Selecting the right CO2 system for paintball depends on whether you prefer the convenience of disposable cartridges or the sustained pressure of a refillable tank. This comparison covers eight options, ranging from standard 12-gram capsules to high-capacity 88-gram tanks and a high-pressure air (HPA) alternative.
Each product serves a different need, from quick reloads with non-threaded 12g cartridges to the consistent velocity of a regulated HPA tank. Reviewing the capacity, compatibility, and installation method will help you match the system to your specific marker and playing style.
Our 3 picks for different needs
HK Army 48ci/3000psi Aluminum HPA Tank
The HK Army 48ci tank offers a refillable high-pressure system with a regulator and gauge for consistent velocity.
Read the details
Crosman Powerlet CO2 Cartridges (40 Count)
The Crosman 40-count pack provides a large quantity of 12-gram cartridges for extended shooting sessions.
Read the details
JT Paintball 88/90gram CO2 Tank (3 Count)
The JT Paintball 88-gram tanks offer higher capacity than 12g capsules for sustained pressure in compatible markers.
Read the detailsAll products, in detail
Umarex High-Grade CO2 Cartridges 12g (30 Pack)
Umarex offers these 12-gram cartridges in a 30-pack configuration, emphasizing clean CO2 quality to support the long-term health of airguns. The listing notes that the number of rounds per capsule varies by the specific airgun model. These cartridges are available in 12-gram or 88-gram sizes, though this specific listing is for the 12-gram variant.
Purchase availability is restricted to certain zip codes, which buyers should verify before ordering.
- Sold in a 30-pack of 12-gram cartridges
- Available for purchase only in certain zip codes
Umarex High-Grade CO2 Cartridges 12g (50 Pack)
This 50-pack of Umarex 12-gram cartridges provides a larger quantity for shooters who consume more CO2 per session. The brand highlights the importance of CO2 quality for airgun performance, describing the gas as clean. Like the 30-pack variant, the number of shots per cartridge depends on the specific airgun used.
Buyers should note that these cartridges are only available for purchase in certain zip codes.
- Sold in a 50-pack of 12-gram cartridges
- Restricted to specific zip codes for purchase
HK Army 48ci/3000psi Aluminum HPA Tank
The HK Army 48ci tank is a refillable high-pressure air system designed as an alternative to CO2. It features a 3000psi capacity and an 850psi output regulator with a pressure gauge. The aluminum construction includes a flat bottom for shoulder comfort and a rubber fill valve cover.
This tank is compatible with standard paintball markers and HPA-equipped airsoft guns, though it ships empty and must be filled prior to use.
- 48ci capacity with 3000psi maximum pressure
- Includes an 850psi output regulator with gauge
JT Paintball 88/90gram CO2 Tank (3 Count)
JT Paintball offers these prefilled 88-gram CO2 tanks in a 3-count pack. They are designed for use in paintball, airsoft, or airgun applications and can function as threaded 88g cartridges. This larger capacity option is suitable for players who prefer the sustained pressure of a tank over smaller 12-gram capsules.
The prefilled nature means they are ready for immediate installation in compatible markers.
- Prefilled 88-gram CO2 capacity
- Sold in a 3-count pack
Guard Dog Security 8g/12g CO2 Cartridges
Guard Dog Security provides non-threaded CO2 cartridges in 8-gram and 12-gram sizes. The listing emphasizes consistent power delivery, stating each cartridge can deliver up to 30 shots. These steel capsules are filled with pure carbon dioxide without oils or lubricants to ensure a snug fit and solid seal.
They are compatible with a wide range of airguns, airsoft pistols, and paintball markers that use a piercing mechanism.
- Non-threaded design for push-in installation
- Compatible with BB guns, airsoft, and paintball markers
Spozer 12g CO2 Cartridges (25 Pack)
Spozer 12g CO2 cartridges are sold in a 25-pack and feature a non-threaded neck for quick push-in installation. The brand claims these cartridges deliver steady pressure supporting 20 to 30 shots, depending on the equipment. They are filled with 100% pure CO2 without oil or additives to prevent residue buildup.
These cartridges are compatible with CO2 BB guns, air pistols, rifles, and paintball markers.
- 25-pack of 12-gram non-threaded cartridges
- Delivers 20-30 shots per cartridge
Daisy Powerline 12-Gram CO2 Cylinders (25 Count)
Daisy Powerline CO2 cylinders are designed to deliver steady pressure from the first shot to the last. The 25-count pack is intended for CO2-powered air rifles and pistols that take standard 12-gram cylinders. Daisy, based in Rogers, Arkansas, manufactures these cylinders to tight standards for dependable operation.
They are suitable for range practice or backyard use across most CO2 platforms on the market.
