Choosing the right sandwich spread depends on your preferred flavor profile and dietary needs. Whether you crave the heat of spicy peppers, the tang of dill pickle, or the creamy richness of mayonnaise, there is a distinct option for every palate. These eight spreads offer a range of sizes and formats, from standard jars to convenient squeeze bottles.
Consider how you plan to use the spread, whether for simple sandwiches, complex salads, or as a marinade for grilling. Some options are certified Kosher or gluten-free, while others focus on specific regional flavors. Reviewing the specific ingredients and certifications will help you find the condiment that best fits your culinary habits.
Our 3 picks for different needs
Wickles Spicy Red Sandwich Spread 16 oz
Wickles Spicy Red offers bold, spicy flavors with red peppers and garlic, ideal for those who want heat in their sandwiches.
Read the details
Blue Plate Mayonnaise Sandwich Spread 8 Fl Oz Jar
Blue Plate Mayonnaise Sandwich Spread is explicitly listed as gluten-free and kosher, making it a suitable choice for specific dietary requirements.
Read the details
Arby's Horsey Sauce 12 fl. oz.
Arby's Horsey Sauce provides a creamy tang with horseradish powder, perfect for recreating signature sandwich flavors at home.
Read the detailsAll products, in detail
Kraft Sandwich Spread 15 fl oz Jar
Kraft offers a classic sandwich spread in a 15 fl oz jar. The listing highlights that the product is Kosher, making it a suitable choice for shoppers seeking specific dietary certifications. This jar size provides a standard volume for household use, allowing for multiple servings over time.
The brand is well-known for its condiments, and this specific variant focuses on a straightforward spread format. It is a practical option for those who prefer a certified product for their daily sandwich making.
- 15 fl oz jar size
- Kosher certified
Heinz Sandwich Spread 300g
Heinz provides a sandwich spread in a 300g container. The listing identifies the brand and the specific weight of the product, which is a common metric for international or metric-based packaging. This option is straightforward, focusing on the brand name and the quantity provided. Shoppers looking for a Heinz-branded spread in a 300g format will find this listing appropriate.
The description is minimal, emphasizing the core product identity without additional flavor descriptors in the provided data.
- 300g container size
- Heinz brand
Wickles Spicy Red Sandwich Spread 16 oz
Wickles Spicy Red Sandwich Spread is a 16 oz jar bursting with bold, spicy flavors. It is made with high-quality red peppers, garlic, and select spices, offering a savory blend of heat. This versatile condiment can be used as a dip, marinade, or glaze, adding a zesty kick to various dishes.
The product is proudly made in the USA, ensuring authentic Southern-inspired flavors. Its convenient jar packaging allows for easy spreading, scooping, or drizzling, making it a flexible addition to your culinary creations.
- 16 oz jar size
- Made in the USA
French's Creamy Dill Pickle Mustard Spread 12 oz
French's Creamy Dill Pickle Mustard blends yellow mustard with dill pickle for a tangy flavor profile. It is thick and spreadable, making it perfect for sandwiches and wraps. This spread adds zippy dill pickle flavor to potato, egg, and chicken salads. It is also great for grilling, where it can be used as a marinade for BBQ chicken or pork.
The combination of mustard and pickle offers a distinct taste that enhances both cold and hot dishes.
- 12 oz size
- Blends yellow mustard with dill pickle
Blue Plate Mayonnaise Sandwich Spread 8 Fl Oz Jar
Blue Plate Mayonnaise Sandwich Spread is an 8 Fl Oz jar made with Blue Plate Mayonnaise and sweet relish. It adds a touch of tang and sweetness to sandwiches, salads, and deviled eggs. The recipe uses oil, vinegar, and only egg yolks, creating a rich, creamy mayonnaise with full, balanced flavor.
This spread is gluten-free and kosher, making it suitable for various dietary needs. It is a versatile topping for burgers, egg or potato salad, and cold cuts, bringing out flavor in every dish.
- 8 Fl Oz jar size
- Gluten-free and kosher
Cento Hoagie Spread Hot 12 oz
Cento Hoagie Spread Hot is a 12 oz option for those who prefer a spicy profile in their hoagies. The listing identifies the product as a hot spread, indicating a level of heat that distinguishes it from milder varieties. This size is suitable for individual or small household use, providing a concentrated amount of flavor.
The brand Cento is associated with this specific hot hoagie spread, offering a straightforward choice for fans of spicy sandwich condiments.
- 12 oz size
- Hot flavor profile
Miracle Whip Mayo-like Dressing 12 fl oz Bottle
Miracle Whip Original Mayo-like Dressing comes in a 12 fl oz squeeze bottle. It is a tangy, delicious dressing and sandwich spread that tastes like mayonnaise. This flavorful ingredient is perfect for making salads, sandwiches, and dips. It contains 35 calories per 1 tbsp. serving and is certified Kosher.
The easy-squeeze bottle format makes it convenient for use, and the product is a SNAP & EBT eligible food item, offering accessibility for many shoppers.
- 12 fl oz squeeze bottle
- Certified Kosher
Arby's Horsey Sauce 12 fl. oz.
Arby's Horsey Sauce is a 12 fl. oz. all-purpose horseradish sauce made with vinegar, horseradish powder, and mustard flour. It adds a creamy tang to sandwiches, seafood cocktails, and chicken marinades. This sauce allows you to recreate Arby's signature sandwiches at home, providing a satisfying flavor with minimal effort.
It is popular for its creamy tanginess and can be used as a dipping sauce or cocktail sauce. The bottle format is convenient for home use, eliminating the need to hoard sauce packets.
