Beauty & Personal Care

Insect Repelling Products: 7 Sawyer and Bug Off Options Compared

This post contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.

Product details come from Amazon listings. Compare the specifications that matter to you, and check the current price and availability on Amazon before buying. How we compare

Choosing the right insect repellent depends on your preferred active ingredient, application method, and whether you need to treat your gear. The seven products in this comparison include topical lotions and sprays for skin, as well as a specialized spray for clothing and tents.

Sawyer dominates the list with multiple Picaridin and DEET options, while Bug Off Me offers a plant-based alternative. Understanding the differences between these formulations will help you select the best protection for your specific outdoor activities.

AT A GLANCE

Our 3 picks for different needs

Sawyer Products SP657 Premium Permethrin Insect Repellent for Clothing, Gear & Tents, Trigger Spray...
03Gear and Clothing Treatment

Sawyer SP657 Premium Permethrin Insect Repellent Spray

Amazon Prime

Sawyer Permethrin spray bonds to fabric for up to 6 weeks, adding a durable layer of protection to shirts, pants, and tents.

Read the details
Sawyer Products SP520 Premium Family Insect Repellent Controlled Release, 20% DEET Lotion, 4-Ounce
05DEET-Based Skin Protection

Sawyer SP520 Premium Family Insect Repellent Lotion

Sawyer SP520 lotion uses encapsulated 20% DEET to provide up to 11 hours of protection against ticks and mosquitoes.

Read the details
Bug Off Me - Mosquito and Insect Repelling Body Spray Infused with Lemon Eucalyptus, Citronella...
06DEET-Free Family Spray

Bug Off Me Mosquito and Insect Repelling Body Spray

Bug Off Me offers a plant-based, DEET-free formula that is safe for children, adults, and pets.

Read the details

All products, in detail

Sawyer Products SP564 Premium Insect Repellent with 20% Picaridin, Lotion, 4-Ounce
01

Sawyer SP564 Premium Insect Repellent Lotion

Amazon Prime

This 4-ounce lotion uses 20% Picaridin to provide up to 12 hours of protection against mosquitoes and ticks. It is fragrance-free, non-greasy, and dries quickly without damaging plastics or synthetic coatings. The formula is safe for the whole family and suitable for various outdoor activities.

It is a good choice for buyers who prefer a lotion application over a spray for targeted coverage on skin.

  • Contains 20% Picaridin for up to 12 hours of protection against mosquitoes and ticks.
  • Fragrance-free and non-greasy lotion that is safe for use on clothing and gear.
Sawyer Products SP5432 Picaridin Insect Repellent Spray, 20%, Pump, 3-Ounce, (Pack of 2) (Packaging...
02

Sawyer SP5432 Picaridin Insect Repellent Spray (2-Pack)

Amazon Prime

This pack of two 3-ounce pump sprays offers a convenient way to stock up on 20% Picaridin repellent. The fragrance-free formula dries quickly and is safe for use on the whole family. It provides up to 12 hours of protection against mosquitoes and ticks. The pump mechanism allows for controlled application, making it suitable for both skin and gear.

This multi-pack is ideal for households or groups needing multiple bottles for extended trips.

  • Pack of two 3-ounce pump sprays containing 20% Picaridin.
  • Provides up to 12 hours of protection against mosquitoes and ticks.
Sale Sawyer Products SP657 Premium Permethrin Insect Repellent for Clothing, Gear & Tents, Trigger Spray...
03Gear and Clothing Treatment

Sawyer SP657 Premium Permethrin Insect Repellent Spray

Amazon Prime

This 24-ounce trigger spray is designed for clothing, gear, and tents rather than direct skin application. The Permethrin formula bonds to fabric fibers for up to 6 weeks or through 6 washings. It is effective against more than 55 kinds of insects, including ticks and mosquitoes.

This product adds a layer of protection to your outdoor kit, making it essential for campers and hikers who want to treat their gear.

  • Bonds to fabric for up to 6 weeks or through 6 washings.
  • Effective against more than 55 kinds of insects, including ticks and mosquitoes.
Sawyer Products SP544 Premium Insect Repellent with 20% Picaridin, Pump Spray, 4-Ounce
04

Sawyer SP544 Premium Insect Repellent Pump Spray

Amazon Prime

This 4-ounce pump spray features 20% Picaridin for long-lasting insect and tick repellency. It is non-greasy, fragrance-free, and odorless, making it comfortable to wear on the skin. The formula is safe for the whole family and dries quickly without damaging plastics or synthetic coatings. It is a versatile option for daily outdoor use, from backyard BBQs to camping trips.

  • 4-ounce pump spray with 20% Picaridin for up to 12 hours of protection.
  • Non-greasy and fragrance-free formula safe for skin and gear.
Sawyer Products SP520 Premium Family Insect Repellent Controlled Release, 20% DEET Lotion, 4-Ounce
05DEET-Based Skin Protection

Sawyer SP520 Premium Family Insect Repellent Lotion

This 4-ounce lotion uses 20% DEET encapsulated in a protein that dissolves slowly to release the active ingredient over time. It provides up to 11 hours of protection against ticks and mosquitoes. The formula is odorless, non-greasy, and perspiration-resistant. It is compatible with sunscreens, making it a practical choice for buyers who prefer DEET-based protection for its established efficacy.

