Selecting the right auto carrier for your model railroad depends on your scale and the specific road names you wish to represent. The options in this comparison span both O-gauge and HO-scale formats, offering distinct choices for layout builders.
O-gauge models from MTH RailKing feature detailed bodies and operating couplers, while HO-scale models from Intermountain focus on bi-level rack designs with various railroad liveries. Each product serves a different scale and aesthetic preference, allowing you to match your rolling stock to your layout's theme.
Our pick: MTH RailKing Southern Pacific Auto Carrier. This MTH RailKing carrier includes two die-cast '55 Ford Thunderbirds and operates on O-27 curves.
Our 3 picks for different needs
MTH RailKing Southern Pacific Auto Carrier
This MTH RailKing carrier includes two die-cast '55 Ford Thunderbirds and operates on O-27 curves.
Read the details
MTH RailKing Chicago North Western Auto Carrier
This MTH RailKing carrier includes four die-cast '49 Coupe De Villes and operates on O-27 curves.
Read the details
Intermountain HO-Scale CP Rail Bi-Level Auto Rack
This Intermountain carrier is an 89-foot bi-level model with CP Rail road names for HO-scale layouts.
Read the detailsAll products, in detail
MTH RailKing Southern Pacific Auto Carrier
This O-gauge auto carrier features a durable ABS body with metal wheels and axles. It includes die-cast 4-wheel trucks and operating die-cast metal couplers for realistic handling. The unit carries two die-cast '55 Ford Thunderbirds and displays colorful paint schemes with decorative brake wheels. It is designed to operate on O-27 curves, making it suitable for layouts with tighter radii.
The Southern Pacific road number 515459 adds authentic detailing to the model.
- Carries two die-cast '55 Ford Thunderbirds
- Operates on O-27 curves
MTH RailKing Chicago North Western Auto Carrier
This O-gauge auto carrier features a durable ABS body with metal wheels and axles. It includes die-cast 4-wheel trucks and operating die-cast metal couplers for realistic handling. The unit carries four die-cast '49 Coupe De Villes and displays colorful paint schemes with decorative brake wheels.
It is designed to operate on O-27 curves, making it suitable for layouts with tighter radii. The Chicago North Western road number 46507 adds authentic detailing to the model.
- Carries four die-cast '49 Coupe De Villes
- Operates on O-27 curves
Intermountain HO-Scale CP Rail Bi-Level Auto Rack
This HO-scale bi-level auto rack carrier features a red color scheme with CP Rail and CPPA road names. It is an 89-foot model designed for HO-scale layouts. The bi-level design allows for the transport of multiple vehicles on two decks. The red paint scheme provides a distinct visual identity for the rolling stock.
This model is part of the Intermountain line of HO-scale freight cars.
- HO-scale 89-foot bi-level design
- CP Rail and CPPA road names
Intermountain HO-Scale BNSF Bi-Level Auto Rack
This HO-scale bi-level auto rack carrier features a brown color scheme with the BNSF Circle Cross logo. It is an 89-foot model designed for HO-scale layouts. The bi-level design allows for the transport of multiple vehicles on two decks. The brown paint scheme with the Circle Cross logo provides a distinct visual identity for the rolling stock.
This model is part of the Intermountain line of HO-scale freight cars.
- HO-scale 89-foot bi-level design
- BNSF Brown Circle Cross road name
Intermountain HO-Scale Norfolk Southern Bi-Level Auto Rack
This HO-scale bi-level auto rack carrier features a color scheme with the Norfolk Southern Horse logo. It is an 89-foot model designed for HO-scale layouts. The bi-level design allows for the transport of multiple vehicles on two decks. The Norfolk Southern road name provides a distinct visual identity for the rolling stock.
This model is part of the Intermountain line of HO-scale freight cars.
- HO-scale 89-foot bi-level design
- Norfolk Southern Horse road name
Intermountain HO-Scale Canadian National Bi-Level Auto Rack
This HO-scale bi-level auto rack carrier features a white color scheme with the Canadian National road name. It is an 89-foot model designed for HO-scale layouts. The bi-level design allows for the transport of multiple vehicles on two decks. The white paint scheme provides a distinct visual identity for the rolling stock.
This model is part of the Intermountain line of HO-scale freight cars.
- HO-scale 89-foot bi-level design
- Canadian National White road name
Intermountain HO-Scale Ferroviaria Mexicana Bi-Level Auto Rack
This HO-scale bi-level auto rack carrier features a color scheme with the Ferroviaria Mexicana TFM road name. It is an 89-foot model designed for HO-scale layouts. The bi-level design allows for the transport of multiple vehicles on two decks. The Ferroviaria Mexicana road name provides a distinct visual identity for the rolling stock.
