Choosing the right cheese making supplies depends on whether you are starting from scratch or already have some tools. A complete kit provides the coagulants, acids, and measuring tools needed for your first batch, while individual components allow you to customize your setup based on the specific cheeses you want to make.
This comparison looks at eight products ranging from all-in-one starter kits to specialized rennet and bulk cheesecloth. By examining the contents of each kit and the specifications of the cloths, you can determine which combination of tools fits your kitchen space and your experience level.
Our 3 picks for different needs
Mozzarella and Ricotta Cheese Making Kit
This kit includes all necessary ingredients and tools like a thermometer and muslin to make 20 batches of mozzarella or ricotta.
Read the details
Easy Cheesemaking Set 5 Molds and Book
This set provides five professional plastic molds and a recipe book for shaping cheeses like paneer and quark.
Read the details
12Pcs Unbleached Cheese Cloths 20×20 Inch
This twelve-pack of unbleached cloths offers a large quantity of reusable Grade 100 cotton for frequent straining tasks.
Read the detailsAll products, in detail
6-Pack Beige Cheesecloth 20×20 Inch
This six-pack of beige cheesecloth is crafted from 100% unbleached cotton, offering a durable and reusable option for straining tasks. The cloths feature hemmed edges to prevent fraying and are machine washable, making them a sustainable choice for frequent kitchen use. They are suitable for pressing cheese, straining soups, and juicing, providing a versatile tool for various culinary preparations.
Buyers who need multiple cloths for simultaneous tasks or want a bulk supply of unbleached cotton should consider this pack.
- Made from 100% unbleached cotton with hemmed edges
- Includes six 20×20 inch cloths in a pack
Cotton Farm Grade 100 XL Cheese Cloth 36×36 Inch
This extra-large 36×36 inch cheesecloth is made from pre-washed, unbleached cotton with a dense Grade 100 weave. The tight 46×54 thread count allows for clean straining of liquids while keeping solids contained, which is useful for making yogurt, nut milk, or cheese. The edges are finished with overlock stitching to prevent unraveling during repeated washing.
This single large sheet is ideal for buyers who need a spacious surface for large batches or want to cut the cloth to custom sizes for specific molds.
- 36×36 inch size with Grade 100 weave
- Pre-washed and odor-free with overlock stitching
North Mountain Supply Liquid Calf Rennet 3 oz
North Mountain Supply offers a 3-ounce bottle of liquid calf rennet, an animal-derived coagulant produced in Italy. With a strength of 1:10,000, this rennet is designed for preparing cheeses with denominations of origin, including those with short, medium, or long seasoning periods. The liquid format allows for precise measurement, with a suggested usage of about 1/4 teaspoon per gallon of whole milk.
This product is suitable for experienced cheesemakers who prefer animal rennet for traditional cheese profiles.
- 3 fluid ounces of liquid calf rennet
- 1:10,000 strength produced in Italy
Easy Cheesemaking Set 5 Molds and Book
This starter kit from Country Trading Co. includes five cheese molds and a recipe book, providing the structural tools needed for draining and shaping cheese. The set features two square and three round molds made from BPA-free, food-safe plastic that is dishwasher safe. The included book offers recipes for ricotta, paneer, goat cheese, and quark, helping users navigate the process.
This kit is a good fit for buyers who already have their own coagulants and acids but need professional-grade molds to form their cheeses.
- Includes 2 square and 3 round BPA-free plastic molds
- Comes with a recipe book for various cheeses
10 Tablets Vegetable Cuajo Marschall 50
This package contains ten vegetable coagulant tablets, specifically the Marschall 50 variety, used for cheesemaking. Vegetable rennet is a plant-based alternative to animal rennet, making it suitable for vegetarian cheese production. The tablet format provides a convenient way to measure coagulant for smaller batches of milk.
Buyers looking for a vegetarian-friendly option for making mozzarella or other fresh cheeses will find this a necessary component for their kitchen supplies.
- Ten vegetable coagulant tablets
- Marschall 50 variety for plant-based coagulation
Mozzarella and Ricotta Cheese Making Kit
This comprehensive kit from New England Cheesemaking Supply Company includes all the ingredients and tools needed to make mozzarella and ricotta. It contains 3 ounces of citric acid, 3 ounces of cheese salt, 5 tablets of vegetable rennet, 1 yard of butter muslin, a thermometer, and a recipe booklet.
The kit is designed to produce 20 one-pound batches of cheese, making it a substantial starter for beginners. It is a complete solution for those who want to start cheesemaking without sourcing individual components.
- Includes citric acid, salt, rennet, muslin, and thermometer
- Ingredients sufficient for 20 one-pound batches
12Pcs Unbleached Cheese Cloths 20×20 Inch
This value pack includes twelve 20×20 inch unbleached cotton cheesecloths, offering a large quantity for frequent users. The cloths are made from 100% natural cotton with a Grade 100 weave, described as tight enough to strain out tiny bits for broths or nut milk. They are reusable and can be washed in the sink or machine, though the listing notes they may shrink slightly after first use.
This pack is ideal for households that use cheesecloth for multiple tasks like canning, juicing, and cheese pressing.
