Choosing the right dog training pad tray depends on your pet's size, the type of pad you use, and your cleaning preferences. Whether you prefer the convenience of disposable pads or the sustainability of reusable turf, the holder you select plays a crucial role in preventing leaks and keeping your floors clean.
This comparison examines eight listed options, ranging from rigid plastic trays to flexible silicone mats and artificial grass systems. By understanding the specific dimensions, materials, and structural features of each product, you can select a solution that fits your home environment and your puppy's training needs effectively.
Our 3 picks for different needs
Silicone Dog Puppy Pad Holder 24×24
This silicone holder features raised edges and a textured pattern for airflow, making it a stable and portable option for standard 24-inch pads.
Read the details
PETMAKER Artificial Grass Puppy Pee Pad 20×25
The four-layer artificial turf system offers a washable alternative to disposable pads, helping small pets learn to relieve themselves on grass.
Read the details
Smart Paws Small Puppy Dog Toilet Tray
Designed for small puppies like Yorkshire terriers, this split-design tray allows for easy cleaning and fits specific small pad sizes.
Read the detailsAll products, in detail
IRIS USA Secure Pee Pad Holder
This rigid plastic tray is designed for regular-sized dogs, specifically fitting 22-inch by 22-inch pads. It features a smooth, non-porous surface that allows for quick wiping without harsh cleaners. The design includes stable, slip-resistant footing to help pets move confidently during training sessions. It is a practical choice for owners who need a durable, easy-to-clean base for standard disposable pads in a crate or floor setup.
- Fits 22"x22" pads or larger
- Dimensions: 22.75"L x 23.00"W x 1.38"H
Glad for Pets Puppy Potty Training Pad Holder
The Glad tray is engineered to secure disposable pads in place, preventing pets from moving or shredding them. It features raised edges for additional leak protection, which helps keep floors cleaner during training. The holder is compatible with specific Glad pad sizes, including 23-inch by 23-inch and 17.5-inch by 23.5-inch options.
It is made with 30% post-consumer recycled materials, offering a structured solution for owners using compatible disposable pads.
- Fits Glad 23"x23" or 17.5"x23.5" pads
- Made with 30% Post Consumer Recycled Materials
Silicone Dog Puppy Pad Holder 24×24
This flexible silicone holder is crafted for 24-inch by 24-inch training pads and features a heavy-duty construction that stays firmly in place. It includes raised edges to prevent spills and a textured pattern that boosts airflow beneath the pad for quicker absorption. The waterproof surface is easy to rinse or wipe clean.
Its portable design allows it to be rolled up for storage, making it a versatile option for travel or multi-purpose use as a feeding mat.
- Fits 24×24-inch training pads
- Made from non-toxic, pet-friendly silicone
PETMAKER Artificial Grass Puppy Pee Pad 20×25
This reusable system uses artificial turf to simulate outdoor grass, helping enforce potty training habits. It features a four-layer system including an odor-resistant cloth mat and a plastic drainage insert that directs liquid into a durable collection holder. The dimensions are 26.18 inches by 20.66 inches, suitable for small-sized pets.
Cleaning is straightforward, requiring only a rinse with soapy water. It is a good fit for owners who want a washable alternative to disposable pads.
- Four-layer system with drainage insert
- Dimensions: 26.18"L x 20.66"W x 1.57"H
Silicone Dog Pee Pad Holder 24×24
Designed for 24-inch by 24-inch pads, this silicone tray features a snug border to catch spills and a height raised edge design to contain leaks. It is made from non-porous food-grade silicone, which is easy to wipe or rinse and does not absorb odors. The textured bottom provides a non-slip base for stability during use.
Like other silicone options, it can be rolled up for portability and used as a feeding or desk mat, offering flexibility for various home setups.
- Fits 24×24 in pee pads
- Made of non-porous food-grade silicone
PETMAKER Artificial Grass Puppy Pee Pad 16×20
This smaller artificial turf pad is designed for small-sized pets, measuring 20 inches by 16 inches. It utilizes a three-layer system where the grass mat sits on a plastic drainage insert that empties into a collection holder. The materials include synthetic plastic for the grass mat and hard plastic for the tray and insert.
It is a compact, reusable option for apartment dwellers or owners of small breeds who need a sanitary indoor relief area that mimics outdoor grass.
- Three-layer system with drainage insert
- Dimensions: 20"L x 16"W x 1.25"H
Smart Paws Small Puppy Dog Toilet Tray
This tray is specifically sized for small puppies like poodles and Yorkshire terriers, measuring 55 cm by 45 cm. It features a mesh plate with a height of 1.5 cm to prevent pets from wetting their feet easily. The split design allows the upper and lower parts to be separated for convenient cleaning, as the mesh plate can be taken off and washed separately.
It is recommended for use with 40 cm by 50 cm pet pads, offering a structured solution for very small breeds.
- Size: 55 x 45 x 3.7 cm
- Split design for separate washing
IMMCUTE Pee Pad Holder 24×24
This soft silicone holder fits up to 24-inch by 24-inch square-shaped pads and includes 8 fixing clips for added stability. It is made from safe, food-grade silicone that is odorless and easy to clean with water or a damp towel. The high raised lip holds spills to keep floors clean, and the tray is lightweight and compact for travel.
It is a versatile option for owners who need a stable, leak-proof base that can also serve as a crate or food mat.
