Selecting the right starter pistol depends on whether you prioritize modern tactical features, historical aesthetics, or high-capacity convenience. These six CO2-powered options range from semi-automatic pistols to classic revolvers, each offering distinct advantages for training and plinking.
Consider your preferred grip style and the type of ammunition you plan to use. Some models offer dual ammo compatibility, while others focus on specific steel BB performance. Reviewing the capacity, frame material, and accessory options will help you identify the platform that best matches your shooting goals.
Our 3 picks for different needs
Umarex Steel-Storm .177 Caliber BB Gun
The 30-shot capacity and 300-round reserve reservoir minimize reload interruptions during extended shooting sessions.
Read the details
Crosman SNR357 Snub Nose CO2 Revolver
The dual ammo design allows shooters to switch between .177 pellets and steel BBs without changing the firearm.
Read the details
Umarex Colt Peacemaker Single Action Army Revolver
The all-metal frame and realistic single-action operation cater to buyers seeking a classic frontier look.
Read the detailsAll products, in detail
Umarex Glock 19 Gen3 .177 Caliber BB Gun
This officially licensed air pistol features a 15-shot magazine and fixed Glock-style sights. It shoots .177 caliber steel BBs at up to 410 fps using a 12-gram CO2 cartridge. The integrated Weaver rail allows for easy mounting of accessories, making it a solid choice for those seeking a modern, semi-automatic style platform for backyard plinking.
- 15-shot capacity with .177 caliber steel BBs
- Integrated Weaver rail for accessory mounting
Crosman SNR357 Snub Nose CO2 Revolver
A full-metal body revolver that offers a dual ammo design compatible with both .177 pellets and steel BBs. It features a 6-shot swing-out cylinder and includes reusable cartridges for both ammo types. With speeds up to 500 fps for pellets and 400 fps for BBs, it provides a heavy-weight, realistic handling experience for shooters who want versatility in ammunition.
- Dual ammo design for .177 pellets and steel BBs
- Full-metal body with a 6-shot swing-out cylinder
Umarex Smith & Wesson M&P 40 .177 BB Gun
This air pistol features a 19-shot drop-free magazine and fiber optic sights for enhanced visibility. It shoots .177 caliber steel BBs at up to 410 fps and includes an integrated accessory rail for tactical lights or lasers. The manual safety and standard action make it suitable for training as well as casual backyard shooting.
- 19-shot drop-free magazine with fiber optic sights
- Integrated accessory rail for tactical attachments
Umarex Colt Peacemaker Single Action Army Revolver
An all-metal frame revolver designed to look and feel like the iconic frontier six-shooter. It shoots .177 caliber steel BBs from individual cartridges at up to 410 fps. The realistic action and historical design make it a compelling option for history buffs and collectors who appreciate the aesthetic of classic single-action firearms.
- All-metal frame with realistic single-action operation
- 6-round capacity with included BB casings
Umarex Steel-Storm .177 Caliber BB Gun
This high-capacity air pistol features a 30-shot capacity with a 300-round reserve BB reservoir. It offers a choice between single shot mode or a 6-round full-auto burst mode. Powered by two 12-gram CO2 cartridges, it shoots .177 caliber steel BBs at up to 430 fps and includes flip-up sights for quick target acquisition.
- 30-shot capacity with a 300-round reserve reservoir
- Selectable single shot or 6-round burst mode
Umarex 2252109 Brodax Air Pistol
A 10-shot revolver with a durable polymer frame and metal internal parts. It shoots .177 caliber steel BBs at up to 375 fps using a 12-gram CO2 cartridge. The integrated Picatinny accessory mounts make it easy to add optics, lasers, or lights, providing a lightweight yet functional platform for shooters who prefer a revolver-style grip.
- 10-shot revolver with a durable polymer frame
- Integrated Picatinny mounts for optics and lights
Head-to-Head Comparisons
Umarex Glock 19 vs Smith & Wesson M&P 40
Both the Umarex Glock 19 and the Smith & Wesson M&P 40 are semi-automatic air pistols that shoot .177 caliber steel BBs at up to 410 fps. The Glock 19 features a 15-shot magazine and fixed Glock-style sights, while the M&P 40 offers a 19-shot drop-free magazine and fiber optic sights.
The M&P 40 includes an integrated accessory rail for tactical lights or lasers, whereas the Glock 19 features an integrated Weaver rail. Buyers who prefer a higher magazine capacity and fiber optic sights may lean toward the M&P 40, while those who value the specific Glock-style markings and fixed sights might prefer the Glock 19.
