Choosing the right plant germination tray depends on the volume of seeds you plan to start and the specific needs of your seedlings. Whether you are growing a few large vegetables or a massive batch of microgreens, the cell size, material, and ventilation features play a significant role in your success.
This comparison looks at eight different tray configurations, ranging from flexible silicone cells to stackable plastic kits. We examine how each option handles drainage, humidity control, and ease of transplanting to help you find the setup that fits your indoor gardening space and workflow.
Our 3 picks for different needs
Burpee SuperSeed 36-Cell Reusable Tray
The flexible silicone cells pop out easily, reducing root stress when moving seedlings to the garden.
Read the details
MIXC 5 Pack Seed Starter Tray Kit
The stackable bottom trays allow you to save operating space before the seeds germinate.
Read the details
Bonviee 5-Pack 12-Cell Seed Starter Tray
The trays are specifically noted for their resistance to high temperatures, making them safe for heat mats.
Read the detailsAll products, in detail
Gardzen 5-Set Seed Starter Tray Kit
This five-set kit provides a total of 200 cells, making it suitable for gardeners who want to start a large volume of seeds at once. Each individual tray holds 40 cells and features a clear dome with two adjustable air vents to manage humidity. The durable plastic construction includes attached stickers to ensure a tight fit between the dome and base, while drain holes at the bottom help prevent overwatering.
This option is well-suited for those who need a complete, organized system for indoor gardening or greenhouse use.
- Includes 5 trays with 40 cells each for a total of 200 cells.
- Features clear domes with two adjustable air vents for humidity control.
Burpee SuperSeed 36-Cell Reusable Tray
The Burpee SuperSeed tray uses 36 flexible, food-grade silicone cells that pop out easily for transplanting, reducing stress on seedling roots. It includes a watering tray with deep channels and a raised perimeter to contain excess water, along with alphanumerical row labels for identification. The silicone material is top-shelf dishwasher safe, simplifying cleanup after the growing season.
This design is particularly helpful for gardeners who prioritize gentle root handling and easy maintenance of their seed starting equipment.
- Uses 36 flexible silicone cells that pop out for easy transplanting.
- Includes a watering tray with deep channels and a raised perimeter edge.
Mr. Pen 5-Set Seed Starter Tray Kit
This five-set kit offers a total of 200 cells, providing a practical solution for organized seed starting and greenhouse growing. The durable plastic components are built for repeated use, and individual cells feature drainage holes to manage water flow and support root development. Clear vented domes allow for easy control of humidity and airflow.
The package also includes a handy shovel and scoop, which helps make soil filling and transplanting cleaner and more efficient for the gardener.
- Includes 5 complete sets with a total of 200 cells.
- Comes with a shovel and scoop for easier soil filling and transplanting.
Burpee SuperSeed 16 XL Cell Tray
Designed for larger seeds, this Burpee tray features 16 extra-large flexible silicone cells that pop out for gentle transplanting. It shares the same smarter watering system as the 36-cell model, with molded corner slots for drainage and a raised perimeter to prevent spills. The alphanumerical labels and included Plant-o-Gram diagram help gardeners keep track of their seedlings.
This option is ideal for those growing vegetables like peppers or tomatoes that require more space for initial root development.
- Features 16 extra-large flexible silicone cells for larger seeds.
- Includes alphanumerical row labels and a Plant-o-Gram diagram for identification.
MIXC 5 Pack Seed Starter Tray Kit
This five-pack kit includes 200 cells in high-quality transparent plastic, allowing for easy observation of plant growth without disturbing the process. The humidity domes feature adjustable vents to regulate temperature and humidity, giving the gardener control over the environment. A key feature is the stackable design, where bottom trays can be stacked to save space before germination.
The package includes garden tools and plant labels, making it a comprehensive kit for indoor or outdoor use.
- Features stackable bottom trays to save space before germination.
- Includes 5 seed trays, 5 bottom trays, 5 domes, 2 tools, and 10 labels.
Bonviee 5-Pack 12-Cell Seed Starter Tray
This five-pack kit provides 60 cells total, with each cell measuring 1.5 inches square, making it suitable for large seeds like potatoes and eggplants. The clear plastic trays allow for easy observation, and the adjustable vents on the domes help regulate the seedling environment. The trays are designed to be heat-resistant, making them safe to use on heat mats without worrying about melting.
The package includes watertight base trays and plant labels for a complete starting setup.
- Cells are 1.5 inches square, suitable for large seeds like potatoes.
- Trays are heat-resistant and designed for use on heat mats.
The Hydroponic City 144-Cell Seed Starter Tray
This set includes 24 trays with 6 cells each, totaling 144 cells, and comes with 5 plant stakes for labeling. Each cell measures 1.5 inches square by 2.25 inches deep, a depth designed to promote healthy root development. The trays are made from durable, reusable materials and feature strategically placed drainage slits to prevent overwatering.
This configuration is equivalent to two standard 1020 tray inserts, offering a versatile option for growing a variety of flowers, herbs, and vegetables.