This model is part of the Intermountain line of HO-scale freight cars.
- HO-scale 89-foot bi-level design
- Ferroviaria Mexicana TFM road name
Head-to-Head Comparisons
MTH Southern Pacific vs Chicago North Western: Vehicle Count and Road Name
Both MTH RailKing auto carriers are O-gauge models with durable ABS bodies and metal wheels. The Southern Pacific unit carries two die-cast '55 Ford Thunderbirds, while the Chicago North Western unit carries four die-cast '49 Coupe De Villes. Both models operate on O-27 curves and feature operating die-cast metal couplers.
The choice between them depends on whether you prefer the specific vehicle types or the road name of the railroad. The Southern Pacific model displays road number 515459, whereas the Chicago North Western model displays road number 46507.
Intermountain CP Rail vs BNSF: HO-Scale Livery Options
Both Intermountain auto carriers are HO-scale 89-foot bi-level models. The CP Rail version features a red color scheme with CPPA road names, while the BNSF version features a brown color scheme with the Circle Cross logo. Both models share the same bi-level design for transporting vehicles on two decks.
The primary difference is the railroad livery, which allows you to match the car to your specific layout theme. Selecting between these two depends on which railroad's aesthetic you wish to incorporate into your HO-scale layout.
Intermountain Norfolk Southern vs Canadian National: Road Name Distinction
Both Intermountain auto carriers are HO-scale 89-foot bi-level models. The Norfolk Southern version features the Horse logo, while the Canadian National version features a white color scheme. Both models share the same bi-level design for transporting vehicles on two decks. The primary difference is the railroad livery, which allows you to match the car to your specific layout theme.
Selecting between these two depends on which railroad's aesthetic you wish to incorporate into your HO-scale layout.
Buying Guide
Scale Compatibility
Ensure the auto carrier matches your layout's gauge. The MTH RailKing models are O-gauge, while the Intermountain models are HO-scale. Mixing scales is not possible, so verify your track gauge before purchasing. O-gauge models are larger and feature more detailed bodies, while HO-scale models are smaller and allow for denser layouts.
Check your existing rolling stock to ensure compatibility.
Curve Radius
Consider the minimum curve radius of your layout. The MTH RailKing auto carriers are designed to operate on O-27 curves. This specification is important for layouts with tighter turns. If your layout uses larger radii, these models will still operate correctly. For HO-scale models, check the manufacturer's specifications for curve compatibility to ensure smooth operation on your track plan.
Road Name and Livery
Select the road name that matches your layout's theme. The MTH models feature Southern Pacific and Chicago North Western liveries. The Intermountain models offer CP Rail, BNSF, Norfolk Southern, Canadian National, and Ferroviaria Mexicana liveries. Matching the livery to your locomotives and other rolling stock creates a cohesive visual appearance.
Consider the historical accuracy of the road names for your specific era of operation.
Vehicle Capacity and Type
Review the type and number of vehicles included with the carrier. The MTH Southern Pacific unit includes two '55 Ford Thunderbirds, while the MTH Chicago North Western unit includes four '49 Coupe De Villes. The Intermountain models are bi-level racks, which typically allow for the transport of multiple vehicles on two decks.
Choose the configuration that best fits your desired visual density and vehicle variety.
Frequently Asked Questions
What scale are the MTH RailKing auto carriers?
The MTH RailKing auto carriers are O-gauge models. They feature durable ABS bodies with metal wheels and axles. They are designed to operate on O-27 curves. This scale is larger than HO-scale and offers detailed features.
What scale are the Intermountain auto carriers?
The Intermountain auto carriers are HO-scale models. They are 89-foot bi-level auto rack carriers. They feature various railroad liveries, including CP Rail, BNSF, and Norfolk Southern. This scale is smaller than O-gauge.
Do the MTH auto carriers include die-cast vehicles?
Yes, the MTH auto carriers include die-cast vehicles. The Southern Pacific unit includes two '55 Ford Thunderbirds. The Chicago North Western unit includes four '49 Coupe De Villes. These vehicles are part of the operating model.
What is the minimum curve radius for the MTH models?
The MTH RailKing auto carriers operate on O-27 curves. This is the minimum curve radius specified for these models. They are designed to handle tighter turns on O-gauge layouts. Check your layout's track plan to ensure compatibility.
This article is part of our complete guide Toys & Games — browse all our comparisons and buying guides.
Last update on 2026-11-20 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API