  • Contains 20% DEET encapsulated in a protein for up to 11 hours of protection.
  • Odorless, non-greasy, and perspiration-resistant lotion compatible with sunscreens.
Bug Off Me - Mosquito and Insect Repelling Body Spray Infused with Lemon Eucalyptus, Citronella...
06DEET-Free Family Spray

Bug Off Me Mosquito and Insect Repelling Body Spray

This 8-ounce body spray is a DEET-free option powered by plant-based ingredients like Lemon Eucalyptus and Citronella. It is designed to be safe for children, adults, and pets. The formula includes Invis-O-Bond technology that creates a breathable barrier against UV rays and pollution. It is a good fit for buyers seeking a natural, eco-conscious repellent that also supports skin health.

  • DEET-free spray infused with Lemon Eucalyptus, Citronella, Rosemary, and Lemongrass.
  • Safe for children, adults, and pets; free from parabens, sulfates, and phthalates.
Sawyer Products SP874 Picaridin Insect Repellent Spray, 20% Picaridin, 4-Ounce, 1-Pack
07

Sawyer SP874 Picaridin Insect Repellent Spray

This 4-ounce spray contains 20% Picaridin and is designed for the whole family. It is non-greasy, fragrance-free, and odorless, drying quickly without damaging plastics or synthetic coatings. The formula provides up to 12 hours of protection against mosquitoes and ticks. It is a reliable choice for outdoor adventures, offering the same active ingredient profile as other Sawyer Picaridin products in a single-pack format.

  • 4-ounce spray with 20% Picaridin for up to 12 hours of protection.
  • Fragrance-free and non-greasy formula safe for skin and gear.

Head-to-Head Comparisons

Sawyer Picaridin Lotion vs. Pump Spray

Both the Sawyer SP564 lotion and the SP544 pump spray use 20% Picaridin and offer up to 12 hours of protection. The primary difference is the application method. The lotion is ideal for targeted application on exposed skin, while the pump spray allows for broader coverage.

Both are non-greasy and fragrance-free. If you prefer a controlled, liquid application, the lotion is a good fit. If you want to cover larger areas quickly, the pump spray is more efficient.

Sawyer DEET Lotion vs. Picaridin Lotion

The Sawyer SP520 uses 20% DEET, while the SP564 uses 20% Picaridin. The DEET formula is encapsulated in a protein to release slowly over up to 11 hours. The Picaridin formula is noted as being more effective at repelling biting flies than DEET. Both are lotions that are non-greasy and safe for the whole family.

Buyers who prefer the established efficacy of DEET may choose the SP520, while those who prefer Picaridin's fly-repelling properties may choose the SP564.

Sawyer Permethrin Spray vs. Bug Off Me Body Spray

These two products serve different purposes. The Sawyer SP657 is a Permethrin spray designed for clothing and gear, not for direct skin application. It bonds to fabric for up to 6 weeks. The Bug Off Me spray is a DEET-free body spray for skin, using plant-based ingredients.

You can use both together: treat your clothes with Permethrin and apply the Bug Off Me spray to your skin. This combination provides layered protection for your body and gear.

Buying Guide

Choosing Between Picaridin and DEET

Picaridin and DEET are both effective insect repellents. Picaridin is often preferred for its lack of odor and its ability to repel biting flies. DEET is a well-established ingredient with a long history of use. The Sawyer SP564 and SP544 use Picaridin, while the SP520 uses DEET.

Consider your sensitivity to odors and your preference for specific active ingredients when making your choice.

Treating Gear with Permethrin

Permethrin is not for skin application. It is designed to be sprayed on clothing, tents, and other gear. The Sawyer SP657 bonds to fabric fibers for up to 6 weeks or through 6 washings. This makes it a cost-effective way to add long-lasting protection to your outdoor kit.

Treat your shirts, pants, and socks before a trip to reduce the likelihood of tick bites.

DEET-Free Options for Sensitive Skin

If you prefer to avoid DEET, the Bug Off Me body spray is a good alternative. It uses plant-based ingredients like Lemon Eucalyptus and Citronella. It is free from parabens, sulfates, and phthalates. This option is suitable for sensitive skin and is safe for children, adults, and pets.

It provides a natural approach to insect repellency without synthetic chemicals.

Application Methods: Lotion vs. Spray

Lotions and sprays offer different application experiences. Lotions, like the Sawyer SP564 and SP520, are good for targeted application on exposed skin. Sprays, like the Sawyer SP544 and Bug Off Me, allow for quicker coverage of larger areas. Consider how you prefer to apply repellent and the size of the area you need to cover.

Both methods are effective when used as directed.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I use Permethrin on my skin?

No, the Sawyer SP657 Permethrin spray is designed for clothing, gear, and tents. It is not intended for direct application on skin. Use a topical repellent like Picaridin or DEET for skin protection.

How long does Sawyer Picaridin last?

The Sawyer Picaridin products provide up to 12 hours of protection against mosquitoes and ticks. They also provide up to 8 hours of protection against flies, gnats, and chiggers.

Is Bug Off Me safe for pets?

Yes, the Bug Off Me body spray is designed to be safe for children, adults, and pets. It is a DEET-free formula that uses plant-based ingredients.

Can I use repellent with sunscreen?

Yes, the Sawyer SP520 DEET lotion is compatible with sunscreens. You can apply sunscreen first, let it dry, and then apply the repellent. This ensures both products work effectively.

Last update on 2026-11-20 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Was this article helpful?

Thanks for your feedback!

Thanks — we'll work to improve this article.

Kylan Shields

Kylan Shields

Kylan Shields is the editorial byline of Tossions. Comparisons published under this name are compiled from Amazon listing data (specifications, customer ratings and availability), not from hands-on testing.