Choosing the right packaged anchovies depends on your preferred texture, packing medium, and intended use. Whether you seek the robust umami of traditional fillets or the mildness of white anchovies, the market offers distinct options.
This guide compares eight products, including fillets in olive oil, water-packed varieties, and a paste format. We examine sourcing origins, nutritional profiles, and packaging types to help you select the best fit for your recipes.
Our 3 picks for different needs
Ortiz Anchovies in Extra Virgin Olive Oil
Ortiz anchovies are wild-caught in Spain and matured in barrels for at least six months, offering a firm, buttery texture.
Read the details
Wild Planet Wild White Anchovies in Water
Wild Planet white anchovies in water provide 1045mg of EPA & DHA Omega-3s per serving, making them a nutrient-dense choice.
Read the details
Cento Anchovy Paste
Cento Anchovy Paste offers a spreadable format with sunflower oil and salt, suitable for quick addition to sauces.
Read the detailsAll products, in detail
Roland Foods Flat Fillets in Olive Oil
Roland Foods offers flat fillets of anchovies packed in olive oil with salt. The listing notes the fish are wild-caught and sustainably sourced from Peru. These fillets are described as having a savory, umami-packed taste suitable for enhancing sauces, dressings, and marinades. The simple ingredient list includes only anchovies, olive oil, and salt.
This option is well-suited for cooks who want a straightforward, imported product for adding depth to dishes like pizza or tapas boards.
- Sourced from Peru
- Ingredients include anchovies, olive oil, and salt
Cento Flat Fillet Anchovies in Olive Oil
Cento provides firm, skinless, and boneless anchovy fillets from Morocco packed in pure olive oil. The product is labeled as Non-GMO, BPA Free, and Gluten-Free. Each serving contains 35 calories and zero carbs, making it a low-calorie option for adding savory depth to meals. The easy-to-open pull-top tin is designed for convenience in busy kitchens.
Cento highlights its long history of providing Italian products, positioning this tin as a reliable choice for salad dressings and pasta sauces.
- Sourced from Morocco
- Contains 35 calories and zero carbs per serving
Ortiz Anchovies in Extra Virgin Olive Oil
Ortiz anchovies are wild-caught in the Cantabrian Sea off the northern coast of Spain. The fillets are described as firm and buttery with a rich umami taste, prepared using traditional methods that include maturing in barrels with salt for a minimum of six months. The product comes in a 3.3oz glass jar.
Ortiz emphasizes a balance of flavor that is not too fishy or briny, with a texture that is firm yet soft. This option is favored by those seeking a premium, traditional Spanish preparation for dishes like pasta puttanesca.
- Wild-caught in Spain
- Matured in barrels with salt for a minimum of 6 months
Reese Flat Fillets in Olive Oil (10 Pack)
Reese offers a pack of ten 2-ounce tins of flat fillets of anchovies packed in oil, totaling 20 ounces. The product is listed as 100% natural, containing anchovies and olive oil. It is described as having a tangy flavor that livens up Caesar dressing and a nutty flavor for pizzas and pasta.
The anchovies are a product of Morocco. This multi-pack format is suitable for households or restaurants that use anchovies frequently and prefer to stock multiple tins at once.
- Pack of 10 tins
- Product of Morocco
Cento Anchovy Paste
Cento Fine Foods produces an anchovy paste with ingredients listed as anchovies, sunflower oil, and salt. The product is 100% Italian and requires refrigeration after opening. It contains fish, which is noted in the allergen statement. This paste format offers a different texture and application method compared to whole fillets, allowing for easy incorporation into sauces or spreads.
It is a convenient option for cooks who want the flavor of anchovies without handling individual fillets.
- Ingredients include anchovies, sunflower oil, and salt
- Requires refrigeration after opening
Wild Planet Wild White Anchovies in EVOO
Wild Planet offers wild white anchovies packed in organic extra virgin olive oil. The product is Non-GMO, Gluten Free, Kosher Pareve, and Dairy Free. Each serving delivers 21g of protein and 688mg of EPA & DHA Omega-3s. The anchovies are described as delicate and small with a mild flavor and tender texture similar to sardines.
They are caught using sustainable, selective harvesting methods. This option is ideal for those seeking a milder anchovy experience with specific nutritional benefits.
- Packed in organic extra virgin olive oil
- Contains 21g of protein per serving
Cento Foods Anchovies Flat
Cento Foods offers a 2-ounce can of flat anchovies. The listing provides minimal detail, identifying the product simply as anchovies. This basic format is suitable for buyers who are familiar with the Cento brand and prefer a standard-sized tin for general culinary use. The lack of extensive feature descriptions in the listing suggests a focus on the core product itself.
Buyers should check the live product card for current availability and specific packaging details.
- 2 Ounce can size
- Brand is Cento Foods
Wild Planet Wild White Anchovies in Water
Wild Planet provides wild white anchovies packed in water with a touch of sea salt. The product is Non-GMO, Gluten Free, Kosher Pareve, and Dairy Free. Each serving contains 21g of protein and 1045mg of EPA & DHA Omega-3s. The anchovies are described as having a clean, mild flavor and a tender texture.
