Choosing the right pickle relish depends on your preferred flavor profile and dietary needs. Whether you prefer a sweet, tangy taste or a classic dill flavor, there are options to suit your palate.
This guide compares eight popular pickle relishes, highlighting their specific features, sizes, and certifications. You will find details on organic, keto-friendly, and kosher-certified varieties to help you make an informed decision for your next hot dog or burger.
Our 3 picks for different needs
Vlasic Dill Relish, 10 fl oz
Vlasic Dill Relish is labeled Keto friendly and contains 0g added sugar, making it a distinct choice for carbohydrate-conscious shoppers.
Read the details
365 by Whole Foods Market Organic Sweet Pickle Relish, 10 fl oz
365 by Whole Foods Market Organic Sweet Pickle Relish is made with premium organic cucumbers, appealing to those who prioritize organic sourcing.
Read the details
Amazon Fresh Dill Relish, 10 fl oz
Amazon Fresh Dill Relish contains no artificial flavors or dyes and is labeled vegan and gluten free, suiting specific dietary restrictions.
Read the detailsAll products, in detail
Heinz Sweet Relish, 12.7 fl oz
Heinz offers a sweet, tangy, and savory flavor profile in a 12.7 fl oz bottle. The product is made from quality vegetables and spices, providing a classic taste for condiment lovers. It is Kosher certified, which is a key detail for specific dietary observances. The easy-to-squeeze bottle design makes serving effortless and mess-free.
This format is ideal for those who prefer a liquid pour over a chunky jar. It works well as a topping for hot dogs and burgers. You can also use it in deviled egg recipes for a different twist. The larger volume compared to standard jars may suit households that use relish frequently.
- 12.7 fl oz bottle size
- Kosher certified
Vlasic Sweet Relish, 10 fl oz
Vlasic presents a sweet relish in a 10 fl oz resealable jar. The product is labeled as Keto friendly, which is a significant distinction for shoppers tracking carbohydrate intake. It features a secret recipe that delivers a sweet flavor to dishes. Each serving contains 15 calories, a specific metric for those monitoring energy intake.
The resealable jar helps lock in flavor after opening. This product is suitable for topping hamburgers and hot dogs. The jar format allows for easy storage in the refrigerator. It is a good choice for those who want a sweet profile without the higher calorie count of some traditional relishes.
- Keto friendly label
- 15 calories per serving
Vlasic Dill Relish, 10 fl oz
Vlasic offers a dill pickle relish in a 10 fl oz resealable jar. This variety is labeled as Keto friendly and contains 0g added sugar. The product delivers a classic dill flavor using a secret recipe. It is noted to contain 0 calories per serving, which is a distinct feature for specific dietary needs.
The resealable jar design helps maintain freshness. This relish is great for topping hamburgers, hot dogs, and sandwiches. It provides a savory, pickle-forward taste rather than a sweet one. The 0g added sugar specification makes it a clear choice for those avoiding added sugars in their condiments.
- 0g added sugar
- 0 calories per serving
365 by Whole Foods Market Organic Sweet Pickle Relish, 10 fl oz
365 by Whole Foods Market provides an organic sweet pickle relish in a 10 fl oz jar. It is made with premium organic cucumbers, emphasizing ingredient quality. The flavor profile offers a perfect balance of sweet and tangy notes. This product is ideal for use on hamburgers, hot dogs, and salads.
The organic certification is a key differentiator for shoppers seeking certified organic produce. The jar size is standard for household use. It provides a versatile condiment that can be used in various recipes. The focus on organic cucumbers appeals to those who prioritize sourcing and sustainability in their grocery choices.
- Made with premium organic cucumbers
- 10 fl oz jar size
Mt Olive Sweet Relish, 16 oz
Mt Olive offers a sweet relish in a 16 oz package. The item package dimensions are 5.1 inches in length, 3.15 inches in width, and 3.15 inches in height. The package weight is 1.66 lbs. This is a single unit package. The larger volume compared to the 10 oz jars from other brands may be suitable for larger households or frequent users.
The sweet flavor profile is a classic choice for hot dogs and burgers. The specific package dimensions and weight are provided for shipping and storage planning. This product is a straightforward grocery item focused on the sweet relish category.
- 16 oz package size
- Package weight of 1.66 lbs
365 by Whole Foods Market Organic Dill Relish, 10 oz
365 by Whole Foods Market offers an organic dill pickle relish in a 10 fl oz jar. It is certified kosher for quality assurance. The product is made from premium organic cucumbers. It is perfect for hot dogs, burgers, and potato salad. The dill flavor is distinct from the sweet variety offered by the same brand.
The kosher certification is a specific attribute for dietary observance. The organic sourcing of the cucumbers is a key feature. This relish provides a savory, pickle-based taste. It is a good option for those who prefer dill over sweet relish and want organic ingredients.
- Certified kosher
- Made from premium organic cucumbers
Amazon Fresh Dill Relish, 10 fl oz
Amazon Fresh provides a dill relish in a 10 fl oz jar. The product contains no artificial flavors or dyes. It is labeled as vegan and gluten free. These dietary attributes make it suitable for a wide range of dietary restrictions. The dill flavor is a classic choice for sandwiches and hot dogs.
