Choosing the right quilting thread depends on whether you are working by hand or machine and the specific fiber of your fabric. Cotton threads are often preferred for their natural look and compatibility with cotton fabrics, while polyester threads offer strength and a wide range of color options.
This comparison looks at seven different thread options, ranging from single high-quality cotton spools to large multi-color polyester sets. By examining the ply, weight, and finish of each product, you can find a thread that matches your project needs and sewing style.
Our 3 picks for different needs
Coats & Clark S980-0100 Hand Quilting Cotton
The special glace finish on this 100% cotton thread is specifically designed to provide abrasion resistance and prevent tangling for hand quilters.
Read the details
BlesSew 24-Spool All-Purpose Polyester
This 24-spool polyester set includes 1,000 yards per spool and is compatible with most home sewing machines for a wide range of fabrics.
Read the details
HDST-HOME 72-Piece Pre-Wound Bobbin Set
This kit provides 36 pre-wound bobbins and matching spools, saving time for sewists who need a variety of colors for automatic winding machines.
Read the detailsAll products, in detail
Connecting Threads Essential White Cotton
This single spool of 100% triple-ply, long-staple cotton thread offers 1,200 yards of 50-weight fiber. The smooth, low-lint finish and soft satin sheen are designed for elegance in every stitch. It fits standard sewing machine spindles and is suitable for all levels of quilting and sewing projects, from beginner to professional.
This option is ideal for sewists who prefer a single, high-quality cotton spool for piecing and topstitching.
- 1,200 yards of 100% triple-ply, long-staple cotton
- 50-weight thread with a smooth, low-lint finish
Coats & Clark S980-0100 Hand Quilting Cotton
Made of 100% cotton, this 350-yard spool is specifically tailored for traditional hand quilters. The special glace finish provides abrasion resistance and helps prevent tangling and knotting during long hand-sewing sessions. This compact package is a focused choice for those who prioritize a dedicated hand-quilting thread with a finish designed to reduce friction and tangles.
- 350-yard spool of 100% cotton
- Special glace finish for abrasion resistance
Gutermann Sew-All 100m Assorted Set
This set includes 20 spools of Allesn her thread in 100m lengths, featuring the most popular basic colors. The all-rounder thread is made with micro core technology, a unique corespinning process based on microfilament polyester made in Germany. It is designed for all fabrics and is suitable for walking with the machine and by hand, as well as for closing, quilting, and fine decorative stitches.
- Pack of 20 spools in 100m lengths
- Micro core technology based on microfilament polyester
New brothread 12-Color Mercerized Cotton
This 12-color set features 100% gassed and mercerized cotton thread made from extra-long staple cotton. Each spool holds 600m (660Y) of 3-ply twisted bonded thread, which is 30WT. The mercerizing process gives the thread less lint, a smoother surface, and a greater luster. It is especially suitable for natural fabrics like cotton and linen, and the spools feature a locking base to resist tangling.
- 12 spools of 600m (660Y) mercerized cotton
- 3-ply twisted bonded thread with a locking base
New brothread 24-Color Mercerized Cotton
This expanded 24-color set offers the same 100% gassed and mercerized cotton thread as the 12-color option. Each spool contains 600m (660Y) of 3-ply twisted bonded thread, providing a wider range of basic colors for various projects. The thread is designed for quilting, serger, piecing, and machine or hand sewing.
The snapping spools include a locking base to keep thread tails from unwinding.
- 24 spools of 600m (660Y) mercerized cotton
- 3-ply twisted bonded thread with a locking base
HDST-HOME 72-Piece Pre-Wound Bobbin Set
This set includes 36 different colors of 100% polyester thread spools and 36 pre-wound bobbins. Each spool holds 360 yards of thread, while each Class A or Class 15 bobbin contains 40 yards. The sturdy plastic bobbins are suitable for sewing machines with automatic winding functions, including brands like Brother, Babylock, Janome, Kenmore, and Singer.
This kit is a convenient option for projects requiring a variety of colors for hand and machine sewing.
- 36 spools of 360-yard polyester thread
- 36 pre-wound Class A or Class 15 bobbins
BlesSew 24-Spool All-Purpose Polyester
This 24-spool set features 1,000 yards of 40/2 spun polyester thread in 22 colors plus double black and white. The thread is colorfast and fade-resistant, made with Azo-free dyes that are OEKO-TEX certified. It is designed for smooth sewing with minimal breakage using standard universal needle sizes 65/9 to 90/14.
The set comes in a boutique-style storage box, making it a practical choice for beginners and quilters who want an organized, all-purpose thread collection.
- 24 spools of 1,000-yard 40/2 spun polyester
- OEKO-TEX certified with Azo-free dyes
Head-to-Head Comparisons
Connecting Threads vs Coats & Clark: Cotton for Machine vs Hand
Connecting Threads offers a 1,200-yard spool of 50-weight triple-ply cotton, which is a substantial amount for machine sewing and piecing. Coats & Clark provides a 350-yard spool of 100% cotton specifically tailored for traditional hand quilters. The Coats & Clark thread features a special glace finish that provides abrasion resistance and prevents tangling, which is a key benefit for hand-sewing.
