Pet Supplies

Dog Milk Replacers Compared: 8 Options for Newborn Puppies

This post contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.

Product details come from Amazon listings. Compare the specifications that matter to you, and check the current price and availability on Amazon before buying. How we compare

Choosing the right dog milk replacer depends on the age of your puppy and your feeding preferences. Powdered formulas require mixing but offer longer shelf life, while liquid options are ready to feed and more portable.

This comparison covers eight products, including PetAg Esbilac and PetLac powders, liquid Esbilac containers, and Manna Pro Nurse All multi-species formulas. Each option has distinct features regarding size, format, and intended use, helping you select the best fit for your specific situation.

Our pick: PetAg Esbilac Puppy Milk Replacer Powder 28 oz. The 28 oz Esbilac powder provides a substantial amount of formula for owners needing to feed multiple puppies over several days.

AT A GLANCE

Our 3 picks for different needs

Pet-Ag Esbilac Puppy Milk Replacer Powder - 28 oz | Powdered Puppy Formula with Prebiotics...
01Large Powder Supply

PetAg Esbilac Puppy Milk Replacer Powder 28 oz

The 28 oz Esbilac powder provides a substantial amount of formula for owners needing to feed multiple puppies over several days.

Read the details
PetAg Esbilac Puppy Milk Replacer Liquid - 16 oz, Pack of 3 - Resealable, Ready-to-Feed Formula with...
06Portable Liquid Feeding

PetAg Esbilac Puppy Milk Replacer Liquid 16 oz Pack of 3

The pack of three liquid Esbilac containers offers a ready-to-feed, resealable option that is convenient for travel or on-the-go care.

Read the details
Manna Pro Nurse All Multi-Species Milk Replacer with Opti-Gut, 8 lb Bag | All-Milk Protein Formula...
07Multi-Species Bulk Feeding

Manna Pro Nurse All Multi-Species Milk Replacer 8 lb

Amazon Prime

The 8 lb Manna Pro Nurse All bag is a large-format option suitable for owners or breeders feeding multiple young animals of different species.

Read the details

All products, in detail

Pet-Ag Esbilac Puppy Milk Replacer Powder - 28 oz | Powdered Puppy Formula with Prebiotics...
01Large Powder Supply

PetAg Esbilac Puppy Milk Replacer Powder 28 oz

This large 28 oz powder is designed for puppies from newborn to six weeks old. It includes prebiotics, probiotics, and a special fiber blend to support digestion and immunity. The formula is described as highly palatable and easy to mix with warm water. It is a suitable choice for owners needing a substantial supply for multiple feedings over several days, as the reconstituted liquid must be refrigerated and consumed within 24 hours.

  • 28 oz powder size
  • Includes prebiotics and probiotics
Pet-Ag PetLac Powder for Puppies - 10.5 oz - Puppy Milk Replacement Powder Puppies Newborn to Six...
02

PetAg PetLac Powder for Puppies 10.5 oz

PetLac is a smaller 10.5 oz powder option for puppies from newborn to six weeks. It provides vitamins, minerals, and amino acids for growth and development. The powder can be refrigerated for up to three months or frozen for six months, offering flexibility for storage.

It is a compact choice for owners who prefer a smaller initial commitment or need a formula for a single puppy.

  • 10.5 oz powder size
  • Unopened powder can be frozen for up to 6 months
Pet-Ag Esbilac Puppy Milk Replacer Powder - 12 oz | Powdered Puppy Formula with Prebiotics...
03

PetAg Esbilac Puppy Milk Replacer Powder 12 oz

This 12 oz version of the Esbilac powder offers the same nutritional profile as the larger 28 oz can, including prebiotics, probiotics, and a special fiber blend. It is formulated for puppies from newborn to six weeks old. The smaller size is convenient for owners who want to try the formula before committing to a larger can or for those with a single puppy who will not consume a large quantity quickly.