Crosman SNR357 vs Umarex Colt Peacemaker
The Crosman SNR357 and the Umarex Colt Peacemaker are both revolvers with a 6-shot capacity, but they differ significantly in construction and ammunition compatibility. The SNR357 features a full-metal body and a dual ammo design compatible with both .177 pellets and steel BBs, offering speeds up to 500 fps with pellets.
The Colt Peacemaker has an all-metal frame and shoots .177 caliber steel BBs at up to 410 fps. The SNR357 includes reusable cartridges for both ammo types, while the Peacemaker includes BB casings. Shooters who want the flexibility to use pellets may find the SNR357 more suitable, while those focused on the historical single-action aesthetic may prefer the Peacemaker.
Umarex Steel-Storm vs Brodax Air Pistol
The Umarex Steel-Storm and the Brodax Air Pistol offer different approaches to capacity and frame construction. The Steel-Storm is a semi-automatic pistol with a 30-shot capacity and a 300-round reserve reservoir, shooting .177 caliber steel BBs at up to 430 fps. It features flip-up sights and a selectable 6-round burst mode.
The Brodax is a 10-shot revolver with a durable polymer frame and metal internal parts, shooting .177 caliber steel BBs at up to 375 fps. The Steel-Storm is powered by two 12-gram CO2 cartridges, while the Brodax uses a single 12-gram cartridge. Buyers seeking high capacity and burst fire may prefer the Steel-Storm, while those who prefer a lighter polymer revolver may choose the Brodax.
Buying Guide
Ammunition Compatibility
Check whether the pistol is designed for steel BBs only or if it supports dual ammunition types. The Crosman SNR357 is compatible with both .177 pellets and steel BBs, offering greater flexibility for different shooting scenarios. Most other models in this comparison, such as the Umarex Glock 19 and the Colt Peacemaker, are specified for .177 caliber steel BBs.
Choosing a dual-ammo model allows you to experiment with different projectile types without purchasing a new firearm.
Magazine Capacity and Reload Frequency
Capacity determines how often you need to reload during a shooting session. The Umarex Steel-Storm offers a 30-shot capacity with a 300-round reserve reservoir, which is ideal for extended plinking. The Umarex Smith & Wesson M&P 40 provides a 19-shot drop-free magazine, while the Umarex Glock 19 has a 15-shot capacity.
Revolvers like the Crosman SNR357 and the Umarex Colt Peacemaker have a 6-shot capacity, requiring more frequent reloads but offering a distinct handling experience.
Frame Material and Weight
The frame material affects the weight and feel of the pistol. The Crosman SNR357 and the Umarex Colt Peacemaker feature full-metal or all-metal frames, providing a heavy-weight, realistic balance. The Umarex Brodax uses a durable polymer frame with metal internal parts, which may result in a lighter overall weight.
Semi-automatic models like the Umarex Glock 19 and the Steel-Storm typically feature polymer or metal frames depending on the specific design. Consider your preference for a heavier, more traditional feel or a lighter, more modern platform.
Accessory Mounts and Sights
Look for integrated rails and sight types that match your intended use. The Umarex Glock 19 and the Smith & Wesson M&P 40 both feature integrated accessory rails for mounting tactical lights or lasers. The Umarex Brodax includes integrated Picatinny accessory mounts for optics, lasers, or lights.
Sight options vary, with the M&P 40 featuring fiber optic sights, the Steel-Storm having flip-up sights, and the Glock 19 using fixed Glock-style sights. These features can enhance visibility and allow for the addition of specialized equipment.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do these starter pistols come with CO2 cartridges?
No, the CO2 cartridges are not included with any of the listed products. Each pistol is powered by 12-gram CO2 cartridges, which must be purchased separately. The Umarex models recommend using Umarex-brand CO2 to ensure a proper seal and best performance.
What is the difference between a starter pistol and an air pistol?
In this context, the term starter pistol often refers to entry-level air pistols or revolvers designed for plinking and training. These firearms use CO2 power to shoot .177 caliber steel BBs or pellets. They are distinct from blank-firing starter pistols used for race starts, which do not fire projectiles.
Can I use pellets in the Umarex Glock 19?
The Umarex Glock 19 is specified to shoot .177 caliber steel BBs. It is not listed as compatible with .177 caliber pellets. For dual ammo compatibility, consider the Crosman SNR357, which is designed to work with both pellets and steel BBs.
Which model has the highest velocity?
The Umarex Steel-Storm shoots .177 caliber steel BBs at up to 430 fps. The Crosman SNR357 delivers speeds up to 500 fps when using .177 caliber pellets, though it reaches 400 fps with BBs. The other models in this comparison shoot at up to 410 fps or 375 fps with steel BBs.
This article is part of our complete guide Sports & Outdoors — browse all our comparisons and buying guides.
Last update on 2026-11-18 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API