- Pack of twelve 20×20 inch cloths
- Grade 100 weave with 56×42 thread count
Mozzarella & Ricotta Cheese Making Kit 5 Piece
This five-piece DIY kit includes vegetable rennet, citric acid, cheese salt, a thermometer, and butter muslin, along with step-by-step instructions. The ingredients are described as gluten-free and non-GMO, and the use of vegetable rennet makes the process vegetarian-friendly. The included instructions for mozzarella take about half an hour, making it accessible for beginners.
This kit is a good gift option for friends or family interested in cultured foods or unique pastimes.
- Includes 5 rennet tablets, 4 oz citric acid, and 8 oz salt
- Vegetarian-friendly with gluten-free and non-GMO ingredients
Head-to-Head Comparisons
New England Kit vs 5-Piece DIY Kit: Ingredient Quantities
Both the New England Cheesemaking Supply Company kit and the 5-piece DIY kit are designed for making mozzarella and ricotta using vegetable rennet. The New England kit includes 3 ounces of citric acid and 3 ounces of cheese salt, and is stated to produce 20 one-pound batches.
The 5-piece kit includes 4 ounces of citric acid and 8 ounces of cheese salt, along with 5 rennet tablets. While both are beginner-friendly, the 5-piece kit offers larger quantities of acid and salt, which may last longer for frequent makers. The New England kit explicitly mentions the batch yield, helping buyers estimate how long the ingredients will last.
6-Pack vs 12-Pack Cheesecloth: Quantity and Weave
The 6-pack beige cheesecloth and the 12-pack unbleached cloths both offer 20×20 inch sheets made from unbleached cotton. The 6-pack features hemmed edges to prevent fraying and is machine washable. The 12-pack specifies a Grade 100 weave with a 56×42 thread count and 400GSM weight, and notes that the cloths may shrink slightly after first use.
If you need a larger quantity of cloths for simultaneous tasks or canning, the 12-pack provides more sheets. If you prefer a specific hemmed finish and a smaller initial investment, the 6-pack is a suitable option.
Liquid Calf Rennet vs Vegetable Tablets: Coagulant Type
The North Mountain Supply liquid calf rennet and the Marschall 50 vegetable tablets represent two different approaches to milk coagulation. The liquid rennet is animal-derived, produced in Italy, and has a 1:10,000 strength, which is often preferred for traditional cheeses with denominations of origin. The vegetable tablets are plant-based, making them suitable for vegetarian cheese making.
The choice between these two depends on your dietary preferences and the specific cheese recipe you are following. Animal rennet may offer different flavor profiles, while vegetable rennet is a necessary component for vegetarian diets.
Buying Guide
Choosing Between Kits and Individual Components
If you are new to cheesemaking, a complete kit like the New England or 5-piece DIY set is convenient because it includes all necessary ingredients and tools. However, if you already have a thermometer or cheesecloth, buying individual components like rennet or molds may be more efficient.
Consider what you already own before purchasing a full kit to avoid duplicating tools.
Understanding Rennet Types
Rennet is the coagulant that turns milk into curds. Animal rennet, such as the liquid calf rennet, is traditional and often used for aged cheeses. Vegetable rennet, available in tablet form, is a plant-based alternative suitable for vegetarian cheeses. Check your recipe to see which type of rennet is recommended, as they can affect the final texture and flavor of the cheese.
Selecting the Right Cheesecloth
Cheesecloth is used for straining whey and pressing curds. Look for unbleached cotton to avoid chemical residues. The weave density, such as Grade 100, determines how fine the straining will be. A tighter weave is better for clear broths or nut milk, while a looser weave may be sufficient for pressing cheese.
Consider the size of the cloth based on the size of your molds or strainers.
Considering Mold Shapes and Materials
Cheese molds help shape the curds and allow whey to drain. Plastic molds are easy to clean and dishwasher safe, as seen in the Easy Cheesemaking Set. The shape of the mold, whether square or round, affects the final presentation of the cheese. If you plan to make a variety of cheeses, a set with different sizes and shapes provides more flexibility than a single mold.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between animal and vegetable rennet?
Animal rennet is derived from the stomachs of young animals and is traditional for many cheeses. Vegetable rennet is plant-based and suitable for vegetarian diets. The choice depends on your dietary preferences and the specific cheese recipe you are following.
How many batches can I make with a starter kit?
The New England kit is stated to make 20 one-pound batches. The 5-piece kit includes larger quantities of acid and salt but does not specify a batch count. Check the product details for specific yield information.
Do I need a thermometer for cheesemaking?
Yes, a thermometer is essential for monitoring the temperature of the milk during the coagulation process. Both the New England and 5-piece kits include a thermometer, ensuring you have the right tool for accurate temperature control.
Can I reuse cheesecloth after washing?
Yes, both the 6-pack and 12-pack cheesecloths are described as reusable and machine washable. They are designed to withstand frequent use and washing, making them a sustainable option for regular cheesemaking and other straining tasks.
This article is part of our complete guide Home & Kitchen — browse all our comparisons and buying guides.
Last update on 2026-11-18 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API