They are sustainably caught using selective harvesting methods. This water-packed option is a good choice for those who prefer a lighter packing medium and higher omega-3 content per serving.
- Packed in water with sea salt
- Contains 1045mg of EPA & DHA Omega-3s per serving
Head-to-Head Comparisons
Ortiz vs Cento: Origin and Texture
Ortiz anchovies are wild-caught in Spain and matured in barrels with salt for a minimum of six months, resulting in a firm, buttery texture. Cento anchovies are sourced from Morocco and described as firm, skinless, and boneless. Ortiz emphasizes a traditional preparation process that balances flavor without being too briny, while Cento highlights a low-calorie profile with zero carbs per serving.
Both are packed in olive oil, but Ortiz uses a glass jar while Cento uses a pull-top tin. The choice depends on whether you prefer the Spanish traditional method or the Moroccan sourcing with specific dietary labels.
Wild Planet: Olive Oil vs Water
Wild Planet offers two variations of wild white anchovies: one in organic extra virgin olive oil and one in water with sea salt. The olive oil version contains 688mg of EPA & DHA Omega-3s per serving, while the water version contains 1045mg. Both are Non-GMO, Gluten Free, Kosher Pareve, and Dairy Free, and each serving provides 21g of protein.
The water-packed version is described as having a clean, mild flavor, while the olive oil version is noted for a rich, savory flavor. Buyers should choose based on their preference for the packing medium and the specific omega-3 content they seek.
Reese vs Roland: Pack Size and Sourcing
Reese offers a pack of ten 2-ounce tins of flat fillets from Morocco, totaling 20 ounces. Roland Foods offers a single 2-ounce pack of flat fillets sourced from Peru. Both are packed in olive oil and described as having a savory or tangy flavor suitable for Caesar dressing and pasta.
Reese highlights a nutty flavor profile, while Roland emphasizes a umami-packed taste. The Reese option is a multi-pack, which may be suitable for frequent users, whereas Roland is a single unit. The sourcing difference between Morocco and Peru may influence flavor preference.
Buying Guide
Packing Medium
The medium in which anchovies are packed significantly affects flavor and texture. Olive oil packing, as seen in Roland, Cento, and Ortiz, adds richness and a savory depth. Water packing, such as in Wild Planet, offers a cleaner, milder taste and higher omega-3 content per serving.
Sunflower oil is used in Cento's paste format. Consider whether you prefer the added fat and flavor of oil or the lighter profile of water for your specific dish.
Sourcing and Origin
Anchovies are sourced from various regions, including Peru, Morocco, and Spain. Roland is sourced from Peru, Cento and Reese from Morocco, and Ortiz from Spain. Wild Planet notes sustainable, selective harvesting methods. The origin can influence the flavor profile and texture of the fillets. Some buyers prefer the traditional Spanish preparation of Ortiz, while others may prefer the Moroccan sourcing of Cento or Reese.
Check the listing for specific sourcing details.
Nutritional Profile
Nutritional information varies by product. Cento flat fillets contain 35 calories and zero carbs per serving. Wild Planet white anchovies provide 21g of protein per serving, with omega-3 content ranging from 688mg in the olive oil version to 1045mg in the water version. Cento paste contains anchovies, sunflower oil, and salt.
If you are tracking calories, carbs, or specific nutrients like omega-3s, compare the nutritional facts listed for each product to find the best fit for your dietary goals.
Packaging and Convenience
Packaging types include tins, glass jars, and paste containers. Cento offers a pull-top tin for easy opening, while Ortiz uses a glass jar. Reese comes in a 10-pack of tins, which is convenient for stocking up. Cento paste requires refrigeration after opening. Consider how you plan to use the anchovies and how often.
A multi-pack may be suitable for frequent use, while a single tin or jar is better for occasional use. Check the packaging type to ensure it fits your kitchen storage and usage habits.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are these anchovies wild-caught?
Yes, several products are described as wild-caught. Roland, Ortiz, and Wild Planet explicitly state their anchovies are wild-caught. Ortiz notes they are caught in the Cantabrian Sea using sustainable techniques. Wild Planet mentions selective harvesting methods to minimize bycatch. Check the specific listing for sourcing details.
What is the difference between white and regular anchovies?
Wild Planet describes their white anchovies as delicate and small with a mild flavor and tender texture, similar to sardines. Regular anchovies, such as those from Cento and Ortiz, are often described as having a robust umami taste and firm texture. The white variety is generally milder, while regular fillets are more savory.
Do I need to refrigerate these products?
Cento Anchovy Paste requires refrigeration after opening. Canned and jarred fillets, such as those from Roland, Cento, and Ortiz, are typically shelf-stable until opened. Always check the specific product label for storage instructions after opening to ensure freshness and safety.
Are these products suitable for specific diets?
Cento flat fillets are labeled Non-GMO, BPA Free, and Gluten-Free. Wild Planet products are Non-GMO, Gluten Free, Kosher Pareve, and Dairy Free. Cento paste contains fish, which is an allergen. Check the allergen statements and dietary labels on each product to ensure they meet your specific dietary requirements.
This article is part of our complete guide Grocery & Gourmet Food — browse all our comparisons and buying guides.
Last update on 2026-11-18 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API
