Choosing the right advent calendar depends on whether you prefer a simple visual countdown or an interactive experience with collectible items. The six options in this comparison range from flat picture-based calendars to fabric trees and toy-filled boxes, each offering a different way to build anticipation for the holiday season.
Some buyers may want a decorative piece that doubles as a countdown, while others may prefer a DIY approach where they fill the pockets themselves. By examining the materials, dimensions, and specific contents of each calendar, you can select the option that best fits your family's traditions and your home's decor style.
Our 3 picks for different needs
Generic Christmas Calendar Gnome Advent
This calendar includes 24 unique gnome dolls that serve as lasting festive decor for mantels and shelves.
Read the details
Pockets of Learning Merry Christmas Green Tree Advent Calendar
The Pockets of Learning calendar features a felt tree and 24 stuffed ornaments for a hands-on countdown.
Read the details
Polly Online Advent Calendar with Pull-Back Cars
This option provides 24 pull-back vehicles for young children who enjoy racing toys during the countdown.
Read the detailsAll products, in detail
Vermont Christmas Company Peaceful Night Advent Calendar
This flat advent calendar from Vermont Christmas Company features a glittered front and measures 14 inches by 11 inches. It is designed for a traditional countdown where you open a window each day in December to reveal a special holiday-themed picture. The listing explicitly notes that the calendar does not contain chocolate, making it a purely visual and decorative item.
It is well-suited for buyers who prefer a simple, picture-based tradition to build anticipation for Christmas without the need for filling pockets or managing small toys.
- Measures 14 inches by 11 inches with glitter highlights on the front.
- Does not contain chocolate and features a holiday picture behind each window.
Generic Christmas Calendar Gnome Advent
This 2026 advent calendar includes 24 small, lifelike gnome dolls, each with a unique appearance and expression. The calendar is described as sturdy and durable, allowing it to be placed in different positions throughout the Christmas period. It functions as both a countdown tool and a source of festive decor, as the gnomes can be displayed on mantels or shelves.
The design appeals to collectors and those who enjoy adding a touch of whimsical charm to their holiday rooms, with each gnome serving as a daily surprise.
- Includes 24 unique gnome dolls with distinct appearances and expressions.
- Constructed from high-quality materials designed to be sturdy and durable.
ASkinds Christmas 24 Day Advent Calendar with Pockets
This wall-hanging bag from ASkinds is made of polyester with a PE waterproof coating and measures 52 by 110 cm. It features 24 large pockets that provide ample space for larger small gifts or treats. The design is intended for buyers who want to fill the calendar themselves, allowing for complete control over the contents of each door.
It is a versatile option for families who prefer a DIY approach to the countdown, as the fabric construction supports a wide variety of personal gifts and decorations.
- Made of polyester with a PE waterproof coating.
- Measures 52 by 110 cm and features 24 individual pockets.
Vermont Christmas Company Woodland Holiday Advent Calendar
This Woodland Holiday Advent Calendar from Vermont Christmas Company measures 11 inches by 14 inches and features glitter on the front. It is themed around the poem 'Twas the Night Before Christmas,' with each of the 24 windows revealing a picture and the corresponding verse.
This specific design is ideal for families who want to combine the countdown with a literary tradition, allowing children to read the poem in segments throughout December. The compact size and classic theme make it a fitting addition to a traditional holiday display.
- Measures 11 inches by 14 inches with glitter on the front.
- Features 24 windows revealing pictures and verses from 'Twas the Night Before Christmas'.
Pockets of Learning Merry Christmas Green Tree Advent Calendar
This felt tree advent calendar from Pockets of Learning measures 14 inches wide by 30 inches high and hangs on a wooden dowel. It includes 24 stuffed cloth ornaments that children can attach to the tree each day. The design encourages fine motor skills and creativity as kids arrange the ornaments, making it an interactive fabric wall hanging.
It is a reusable heirloom piece that serves as both a countdown and a decorative element, with a top loop for easy display on a wall or door.
- Measures 14 inches wide by 30 inches high and hangs on a wooden dowel.
- Includes 24 stuffed cloth ornaments for a hands-on countdown activity.
Polly Online Advent Calendar with Pull-Back Cars
This advent calendar from Polly Online is designed for young vehicle enthusiasts and features 24 pull-back cars hidden behind doors. The set includes a variety of police cars, standard cars, and construction vehicles, each with expressive faces and vibrant designs. The pull-back action provides engaging playtime, allowing children to race the vehicles across floors.
The calendar box also serves as compact storage for the vehicles when not in use, making it a practical and entertaining gift for kids who enjoy toys.
- Includes 24 pull-back toy cars, including police and construction vehicles.
- The calendar box provides compact storage for the vehicles.
