Choosing the right pancake and waffle mix depends on your preferred flavor profile, package size, and specific dietary goals. Some mixes focus on a classic buttermilk taste, while others emphasize whole grains or higher protein content. The preparation process is generally simple, with most options requiring only water to create the batter.
The eight options in this comparison range from single 32 oz boxes to multi-packs of smaller pouches. You can select a mix based on whether you want a large family-sized box or individual portions for easy storage. Each product has distinct features, such as specific protein counts or non-GMO ingredients, that help you find the best fit for your breakfast routine.
Our 3 picks for different needs
Kodiak Cakes Protein Pancake Power Cakes, Buttermilk, 20 oz, 6 Pack
Kodiak Cakes Power Cakes are made with whole wheat and oat flours and provide 14g of protein per serving.
Read the details
Betty Crocker Buttermilk Pancake and Waffle Mix, 6.75 oz, 9 Pack
Betty Crocker's 9-pack of pouches allows for easy customization with fruits, nuts, or chocolate chips.
Read the details
Birch Benders Buttermilk Pancake & Waffle Mix, 16 oz
Birch Benders mix is made with a blend of wholesome, non-GMO ingredients in a 16 oz bag.
Read the detailsAll products, in detail
Mrs. Butterworth's Complete Buttermilk Pancake and Waffle Mix, 32 oz
This 32 oz box of Mrs. Butterworth's mix is designed for a simple breakfast routine. The listing notes that it is a good source of calcium and contains no preservatives. It is marketed as a complete mix that is easy to make by just adding water.
This option is suitable for shoppers who want a straightforward buttermilk flavor for weekend brunch or daily baking.
- 32 oz box size
- Good source of calcium
Betty Crocker Buttermilk Pancake and Waffle Mix, 6.75 oz, 9 Pack
Betty Crocker offers this mix in a 9-pack of 6.75 oz pouches. Each pouch is listed to make 10 pancakes and requires only water, with no eggs or milk needed. The mix is described as a quick and easy breakfast option that can be personalized with fruits, nuts, or chocolate chips.
This multi-pack format is useful for households that want to customize their batter or store individual portions.
- 9-pack of 6.75 oz pouches
- Makes 10 pancakes per pouch
Krusteaz Light and Fluffy Buttermilk Complete Pancake Mix, 32 oz
Krusteaz presents a 32 oz box of its Light and Fluffy Buttermilk mix. The product is crafted with buttermilk and is intended for breakfast, snacks, and beyond. It contains no artificial flavors, colors, or preservatives. The listing suggests using a waffle iron for buttermilk waffles and provides a recipe on the back of the bag.
This is a versatile option for those who want a classic buttermilk taste in a single large box.
- 32 oz box size
- No artificial flavors, colors, or preservatives
Amazon Grocery Buttermilk Pancake and Waffle Mix, 32 oz
Amazon Grocery offers a 32 oz box of Buttermilk Pancake and Waffle Mix. The ingredients include wheat, milk, and egg. The product is listed as containing no artificial flavors, synthetic colors, or chemical preservatives. It is part of the Amazon Grocery line, which is described as providing favorites for great-tasting meals.
This mix is a standard buttermilk option for shoppers looking for a straightforward 32 oz box.
- 32 oz box size
- Contains wheat, milk, and egg
Stonewall Kitchen Buttermilk Pancake & Waffle Mix, 16 oz
Stonewall Kitchen provides a 16 oz bag of its Buttermilk Pancake & Waffle Mix. The listing describes it as a fool-proof mix perfect for breakfast or Sunday brunch. It is designed to be paired with jams and syrups, and users can create their own recipes by adding fruit or trying new toppings.
This smaller 16 oz size is a good fit for those who want to try a gourmet-style mix or use it for occasional brunches.
- 16 oz bag size
- Designed to complement jams and syrups
Birch Benders Buttermilk Pancake & Waffle Mix, 16 oz
Birch Benders offers a 16 oz bag of Buttermilk Pancake & Waffle Mix. The product is made with a blend of wholesome, non-GMO ingredients. It is listed as easy and quick to prepare, requiring only water. The mix is described as producing fluffy pancakes and waffles with a rich buttermilk flavor.
This option is suitable for shoppers who prioritize non-GMO ingredients in a smaller 16 oz package.
- 16 oz bag size
- Made with non-GMO ingredients
Kodiak Cakes Protein Pancake Power Cakes, Buttermilk, 20 oz, 6 Pack
Kodiak Cakes provides a pack of six 20 oz boxes of Power Cakes. This mix is made with whole wheat and oat flours and is packed with 14g of protein per serving. It is made with non-GMO ingredients and can be used as a whole grain alternative to flour in baking recipes.
The box is made from 100% recycled paper. This is a distinct choice for buyers seeking a higher-protein, whole grain option in a multi-pack.
- Pack of 6, 20 oz boxes
- 14g protein per serving
Amazon Grocery Original Pancake and Waffle Mix, 32 oz
Amazon Grocery also offers an Original Pancake and Waffle Mix in a 32 oz box. The ingredients include wheat and egg. The product is listed as containing no synthetic colors or chemical preservatives. It is part of the Amazon Grocery line, which aims to provide everything needed for great-tasting meals.