  • 12 oz powder size
  • Formulated with a special fiber blend
PetAg Esbilac Healthy Development - 14 oz - Great Tasting Nutritional Supplement for Dogs and...
04

PetAg Esbilac Healthy Development 14 oz

Unlike the standard milk replacers, this 14 oz powder is a nutritional supplement for dogs weaning to six years old. It contains DHA and Vitamin E to support cognitive development and Omega 6 fatty acids for skin and coat health. It is designed to support the transition to solid foods for weaning puppies.

This product is not a complete milk replacement for newborns but a supplement for growing dogs.

  • Supplement for weaning to 6 years
  • Contains DHA and Omega 6 fatty acids
Manna Pro Nurse All Multi-Species Milk Replacer, 3.5 lb Bag | Complete Nutrition Milk Replacer, For...
05

Manna Pro Nurse All Multi-Species Milk Replacer 3.5 lb

Amazon Prime

This 3.5 lb bag is a multi-species milk replacer suitable for puppies, kittens, calves, and other young animals. It contains 24% protein and 24% fat, along with Opti-Gut probiotics. The all-milk protein formula is designed for quick and convenient preparation. It is a versatile option for owners who may need to feed different types of young animals or who prefer a larger bag size for bulk feeding.

  • 3.5 lb bag size
  • Contains 24% protein and 24% fat
PetAg Esbilac Puppy Milk Replacer Liquid - 16 oz, Pack of 3 - Resealable, Ready-to-Feed Formula with...
06Portable Liquid Feeding

PetAg Esbilac Puppy Milk Replacer Liquid 16 oz Pack of 3

This pack of three 16 oz liquid containers offers a ready-to-feed formula for newborn puppies to one year old. The Tetra Pak containers are resealable and portable, making them convenient for travel or on-the-go feeding. Once opened, the liquid must be refrigerated and discarded after 72 hours.

This format eliminates the need for mixing and measuring, providing a consistent nutritional dose.

  • Pack of three 16 oz liquid containers
  • Resealable Tetra Pak packaging
Manna Pro Nurse All Multi-Species Milk Replacer with Opti-Gut, 8 lb Bag | All-Milk Protein Formula...
07Multi-Species Bulk Feeding

Manna Pro Nurse All Multi-Species Milk Replacer 8 lb

Amazon Prime

The 8 lb bag of Nurse All is a large-format multi-species milk replacer with Opti-Gut probiotics. It is designed to provide consistent nutrition from the second day of life through weaning. The all-milk protein formula supports muscle development and overall growth. This size is ideal for breeders or owners with multiple litters who need a high-volume supply of a fast-mixing formula.

  • 8 lb bag size
  • Designed for use from day 2 through weaning
PetAg Esbilac Puppy Milk Replacer Liquid - 16 oz | Resealable, Ready-to-Feed Formula with Vitamins...
08

PetAg Esbilac Puppy Milk Replacer Liquid 16 oz

This single 16 oz liquid container is a ready-to-feed formula for newborn puppies to one year old. It is packaged in a resealable Tetra Pak that is portable and easy to store. The formula is highly palatable and formulated with a special fiber blend for easy digestion.

It is a convenient option for owners who need a small quantity of liquid formula without the commitment of a multi-pack.

  • Single 16 oz liquid container
  • Ready-to-feed with no mixing required

Head-to-Head Comparisons

PetAg Esbilac 28 oz vs 12 oz Powder

Both the 28 oz and 12 oz PetAg Esbilac powders offer the same nutritional profile, including prebiotics, probiotics, and a special fiber blend. The primary difference is the quantity of powder provided. The 28 oz can is a larger supply, which may be more economical per ounce for owners with multiple puppies or a longer feeding period.

The 12 oz can is a smaller commitment, suitable for a single puppy or for owners who want to try the formula before buying a larger size. Both require mixing with warm water and must be refrigerated after reconstitution.