- 25-count pack of 12-gram cylinders
- Designed for CO2 air rifles and pistols
Crosman Powerlet CO2 Cartridges (40 Count)
Crosman Powerlet CO2 cartridges are built to the company's own specifications for consistent pressure with each trigger pull. This 40-count pack offers a larger quantity for extended shooting sessions. The cartridges feature a snug fit and leak-free seal with durable metal construction. They are optimized for Crosman CO2 airguns but are compatible with the majority of standard 12-gram CO2 platforms.
- 40-count pack of 12-gram cartridges
- Made in USA with durable metal construction
Head-to-Head Comparisons
Umarex 30-Pack vs 50-Pack: Quantity Needs
Both Umarex listings offer 12-gram high-grade CO2 cartridges, but they differ in pack size. The 30-pack is suitable for players who use fewer cartridges per session or want to test the brand before committing to a larger quantity. The 50-pack provides more cartridges, which may reduce the frequency of repurchasing for frequent shooters.
Both versions are restricted to certain zip codes, so buyers must verify their location for availability. The choice between the two depends entirely on your consumption rate and storage space.
Guard Dog vs Spozer: 12g Cartridge Features
Guard Dog Security and Spozer both offer 12-gram non-threaded CO2 cartridges designed for push-in installation. Guard Dog highlights compatibility with a wide range of airguns and airsoft pistols, noting that each cartridge can deliver up to 30 shots. Spozer specifies that their cartridges support 20 to 30 shots and emphasizes the use of 100% pure CO2 without oil or additives.
Both brands claim a snug fit and leak-resistant seal. The primary distinction is the specific shot count range and the emphasis on purity in the Spozer description.
HK Army HPA Tank vs JT 88g CO2 Tank
The HK Army 48ci tank is a refillable HPA system with a 3000psi capacity and an 850psi output regulator, while the JT Paintball tank is a prefilled 88-gram CO2 cartridge. The HPA tank requires filling prior to use and offers a pressure gauge for monitoring levels, whereas the CO2 tank is ready for immediate use.
The HPA system is designed for consistent velocity in all weather conditions, while the CO2 tank provides a traditional gas experience. Buyers must ensure their marker is compatible with either HPA or CO2 systems before purchasing.
Buying Guide
Cartridge Capacity and Shot Count
The number of shots per cartridge varies by brand and equipment. Guard Dog claims up to 30 shots per 12g cartridge, while Spozer lists a range of 20 to 30 shots. Umarex notes that the number of rounds depends on the specific airgun. Larger 88-gram tanks like the JT Paintball option provide significantly more capacity.
Consider your typical session length to determine if 12g capsules or 88g tanks better suit your needs.
Threaded vs Non-Threaded Installation
Non-threaded cartridges, such as those from Guard Dog and Spozer, are pushed into the gun's piercing mechanism for quick installation. Threaded cartridges require screwing in, which may offer a different seal mechanism. The installation method must match your marker's CO2 inlet valve. Check your marker's manual to confirm whether it accepts threaded or non-threaded cartridges before purchasing.
CO2 vs HPA Systems
CO2 systems use disposable cartridges or prefilled tanks, while HPA systems use refillable high-pressure air tanks. The HK Army HPA tank offers a regulated output of 850psi, which can provide consistent velocity. CO2 systems are generally simpler to use but may be affected by temperature.
HPA tanks require a filling station and ship empty. Choose based on your access to filling services and preference for consistency.
Compatibility and Availability
Most 12-gram cartridges are compatible with standard CO2 airguns, airsoft pistols, and paintball markers. However, specific brands like Crosman may be optimized for their own platforms. Umarex cartridges are only available in certain zip codes, which can limit access. Always verify that the cartridge size and type match your marker's requirements.
Check current prices and availability on the live product cards before ordering.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are 12g CO2 cartridges compatible with all paintball markers?
Most standard paintball markers accept 12-gram CO2 cartridges, but you must ensure the cartridge type (threaded or non-threaded) matches your marker's inlet valve. Check your marker's manual for specific compatibility requirements before purchasing.
What is the difference between CO2 and HPA tanks?
CO2 tanks are typically prefilled or disposable, while HPA tanks are refillable with compressed air. HPA systems often provide more consistent velocity and are less affected by temperature, but they require a filling station and ship empty.
How many shots can I expect from a 12g CO2 cartridge?
Shot count varies by brand and equipment. Guard Dog claims up to 30 shots, while Spozer lists 20 to 30 shots. The actual number depends on the specific airgun or marker used and its pressure requirements.
Do I need to fill HPA tanks before use?
Yes, all compressed air HPA paintball tanks, including the HK Army 48ci model, are shipped empty and must be filled prior to use to comply with Department of Transportation laws. You will need access to a filling station.
This article is part of our complete guide Sports & Outdoors — browse all our comparisons and buying guides.
Last update on 2026-11-18 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API