This is a standard original-style mix for those who prefer a simpler ingredient profile in a 32 oz box.
- 32 oz box size
- Contains wheat and egg
Head-to-Head Comparisons
Mrs. Butterworth's vs Krusteaz: 32 oz Buttermilk Boxes
Both Mrs. Butterworth's and Krusteaz offer 32 oz boxes of buttermilk pancake and waffle mix. Mrs. Butterworth's is noted as a good source of calcium and contains no preservatives. Krusteaz is described as Light and Fluffy and contains no artificial flavors, colors, or preservatives. Krusteaz also suggests using a waffle iron for buttermilk waffles and provides a recipe on the back of the bag.
If you are looking for a mix that highlights calcium content, Mrs. Butterworth's is a clear choice. If you prefer a mix that explicitly lists the absence of artificial additives and includes a waffle recipe, Krusteaz is the better fit.
Betty Crocker vs Kodiak Cakes: Multi-Pack Formats
Betty Crocker and Kodiak Cakes both offer multi-pack options, but they serve different needs. Betty Crocker provides a 9-pack of 6.75 oz pouches, with each pouch making 10 pancakes. This format is ideal for those who want to customize their batter with fruits, nuts, or chocolate chips.
Kodiak Cakes offers a pack of six 20 oz boxes, which are made with whole wheat and oat flours and contain 14g of protein per serving. If you want a smaller, customizable portion for quick breakfasts, Betty Crocker is the right choice. If you are looking for a higher-protein, whole grain mix in a larger box format, Kodiak Cakes is the better option.
Stonewall Kitchen vs Birch Benders: 16 oz Gourmet Options
Stonewall Kitchen and Birch Benders both provide 16 oz bags of buttermilk pancake and waffle mix. Stonewall Kitchen describes its mix as fool-proof and perfect for Sunday brunch, and it is designed to complement its collection of jams and syrups. Birch Benders is made with a blend of wholesome, non-GMO ingredients and is listed as producing fluffy pancakes and waffles with a rich buttermilk flavor.
If you want a mix that pairs well with gourmet toppings and syrups, Stonewall Kitchen is the better fit. If you prioritize non-GMO ingredients in a smaller package, Birch Benders is the clear choice.
Buying Guide
Package Size and Portion Control
The size of the package is a key factor in how you will use the mix. Larger 32 oz boxes, like those from Mrs. Butterworth's, Krusteaz, and Amazon Grocery, are suitable for households that make pancakes frequently. Smaller 16 oz bags, such as those from Stonewall Kitchen and Birch Benders, are better for occasional use or for trying a new flavor.
Multi-packs, like the Betty Crocker 9-pack or Kodiak Cakes 6-pack, offer flexibility for storage and portion control.
Ingredient Profiles and Dietary Needs
Check the ingredient list to ensure the mix meets your dietary preferences. Kodiak Cakes Power Cakes are made with whole wheat and oat flours and are non-GMO. Birch Benders is also made with non-GMO ingredients. Amazon Grocery's Original mix contains wheat and egg, while its Buttermilk mix contains wheat, milk, and egg.
If you are looking for a mix with specific nutritional benefits, such as the 14g of protein per serving in Kodiak Cakes, that is a distinct feature to consider.
Preparation and Customization
Most mixes in this comparison are designed to be easy to prepare by simply adding water. Betty Crocker's mix is specifically noted as requiring no eggs or milk, making it a very simple option. You can also customize your batter by adding fruits, nuts, or chocolate chips, as suggested for Betty Crocker and Stonewall Kitchen.
If you want a mix that allows for easy personalization, these options are a good fit.
Flavor and Texture Preferences
The flavor and texture of the pancakes can vary between brands. Krusteaz is described as Light and Fluffy, while Birch Benders is listed as producing fluffy pancakes with a rich buttermilk flavor. Stonewall Kitchen is described as a fool-proof mix perfect for brunch. If you have a preference for a specific texture or flavor profile, look for these descriptors in the product listing to find the mix that best matches your taste.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do these mixes require eggs or milk?
Most of the mixes listed, including Betty Crocker, Krusteaz, and Birch Benders, are described as requiring only water. Amazon Grocery's Buttermilk mix contains milk and egg in its ingredients, but the preparation instructions for most options emphasize the simplicity of just adding water.
Which mix is best for a high-protein breakfast?
The listing states that the mix is packed with 14g of protein per serving and is made with whole wheat and oat flours. You can also increase the protein content by adding milk or an egg.
Are there any non-GMO options available?
Yes, Birch Benders and Kodiak Cakes are both listed as being made with non-GMO ingredients. Birch Benders uses a blend of wholesome, non-GMO ingredients, while Kodiak Cakes is made with non-GMO whole wheat and oat flours.
Can I use these mixes for waffles?
Yes, all eight products are titled as pancake and waffle mixes. Krusteaz specifically suggests using a waffle iron to create buttermilk waffles and provides a recipe on the back of the bag. The other mixes are also described as being suitable for making waffles in addition to pancakes.
This article is part of our complete guide Grocery & Gourmet Food — browse all our comparisons and buying guides.