- Includes 8 fixing clips for stability
- Fits up to 24" x 24" square pads
Head-to-Head Comparisons
IRIS USA vs Glad: Rigid Plastic Trays
Both the IRIS USA and Glad trays are rigid plastic options designed to hold disposable pads securely. The IRIS USA holder is sized for 22-inch by 22-inch pads or larger, featuring a smooth, non-porous surface for easy wiping. In contrast, the Glad tray is specifically compatible with Glad brand pads in 23-inch by 23-inch or 17.5-inch by 23.5-inch sizes.
The Glad option highlights the use of recycled materials, while the IRIS tray emphasizes versatility in fitting various crate sizes. If you use standard 22-inch pads, the IRIS tray is a direct fit, whereas the Glad tray is best if you are already committed to their specific pad dimensions.
Silicone Holders: Pee Pad Holder for Dogs vs Silicone Dog Pee Pad Holder for
These two silicone holders both fit 24-inch by 24-inch pads and feature raised edges for leak protection. The Pee Pad Holder for Dogs model includes a textured pattern designed to boost airflow beneath the pad, which may aid in absorption, and is described as heavy-duty.
The Silicone Dog Pee Pad Holder for model emphasizes a snug border and a non-porous food-grade silicone construction that resists odor absorption. Both are portable and can be rolled up for storage. The choice between them often comes down to the specific texture and airflow features of the Pee Pad Holder for Dogs versus the emphasized odor resistance of the Silicone Dog Pee Pad Holder for, as both serve the same primary function for 24-inch pads.
PETMAKER Grass Pads: 20×25 vs 16×20
PETMAKER offers two sizes of artificial grass pads, differing primarily in dimensions and layer count. The 20×25 model (Artificial Grass Puppy Pee Pad for) features a four-layer system including an odor-resistant cloth mat, measuring 26.18 inches by 20.66 inches. The 16×20 model (PETMAKER Artificial Grass Puppy Pee Pad) uses a three-layer system and measures 20 inches by 16 inches.
The larger pad is suitable for small-sized pets that need more surface area, while the smaller pad is a compact option for very small breeds. Both are reusable and require rinsing with soapy water, but the additional layer in the larger model may offer different odor management characteristics compared to the three-layer design.
Buying Guide
Match the Holder to Your Pad Size
The most critical factor is ensuring the tray fits your specific training pad. Rigid plastic trays like the IRIS USA are sized for 22-inch pads, while silicone options often fit 24-inch pads. If you use disposable pads, check the exact dimensions listed in the product description.
A holder that is too small will not contain the pad, while one that is too large may allow the pad to shift. For artificial grass systems, the pad size is fixed, so you must choose a size that matches your pet's body size.
Consider Material and Cleaning Ease
Silicone holders are generally waterproof and can be rinsed or wiped clean, making them easy to maintain for daily hygiene. Rigid plastic trays also offer smooth, non-porous surfaces that resist odors and allow for quick cleanup. Artificial grass pads require rinsing with soapy water to clean the turf and drainage layers.
If you prefer a low-maintenance option, silicone or plastic trays with disposable pads may be easier than washing reusable turf, which requires more thorough cleaning to remove odors.
Assess Leak Protection Features
Raised edges are a common feature in these trays, designed to contain spills and prevent urine from leaking onto your floors. Silicone trays often feature high raised lips that are flexible yet effective at holding liquid. Rigid plastic trays also have raised edges, but their fixed shape may not conform as closely to the pad as silicone does.
If you are concerned about leaks, look for descriptions that specifically mention leak-proof designs or high edges, as these features are intended to protect your flooring during training sessions.
Portability and Multi-Purpose Use
Silicone holders are often designed to be rolled up for compact storage and travel, making them a good choice if you need to move the training area around your home or take it on trips. They can also double as feeding mats or protective liners for other uses.
Rigid plastic trays are less portable but offer a stable, flat surface that is ideal for permanent setups in crates or specific corners of a room. Consider whether you need a flexible, portable solution or a stable, stationary base for your pet's training routine.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I use any brand of pad with these trays?
It depends on the tray type. Silicone and some plastic trays are designed to fit specific standard sizes, such as 24-inch or 22-inch pads. You should check the dimensions of your disposable pads against the holder's specifications to ensure a snug fit. Artificial grass pads are reusable and do not require disposable pads, but they are sized for specific pet sizes.
How do I clean an artificial grass pad?
Cleaning is typically done by rinsing the layers with soapy water. The PETMAKER grass pads, for example, can be rinsed to remove waste and odors. It is important to clean the drainage insert and collection holder as well to maintain hygiene. Regular cleaning helps prevent odor buildup and keeps the pad fresh for your pet.
Are silicone trays safe for puppies?
Yes, the silicone holders listed are described as made from non-toxic, pet-friendly, or food-grade silicone. These materials are generally safe for pets to stand on and are easy to clean. The non-porous nature of silicone also helps prevent the absorption of odors and bacteria, contributing to a hygienic training environment.
Which tray is best for small toy breeds?
The Smart Paws tray is specifically sized for small puppies like poodles and Yorkshire terriers, measuring 55 cm by 45 cm. The PETMAKER 16×20 grass pad is also a compact option for small-sized pets. For these breeds, a smaller, more structured tray can help prevent accidents by providing a defined area that is easier for them to recognize and use.
This article is part of our complete guide Pet Supplies — browse all our comparisons and buying guides.
Last update on 2026-11-21 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API
