kilns.
- 16-ounce mid-fire glaze for cone 5 and 6
- Glossy, opaque finish with watercolor effect
100ml Air Dry Clay Glaze Gloss
This 100ml air dry clay glaze is designed to protect clay surfaces from drying out, cracks, and scratches. It is watertight and fireproof, drying to a transparent, high-gloss finish. The product is specially designed for air-drying pottery clay and can be used on plaster, colored porcelain, pre-painted metal, wood, jewelry, and artificial flowers.
It provides a strong protective film for finished works. The glaze is not suitable for food utensils. This option is a practical choice for crafters who need a versatile sealant for various non-food surfaces.
- 100ml watertight and fireproof glaze
- Suitable for clay, wood, and jewelry
Creative Hobbies Mayco Underglaze Set of 10
This set includes ten 2-ounce jars of Mayco Underglaze in assorted colors. Underglazes are highly versatile and can be applied to wet clay, greenware, or cone 04 bisque. They fire from cone 04 to cone 6, though results may vary at cone 6. The set is AP Certified Non-Toxic and made in the USA.
It includes a free book on how to paint bisque. These underglazes serve equally well for students starting out or seasoned artists working on gallery pieces. This option is ideal for those who want to decorate clay before glazing.
- 10 jars of 2-ounce underglaze colors
- Fires from cone 04 to cone 6
Creative Hobbies Mayco Stroke & Coat Kit 3
Creative Hobbies Ceramic Glaze Kit 3 features twelve popular colors of Mayco Stroke & Coat glazes in 2-ounce squeeze bottles. This high-performance glaze is designed for one-fire decorating and glazing on bisque. The colors stay true from jar to fired finish, and the glazes are intermixable to achieve custom shades.
Applying one coat creates a translucent effect, while three coats provide rich, opaque coverage. The set is non-toxic and dinnerware safe. It includes a booklet on how to paint pottery. This kit is suitable for potters who want a convenient, no-thinning-required glazing system.
- 12 colors in 2-ounce squeeze bottles
- One-fire decorating on bisque
Head-to-Head Comparisons
Creative Hobbies Kit 1 vs Kit 3: Color Range and Application
Both Creative Hobbies kits feature Mayco Stroke & Coat glazes in 2-ounce squeeze bottles, but they offer different color palettes. Kit 1 includes colors like Blue Yonder, Moody Blue, and Tuxedo, while Kit 3 features a different set of 12 popular colors. Kit 1 is explicitly noted as food safe and conforming to ASTM D-4236, whereas Kit 3 is described as non-toxic and dinnerware safe.
Both kits include a booklet on how to paint pottery. Kit 1 is suitable for those who want a specific set of colors, while Kit 3 offers an alternative palette for those who already own Kit 1 or prefer different shades.
Aukney vs Generic 100ml Air Dry Glaze: Protection and Use
Both the Aukney 100ML Air Dry Clay Glaze and the 100ml Air Dry Clay Glaze Gloss are designed to protect air-dry clay. The Aukney product emphasizes preventing crazing and providing waterproof protection, with a specific application process involving a white acrylic primer. The generic 100ml glaze is described as watertight and fireproof, suitable for a wider range of surfaces including jewelry and artificial flowers.
Both products are not suitable for food use. The Aukney option may be preferred for those following a specific primer-based workflow, while the generic option offers broader surface compatibility.
Sax Crystal Magic vs Mayco Elements: Effect and Firing
Sax Crystal Magic Glazes and Mayco Elements Glaze Sets both offer 12-jar assortments, but they differ in effect and firing. Sax glazes feature tiny crystals that melt and move during firing, creating blooming colors and unique results for each application. They are specified for cone 6 firing.
Mayco Elements glazes are semi-opaque and opaque, inspired by earth elements, and are ideal for cone 06/05 firings, though they can be used at higher cones. Sax glazes are AP certified and lead-free, while Mayco Elements are non-toxic and made in the USA. Sax is better for unpredictable, artistic effects, while Mayco Elements offers more consistent, earth-toned coverage.
Buying Guide
Kiln Firing vs Air-Dry
Determine if your project requires a kiln. Kiln-fired glazes like Mayco and Sax are designed for high-heat firing and provide durable, glossy finishes. Air-dry glazes like the Aukney and generic 100ml options are for projects that do not require firing, offering a protective seal for air-dry clay.
Check the firing cone requirements for kiln glazes to ensure they match your kiln's capabilities.
Food Safety and Toxicity
If you are making functional pottery, verify that the glaze is food safe. Creative Hobbies Mayco Stroke & Coat Kit 1 is explicitly labeled as food safe and AP Certified Non-Toxic. Penguin Pottery Floating Blue is a glossy, opaque glaze formulated for mid-fire kilns at cone 5 and 6.
For non-functional art, ensure the glaze is non-toxic. Always check the specific product listing for safety certifications like ASTM D-4236 or AP certification.
Finish and Opacity
Consider the desired finish. Glossy glazes like Penguin Pottery Floating Blue and Mayco Stroke & Coat provide a shiny, smooth surface. Semi-opaque and opaque glazes like Mayco Elements offer solid color coverage. Translucent effects can be achieved with single coats of Stroke & Coat. Crystal glazes like Sax produce unique, blooming effects.
Choose based on whether you want a uniform color or a textured, artistic finish.
Color Palette and Versatility
Select a color palette that suits your project. Multi-color kits like Creative Hobbies and Mayco Elements offer a range of shades for various designs. Single-color options like Penguin Pottery Floating Blue are ideal for specific accents. Inter-mixable glazes allow for custom shades. Consider if you need a wide variety of colors or a specific hue.
Check if the glazes can be used in combination with other products.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I use air-dry glazes on kiln-fired pottery?
Air-dry glazes are designed for air-dry clay and may not withstand high kiln temperatures. Kiln-fired glazes are formulated for high heat. Check the specific product instructions to ensure compatibility with your firing method.
Are these glazes safe for food contact?
Some glazes are food safe, such as Creative Hobbies Mayco Stroke & Coat Kit 1. Others, like the air-dry glazes, are not suitable for food use. Always verify the food safety rating on the product listing.
What firing cone do these glazes require?
Mayco Stroke & Coat is a low-fire cone 06 glaze. Mayco Elements are ideal for cone 06/05. Sax Crystal Magic fires at cone 6. Penguin Pottery Floating Blue is for cone 5 and 6. Match the glaze cone to your kiln's firing range.
Do I need to thin these glazes before applying?
Creative Hobbies Mayco Stroke & Coat Kit 3 is described as a high-performance glaze that can be used right from the bottle with no thinning needed. Other glazes may require thinning depending on the desired opacity. Check the specific product instructions for application guidelines.
This article is part of our complete guide Arts, Crafts & Sewing — browse all our comparisons and buying guides.
Last update on 2026-11-18 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API