PetAg Esbilac Liquid Pack of 3 vs Single

The PetAg Esbilac liquid formula is available in a pack of three 16 oz containers or as a single 16 oz container. Both are ready-to-feed, resealable Tetra Paks that do not require mixing. The pack of three provides a larger supply, which is convenient for owners who need to feed multiple times a day or have multiple puppies.

The single container is a smaller option for those who need a limited quantity or want to try the liquid format. Both must be refrigerated once opened and discarded after 72 hours.

Manna Pro Nurse All 3.5 lb vs 8 lb Bag

The Manna Pro Nurse All multi-species milk replacer is available in 3.5 lb and 8 lb bag sizes. Both contain 24% protein and 24% fat, along with Opti-Gut probiotics. The 3.5 lb bag is a smaller option, suitable for owners with a single litter or who prefer to buy in smaller quantities.

The 8 lb bag is a larger supply, which may be more practical for breeders or owners with multiple litters. Both are designed for quick and convenient preparation and are suitable for a variety of young animal species.

Buying Guide

Powder vs Liquid Format

Powdered milk replacers require mixing with warm water and must be refrigerated after reconstitution, typically for 24 to 72 hours depending on the brand. Liquid formulas are ready to feed and come in resealable containers, making them more portable and convenient for on-the-go feeding. Choose powder if you prefer to mix your own formula and have reliable refrigeration.

Choose liquid if you need a convenient, no-mix option for travel or busy schedules.

Puppy Age and Weaning

Most milk replacers are formulated for puppies from newborn to six weeks old. Some products, like PetAg Esbilac Healthy Development, are supplements for weaning puppies to six years old, supporting the transition to solid foods. Check the label to ensure the product is appropriate for your puppy's age.

Newborns require a complete milk replacement, while weaning puppies may benefit from a supplement that supports the transition to solid foods.

Multi-Species vs Dog-Specific

Some milk replacers, like Manna Pro Nurse All, are formulated for multiple species including puppies, kittens, calves, and goats. Dog-specific formulas, like PetAg Esbilac, are tailored to the nutritional needs of puppies. If you are only feeding puppies, a dog-specific formula may be more appropriate.

If you are caring for multiple types of young animals, a multi-species formula offers versatility and convenience.

Storage and Shelf Life

Unopened powder can often be stored for several months, with some brands allowing freezing for extended storage. Once mixed, powdered formulas must be refrigerated and consumed within a specific timeframe, usually 24 to 72 hours. Liquid formulas in resealable containers must also be refrigerated once opened and discarded after 72 hours.

Plan your feeding schedule and storage capacity accordingly to ensure freshness and safety.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I use multi-species milk replacer for my puppy?

Yes, multi-species milk replacers like Manna Pro Nurse All are formulated to provide complete nutrition for puppies and other young animals. They contain balanced protein, fat, and probiotics to support healthy growth and development in a variety of species.

How long does mixed milk replacer last?

Once mixed, powdered milk replacers must be refrigerated and typically need to be consumed within 24 to 72 hours, depending on the brand. Liquid formulas in resealable containers must also be refrigerated once opened and discarded after 72 hours.

Is Esbilac Healthy Development a milk replacer?

No, PetAg Esbilac Healthy Development is a nutritional supplement for dogs weaning to six years old. It supports growth and development with high-quality protein, DHA, and Omega 6 fatty acids, but it is not a complete milk replacement for newborn puppies.

Do I need to mix liquid milk replacer?

No, liquid milk replacers like PetAg Esbilac Liquid are ready to feed. You simply shake gently before use and warm to room or body temperature. This eliminates the need for mixing and measuring, making it a convenient option for busy owners.

Last update on 2026-11-18 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Was this article helpful?

Thanks for your feedback!

Thanks — we'll work to improve this article.

Kylan Shields

Kylan Shields

Kylan Shields is the editorial byline of Tossions. Comparisons published under this name are compiled from Amazon listing data (specifications, customer ratings and availability), not from hands-on testing.