The absence of artificial additives is a key selling point for health-conscious shoppers. The jar size is standard for household use. This product is a good choice for those seeking a clean-label dill relish.
- No artificial flavors or dyes
- Vegan and gluten free
Amazon Saver Sweet Relish, 10 fl oz
Amazon Saver offers a sweet relish in a 10 fl oz jar. It is part of the Amazon Saver line, which aims to help grocery budgets go further. The sweet flavor profile is a classic condiment choice. The jar size is standard for household use.
This product is a straightforward option for those looking for a basic sweet relish. The brand positioning focuses on essential grocery items. It is a good choice for those who want a simple, no-frills sweet relish for their hot dogs and burgers.
- 10 fl oz jar size
- Amazon Saver brand
Head-to-Head Comparisons
Vlasic Sweet vs. Vlasic Dill Relish
Both Vlasic relishes come in 10 fl oz resealable jars and are labeled Keto friendly. The Sweet Relish contains 15 calories per serving and delivers a sweet flavor. The Dill Relish contains 0 calories per serving and 0g added sugar, offering a classic dill taste.
If you prefer a sweet profile, the Sweet Relish is the choice. If you want a savory, pickle-forward taste with no added sugar, the Dill Relish is better. The resealable jar design is consistent across both, ensuring flavor retention. Choose based on your preference for sweet versus dill flavor.
365 Organic Sweet vs. 365 Organic Dill Relish
Both 365 by Whole Foods Market relishes are made with premium organic cucumbers and come in 10 fl oz jars. The Sweet Pickle Relish offers a balance of sweet and tangy flavors, ideal for salads. The Dill Relish is certified kosher and is perfect for potato salad.
The organic certification is a key feature for both. If you prefer a sweet taste, choose the Sweet Pickle Relish. If you want a savory dill flavor and kosher certification, choose the Dill Relish. The organic sourcing ensures quality ingredients in both products.
Heinz Sweet vs. Mt Olive Sweet Relish
Heinz Sweet Relish comes in a 12.7 fl oz easy-to-squeeze bottle and is Kosher certified. Mt Olive Sweet Relish comes in a 16 oz package with specific dimensions and weight. The Heinz bottle offers a mess-free serving experience, while the Mt Olive package is larger in volume.
If you prefer a squeeze bottle for easy application, Heinz is the choice. If you need a larger volume in a standard package, Mt Olive may be better. Both offer a sweet flavor profile for hot dogs and burgers. The packaging format is the main difference between these two sweet relishes.
Buying Guide
Flavor Profile: Sweet vs. Dill
Decide whether you prefer a sweet or dill flavor. Sweet relishes, like Heinz and Vlasic Sweet, offer a tangy and savory taste. Dill relishes, like Vlasic Dill and Amazon Fresh Dill, provide a classic pickle flavor. Consider your preferred taste for hot dogs and burgers.
Some shoppers enjoy mixing both for a balanced flavor. Check the specific flavor description in each product listing to ensure it matches your preference.
Dietary Certifications and Labels
Look for specific dietary labels if you have restrictions. Some relishes are labeled Keto friendly, such as Vlasic Sweet and Dill. Others are certified kosher, like Heinz and 365 Dill. Amazon Fresh Dill is labeled vegan and gluten free. These certifications can help you align your condiment choice with your dietary needs.
Check the product details for specific certifications and labels to ensure they meet your requirements.
Packaging and Serving Convenience
Consider the packaging format for ease of use. Heinz comes in an easy-to-squeeze bottle, which is mess-free. Most other options come in resealable jars, which help lock in flavor. The jar size varies, with most being 10 fl oz, while Heinz is 12.7 fl oz and Mt Olive is 16 oz.
Choose a format that fits your serving habits and storage space. Squeeze bottles are convenient for quick toppings, while jars are good for scooping.
Organic and Ingredient Quality
If ingredient sourcing is important, look for organic options. 365 by Whole Foods Market offers both sweet and dill relishes made with premium organic cucumbers. This certification ensures the cucumbers are grown without synthetic pesticides. Other brands may not specify organic sourcing. Check the ingredient list and certifications to determine if organic quality is a priority for you.
Organic options may appeal to those who prioritize sustainability and natural ingredients.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between sweet and dill relish?
Sweet relish has a tangy and savory flavor, often used on hot dogs and burgers. Dill relish has a classic pickle flavor, which is more savory and less sweet. The choice depends on your personal taste preference for condiments.
Are any of these relishes keto friendly?
Yes, Vlasic Sweet Relish and Vlasic Dill Relish are labeled as Keto friendly. The Dill Relish also contains 0g added sugar and 0 calories per serving, making it a suitable option for keto diets.
Which relishes are certified kosher?
Heinz Sweet Relish and 365 by Whole Foods Market Organic Dill Relish are certified kosher. This certification ensures the products meet specific dietary laws, which is important for kosher-observant shoppers.
What is the largest package size available?
Mt Olive Sweet Relish comes in a 16 oz package, which is the largest size listed. Heinz Sweet Relish is 12.7 fl oz, and most other options are 10 fl oz. Choose the size that best fits your household's usage.
This article is part of our complete guide Grocery & Gourmet Food — browse all our comparisons and buying guides.
Last update on 2026-11-18 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API