- Includes 24 six-cell trays for a total of 144 cells.
- Cells are 2.25 inches deep to promote healthy root development.
Mr. Pen 5 Pack 17×10 Inch Seed Tray
This five-pack of one-piece seed trays measures 17 by 10 by 2.4 inches, providing a large surface area for growing. The sturdy, durable plastic is lightweight and easy to clean, with raised edges to keep soil and water contained. These trays are compatible with all types of heat mats, humidity domes, and hydroponics systems.
They are versatile enough for germinating seeds, growing sprouts, or microgreens, making them a flexible addition to any gardening toolkit.
- Measures 17 x 10 x 2.4 inches with a one-piece design.
- Compatible with heat mats, humidity domes, and hydroponics systems.
Head-to-Head Comparisons
Burpee 36-Cell vs 16 XL Cell: Cell Size and Material
Both Burpee SuperSeed trays use flexible, food-grade silicone cells that pop out for easy transplanting, but they differ significantly in cell count and size. The 36-cell tray is better for starting a larger number of smaller seeds, such as herbs or flowers, while the 16 XL cell tray provides more space for larger seeds like peppers and tomatoes.
If you are growing a mix of vegetables, the 36-cell tray offers more density, whereas the 16 XL tray prioritizes root space for individual plants. Both include the same watering system with deep channels and raised perimeters to manage moisture effectively.
Gardzen vs Mr. Pen 5-Set Kits: Included Tools and Vents
The Gardzen and Mr. Pen five-set kits both offer 200 cells and clear vented domes, but they differ in their included accessories and ventilation design. The Gardzen kit features two air vents on the top of the dome for adjustable airflow, while the Mr. Pen kit includes a shovel and scoop to make soil filling and transplanting easier.
If you prioritize humidity control through ventilation, the Gardzen design may be more appealing. However, if you want to reduce the mess of handling soil, the Mr. Pen kit’s included tools provide a practical advantage for daily use.
MIXC vs Bonviee: Stackability and Heat Resistance
The MIXC and Bonviee kits both come in five-packs with clear domes and adjustable vents, but they target different growing conditions. The MIXC kit is designed for space efficiency, with bottom trays that can be stacked one by one to save room before germination. In contrast, the Bonviee kit emphasizes durability in heated environments, noting that its trays are resistant to high temperatures and safe for use on heat mats.
Choose MIXC if you have limited shelf space, or Bonviee if you rely on heat mats to speed up germination.
Buying Guide
Cell Count and Seed Volume
Determine how many seeds you plan to start at once. Kits with 200 cells, like the Gardzen and Mr. Pen options, are ideal for gardeners who want to start a large variety of plants simultaneously. Smaller trays, such as the 16-cell Burpee or 12-cell Bonviee, are better for those who prefer to start seeds in smaller batches or are growing larger vegetables that need more space per cell.
Material and Transplanting Ease
Consider how you will move seedlings from the tray to the garden. Flexible silicone cells, found in the Burpee SuperSeed trays, pop out easily and reduce root damage during transplanting. Rigid plastic trays, such as those from The Hydroponic City or Mr. Pen, are durable and reusable but may require more care when removing seedlings to avoid disturbing the root ball.
Ventilation and Humidity Control
Proper airflow is critical for preventing mold and promoting healthy growth. Look for domes with adjustable vents, which are featured in the Gardzen, Mr. Pen, MIXC, and Bonviee kits. These vents allow you to regulate humidity levels as your seedlings grow, providing a more controlled environment than solid domes or open trays.
Compatibility with Heat Mats
If you use heat mats to speed up germination, ensure your tray is rated for high temperatures. The Bonviee kit is explicitly noted for its heat resistance, making it a safe choice for heated setups. For other trays, check the manufacturer’s specifications to ensure the plastic will not warp or melt under the heat of a mat, especially if you are growing in a warm environment.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I reuse these seed starter trays?
Yes, most of the trays listed are designed for repeated use. The Burpee silicone trays are dishwasher safe, and the plastic trays from Gardzen, Mr. Pen, and others are made from durable materials that can be cleaned and stored for the next growing season.
What is the difference between a seed tray and a propagator?
A seed tray is the base that holds the cells and soil, while a propagator often includes a humidity dome to create a greenhouse effect. Many kits, like the MIXC and Bonviee options, include both the tray and the dome to provide a complete germination environment.
How do I prevent overwatering in these trays?
Most of these trays feature drainage holes or slits in the cells to allow excess water to escape. The Burpee trays also have deep channels in the watering tray to draw water away from the cells, helping to maintain optimal soil moisture without waterlogging the roots.
Are these trays suitable for microgreens?
Yes, the Mr. Pen 17×10 inch trays are specifically noted as being great for growing sprouts and microgreens. Their one-piece design and raised edges help keep soil and water contained, making them a versatile option for both traditional seed starting and microgreen production.
This article is part of our complete guide Garden & Outdoor Living — browse all our comparisons and buying guides.
Last update on 2026-11-20 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API