If you are doing a large machine project, the Connecting Threads spool offers more yardage. If you are hand-quilting a single quilt, the Coats & Clark finish may be more suitable for your specific technique.
New brothread 12-Color vs 24-Color: Color Range
Both New brothread options feature 100% gassed and mercerized cotton thread in 600m (660Y) spools. The primary difference is the number of colors included in the set. The 12-color set provides a selection of neutral and jean colors, which is useful for basic piecing and topstitching.
The 24-color set expands this range to include 24 basic colors, offering more variety for those who want a broader palette. Both sets use the same 3-ply twisted bonded thread and include spools with a locking base to resist tangling. Choose the 12-color set if you need specific neutrals, or the 24-color set if you want a wider selection of basic colors.
Gutermann vs BlesSew: Polyester Set Sizes
Gutermann’s Sew-All set includes 20 spools of 100m thread, which is a smaller amount per spool but offers a wide range of basic colors. BlesSew’s set includes 24 spools of 1,000-yard thread, providing a much larger total yardage. The Gutermann thread is made with micro core technology based on microfilament polyester, while the BlesSew thread is 40/2 spun polyester.
The BlesSew set is designed for smooth sewing with minimal breakage and includes a storage box. If you need a large amount of thread for frequent sewing, the BlesSew set offers more yardage per spool. If you prefer a smaller spool size for specific machine setups, the Gutermann set is a compact option.
Buying Guide
Cotton vs Polyester Fiber
Cotton thread is almost universally suited for any type of sewing, including piecing, quilting, and topstitching, and is especially suitable for natural fabrics like cotton and linen. Polyester thread is sturdy and durable, and it does not stretch a great deal like nylon threads. When choosing between the two, consider the fabric you are using.
Mercerized cotton thread has almost the same washing shrinkage rate as natural fabric, which can help avoid puckering after washing. Polyester is often used for its strength and colorfastness.
Ply and Weight
Thread weight and ply affect the thickness and strength of your stitches. A 50-weight single-ply yarn is a common standard for many sewing projects. Some threads, like the New brothread options, are 3-ply twisted bonded, which results in an actual weight of 30WT. Thicker threads may require needles with a larger eye to prevent stripping.
If you are using a standard 40WT sewing or embroidery thread, you may need to adjust your needle size if you switch to a thicker mercerized cotton thread. Always check the recommended needle size for your specific thread.
Hand vs Machine Use
Some threads are specifically designed for hand quilting, while others are optimized for machine sewing. Coats & Clark’s S980-0100 is ideal for traditional hand quilters and features a glace finish to prevent tangling. Connecting Threads’ Essential Thread is great for all levels of quilting and sewing projects from beginner to professional and fits standard sewing machine spindles.
If you are doing a lot of hand-sewing, look for a thread with a finish that reduces friction. If you are using a machine, ensure the spool fits your machine’s spindle or that you have the appropriate thread stand.
Spool Size and Storage
The size of the spool and the total yardage can impact how often you need to replace your thread. A 1,200-yard spool, like the Connecting Threads option, is a large amount for a single spool. A 350-yard spool, like the Coats & Clark option, is more compact.
Some sets, like the BlesSew and HDST-HOME options, come in storage boxes or kits that help keep your thread organized. If you have limited storage space, a smaller spool or a set with a storage box might be more convenient. Check the dimensions of the spool to ensure it fits your sewing machine or storage container.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is mercerized cotton thread suitable for quilting?
Yes, mercerized cotton thread is especially suitable for natural fabrics like cotton and linen. The mercerizing process gives the thread less lint, a smoother surface, and a greater luster. It is widely used for quilting, serger, piecing, and machine or hand sewing.
What is the difference between 3-ply and single-ply thread?
Single-ply yarn is a single strand of fiber, while 3-ply thread is made by twisting three strands together. This twisting process can result in a different actual weight and thickness. For example, a 50-weight single-ply yarn twisted into 3-ply may have an actual weight of 30WT.
Can I use polyester thread for hand quilting?
Polyester thread is sturdy and durable, and it can be used for hand sewing. However, some quilters prefer cotton for hand quilting because of its natural look and compatibility with cotton fabrics. The choice often depends on personal preference and the specific project requirements.
Do I need a special needle for mercerized cotton thread?
Mercerized cotton thread is often thicker than normal 40WT sewing or embroidery thread. It is recommended to use needles with a large eye, such as size 80/12 or larger, to prevent stripping. This ensures that the thread passes through the needle eye smoothly without fraying.
This article is part of our complete guide Arts, Crafts & Sewing — browse all our comparisons and buying guides.