- 12 fl. oz. bottle size
- Made with vinegar, horseradish powder, and mustard flour
Head-to-Head Comparisons
Wickles Spicy Red vs Cento Hoagie Spread Hot
Both Wickles Spicy Red and Cento Hoagie Spread Hot cater to shoppers who enjoy heat in their condiments. Wickles Spicy Red is a 16 oz jar made with red peppers, garlic, and select spices, offering a bold, spicy flavor that can be used as a dip, marinade, or glaze.
It is made in the USA with Southern-inspired flavors. Cento Hoagie Spread Hot is a 12 oz option specifically labeled as hot, providing a spicy profile for hoagies. While both offer heat, Wickles provides a larger volume and detailed ingredient information, whereas Cento focuses on a specific hoagie application.
Blue Plate Mayonnaise vs Miracle Whip Dressing
Blue Plate Mayonnaise Sandwich Spread and Miracle Whip Mayo-like Dressing both offer creamy, mayonnaise-based options. Blue Plate is an 8 Fl Oz jar made with mayonnaise and sweet relish, and it is explicitly listed as gluten-free and kosher. Its recipe uses oil, vinegar, and egg yolks for a rich flavor.
Miracle Whip is a 12 fl oz squeeze bottle that is a tangy, delicious dressing and sandwich spread, also certified Kosher. It contains 35 calories per tablespoon and is SNAP & EBT eligible. Blue Plate offers a smaller jar with a gluten-free claim, while Miracle Whip provides a larger squeeze bottle format.
French's Dill Pickle Mustard vs Arby's Horsey Sauce
French's Creamy Dill Pickle Mustard and Arby's Horsey Sauce both offer tangy, distinctive flavors for sandwiches and other dishes. French's blends yellow mustard with dill pickle, creating a zippy flavor that is great for grilling and salads. It is a 12 oz spread. Arby's Horsey Sauce is a 12 fl. oz. bottle made with vinegar, horseradish powder, and mustard flour, adding a creamy tang.
It is designed to recreate Arby's signature sandwiches and can be used as a dipping sauce. French's focuses on the dill pickle and mustard combination, while Arby's emphasizes the horseradish element for a different kind of tang.
Buying Guide
Flavor Profile and Heat Level
Determine if you prefer mild, tangy, or spicy flavors. Wickles Spicy Red and Cento Hoagie Spread Hot are designed for those who enjoy heat, with Wickles using red peppers and garlic. French's Creamy Dill Pickle Mustard offers a zippy, tangy profile from dill pickle and mustard.
Arby's Horsey Sauce provides a creamy tang with horseradish. If you prefer a milder, classic taste, Kraft and Heinz offer standard sandwich spreads, while Blue Plate and Miracle Whip provide creamy, mayonnaise-based options.
Dietary Certifications and Ingredients
Check for specific dietary needs such as Kosher or gluten-free certifications. Kraft, Blue Plate, and Miracle Whip are all listed as Kosher. Blue Plate is also explicitly labeled as gluten-free. Miracle Whip is a SNAP & EBT eligible food item. If you have specific dietary restrictions, these certifications can help you make an informed choice.
Always review the ingredient list for allergens, as some spreads contain mustard, vinegar, or egg products.
Packaging Size and Format
Consider the size and format that best suits your usage. Kraft comes in a 15 fl oz jar, while Wickles Spicy Red is a 16 oz jar. French's, Cento, and Arby's are all 12 oz or 12 fl. oz. options. Blue Plate is an 8 Fl Oz jar, and Miracle Whip is a 12 fl oz squeeze bottle.
The squeeze bottle format of Miracle Whip may be convenient for easy dispensing, while jars are standard for most other options. Choose a size that matches your consumption rate to avoid waste.
Versatility in Cooking and Serving
Think about how you plan to use the spread beyond sandwiches. Wickles Spicy Red can be used as a dip, marinade, or glaze. French's Creamy Dill Pickle Mustard is great for grilling and can be used as a marinade for BBQ chicken or pork. Arby's Horsey Sauce is versatile for seafood cocktails, chicken marinades, and dipping sauces.
Blue Plate and Miracle Whip are ideal for salads, deviled eggs, and dips. If you want a condiment that can enhance multiple dishes, look for spreads that list multiple uses in their features.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which sandwich spreads are Kosher?
Kraft, Blue Plate, and Miracle Whip are all listed as Kosher in their product descriptions. This certification may be important for shoppers with specific dietary requirements. Always check the packaging for the specific Kosher symbol or certification details to ensure it meets your standards.
Are any of these spreads gluten-free?
Blue Plate Mayonnaise Sandwich Spread is explicitly listed as gluten-free in its features. This makes it a suitable option for those avoiding gluten. Other spreads in this comparison do not have a gluten-free claim in the provided data, so you should check their individual labels if this is a concern.
What is the difference between a spread and a dressing?
Miracle Whip is described as a mayo-like dressing and sandwich spread, indicating it can be used in both ways. Other products like Kraft and Heinz are labeled specifically as sandwich spreads. The distinction often lies in the intended use, with dressings often being thinner for salads, while spreads are thicker for sandwiches.
Can these spreads be used as marinades?
Yes, several of these spreads can be used as marinades. Wickles Spicy Red is listed as a marinade, and French's Creamy Dill Pickle Mustard is great for grilling and can be used as a marinade for BBQ chicken or pork. Arby's Horsey Sauce is also suggested for chicken marinades.
This versatility makes them useful for cooking beyond just sandwiches.
This article is part of our complete guide Grocery & Gourmet Food — browse all our comparisons and buying guides.
Last update on 2026-11-18 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API