Head-to-Head Comparisons
Vermont Christmas Company Peaceful Night vs Woodland Holiday
The Peaceful Night model measures 14 inches by 11 inches and features a glittered front with holiday-themed pictures behind each window. The Woodland Holiday model measures 11 inches by 14 inches and is themed around the poem 'Twas the Night Before Christmas,' revealing a picture and verse for each day.
The Peaceful Night is a landscape-oriented design, while the Woodland Holiday is portrait-oriented. Buyers who prefer a general holiday theme may choose the Peaceful Night, while those who want to incorporate a specific poem into their tradition may prefer the Woodland Holiday.
Gnome Collectibles vs Pull-Back Cars
The Generic Gnome Advent Calendar and the Polly Online Pull-Back Car Calendar both include 24 items that serve as daily surprises. The gnome calendar features small, lifelike dolls with unique expressions that can be displayed as festive decor on mantels or shelves. The Polly Online calendar includes pull-back toy vehicles, such as police and construction cars, that provide active playtime for children.
The gnome calendar is better suited for collectors or those who want a decorative display, while the car calendar is ideal for young children who enjoy racing toys. Both options offer a tangible item to open each day, but the gnome dolls are static decor, whereas the cars are interactive toys.
ASkinds DIY Pockets vs Pockets of Learning Felt Tree
The ASkinds Advent Calendar and the Pockets of Learning Felt Tree both serve as wall-hanging countdowns, but they function differently. The ASkinds calendar is a fabric bag with 24 pockets that you fill yourself, allowing you to decide the contents of each door. It measures 52 by 110 cm and is made of polyester with a PE waterproof coating.
The Pockets of Learning calendar is a felt tree that comes with 24 stuffed cloth ornaments, which children attach to the tree each day. It measures 14 inches wide by 30 inches high. The ASkinds option is for buyers who want a DIY experience, while the Pockets of Learning option is for those who want a pre-filled, interactive activity.
Buying Guide
Consider the Countdown Style
Decide whether you want a visual countdown or an interactive one. Picture-based calendars like the Vermont Christmas Company options are simple and decorative, requiring no filling. Fabric trees and toy-filled calendars like the Pockets of Learning and Polly Online options provide a hands-on activity for children.
If you prefer to control the contents, a DIY pocket calendar like the ASkinds option is the best choice. Your choice should align with how your family likes to engage with the holiday tradition.
Check the Dimensions and Display
Measure the space where you plan to hang the calendar. The Vermont Christmas Company calendars are compact, measuring around 11 to 14 inches in each dimension. The Pockets of Learning felt tree is taller, measuring 30 inches high, and hangs on a wooden dowel. The ASkinds pocket calendar is a large bag measuring 52 by 110 cm.
Ensure the calendar fits your wall or door space and that the hanging mechanism, such as a top loop or dowel, is suitable for your display area.
Evaluate the Contents and Materials
Look at what is included in the calendar. Others, like the Gnome Advent Calendar, include collectible dolls, while the Polly Online calendar includes pull-back cars. The ASkinds calendar is empty and made of polyester with a waterproof coating. Consider the durability of the materials and whether the included items, such as stuffed ornaments or toy cars, are appropriate for the age of the intended user.
Match the Theme to Your Decor
Choose a calendar that complements your existing holiday decorations. The Woodland Holiday calendar features a classic poem theme, while the Peaceful Night calendar has a general holiday picture theme. The Gnome Advent Calendar adds a whimsical touch with its cute dolls, and the Pockets of Learning tree offers a traditional green tree look.
The Polly Online calendar features vibrant vehicle designs. Selecting a theme that matches your home's aesthetic will ensure the calendar serves as a cohesive part of your holiday display.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do these advent calendars contain chocolate?
The other options, such as the Gnome and Pull-Back Car calendars, include toys or dolls rather than food. The ASkinds calendar is empty and designed for you to fill with your own choice of treats or gifts.
Are these calendars reusable?
The Pockets of Learning felt tree is described as a reusable heirloom piece that can be enjoyed year after year. The ASkinds pocket calendar is also a fabric item that can be refilled. The other options, such as the picture-based calendars and toy-filled boxes, are typically used for a single season.
What is the best option for young children?
The Pockets of Learning felt tree encourages fine motor skills as children attach ornaments. The Polly Online calendar features pull-back cars that provide active playtime. These interactive options are well-suited for young children who enjoy hands-on activities during the countdown.
How do I display a wall-hanging advent calendar?
The Pockets of Learning calendar hangs on a wooden dowel with a top loop. The ASkinds calendar is a wall-hanging bag. You should ensure your wall or door can support the weight of the calendar and its contents, and that the hanging mechanism is secure.
This article is part of our complete guide Home & Kitchen — browse all our comparisons and buying guides.
Last update on 2026-11-21 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API
