Choosing the right sugar packet holder depends on your material preference, the number of units needed, and the specific environment where they will be used. Whether you are outfitting a home coffee bar, a busy restaurant, or an office break room, the available options range from single glass units to large sets of plastic caddies.
This comparison examines eight distinct products, looking at their construction materials, dimensions, and intended uses. By understanding the differences between acrylic, SAN plastic, wood, and glass, you can select a holder that fits your aesthetic and functional needs.
Our 3 picks for different needs
Carlisle FoodService White SAN Sugar Caddy
The Carlisle white caddy is NSF Listed and dishwasher safe, making it a suitable choice for commercial kitchens requiring certified materials.
Read the details
BWODYAY Acacia Wood Sugar Packet Holder
The BWODYAY holder is handcrafted from solid acacia wood with a non-slip pad, fitting buyers who prefer a natural material over plastic.
Read the details
New Star Foodservice Set of 24 Black SAN Sugar Holders
The New Star set of 24 black SAN holders provides a large quantity of compact units for outfitting multiple restaurant tables at once.
Read the detailsAll products, in detail
SOUJOY Set of 6 Acrylic Sugar Packet Holders
This set includes six clear acrylic holders, each measuring 4.2 inches long, 2.4 inches wide, and 2 inches high. The BPA-free material is described as shatter-resistant and stackable, making it suitable for tight spaces on countertops or in cabinets. The smooth surface is easy to clean with mild soap and water, and the open top keeps contents visible.
This option is well-suited for home kitchens, coffee bars, or offices that need a simple, elegant shape to match modern decor while organizing sugar packets, tea bags, and creamers.
- Set of 6 holders measuring 4.2"L x 2.4"W x 2"H
- Made of BPA-free clear acrylic that is stackable
New Star Foodservice Set of 24 Black SAN Sugar Holders
Designed for restaurant-grade use, this set of 24 holders is made from heavy-duty SAN plastic. Each unit measures 3-3/8 inches by 2-1/2 inches by 2 inches, offering a compact footprint that minimizes clutter on tabletops. The black plastic construction is described as stain and break-resistant, helping maintain appearance during daily use.
This large pack provides ample supply for multiple tables or locations, keeping sugar packets, sweeteners, and condiments neatly arranged and easily accessible in a commercial setting.
- Set of 24 holders made of heavy-duty SAN plastic
- Measures 3-3/8" x 2-1/2" x 2" per unit
New Star Foodservice Set of 12 Clear Plastic Sugar Holders
This set includes 12 clear plastic sugar packet holders, each measuring approximately 3.8 inches by 2.5 inches by 2 inches. The transparent construction allows for easy visibility of contents at a glance, which is useful for organizing table-top sweeteners. The lightweight plastic is described as durable and easy to clean, making it suitable for both restaurant and home use.
This option helps keep condiments and sweeteners in one place for easy access in a variety of dining environments.
- Set of 12 clear plastic holders
- Measures approximately 3.8" x 2.5" x 2"
Carlisle FoodService White SAN Sugar Caddy
This white plastic sugar caddy is crafted from SAN material, offering durability against staining, breaking, and chipping. It is designed to hold 20 sugar packets, helping to keep kitchen or dining areas neatly arranged. The caddy is dishwasher safe and recyclable, providing an environmentally responsible option for foodservice applications.
It is NSF Listed, meeting standards for quality, safety, and cleanliness. This single-unit option is ideal for those seeking a certified, durable, and easy-to-clean container for individual table or counter use.
- Holds 20 sugar packets and is NSF Listed
- Dishwasher safe and made of recyclable SAN plastic
BWODYAY Acacia Wood Sugar Packet Holder
Handcrafted from 100% solid acacia wood, this holder features a non-slip bottom pad to prevent scratching tabletops. It measures 4.9 inches by 2.6 inches by 2.2 inches, offering a compact design that fits neatly on tabletops or in drawers. The multi-purpose caddy is suitable for organizing sugar packets, tea bags, office supplies, or small candies.
Its warm wood aesthetic adds a decorative touch to coffee bars or dining tables, making it a suitable gift option for family and friends who enjoy a natural material finish.
- Handcrafted from 100% solid acacia wood
- Measures 4.9" x 2.6" x 2.2" with a non-slip bottom pad
ELLDOO Set of 4 Acrylic Sugar Packet Holders
This set of four holders is made from high-quality food-grade acrylic, described as sturdy, transparent, and stackable for space-saving. Each unit measures 3.2 inches by 2.2 inches by 2.0 inches. The clear design allows you to see through what is inside, helping you find what you need at a glance.
These caddies are multi-purpose, suitable for storing sugar packets, tea bags, cookies, or candies. They are well-suited for family gatherings, restaurants, offices, or hotels where a transparent, modern look is desired.
- Set of 4 food-grade acrylic holders
- Measures 3.2" x 2.2" x 2.0" per unit
Carlisle FoodService Black SAN Sugar Caddy
This black plastic sugar caddy is crafted from SAN material, offering exceptional durability against staining, breaking, and chipping. It holds 20 sugar packets, serving as an organizational tool for kitchen or dining areas. The caddy is dishwasher safe and recyclable, making it an environmentally responsible choice.
It is NSF Listed, ensuring it meets stringent standards for quality, safety, and cleanliness in foodservice applications. This single-unit option provides a durable, certified, and easy-to-clean solution for individual use.
- Holds 20 sugar packets and is NSF Listed
- Dishwasher safe and made of recyclable SAN plastic
Libbey Glass Clear Sugar Packet Holder
This crystal clear glass holder features a perfectly balanced and petite design, making it ideal for resting on tabletops. It measures 3 1/2 inches in length, 2 3/8 inches in width, and 2 1/8 inches in height. The glass construction provides a classic look while offering convenient access to sugar for coffee or tea.
This single-unit option is great for organizing sugar packets in a home or commercial setting where a durable, transparent glass material is preferred over plastic or wood.
- Made of crystal clear glass
- Measures 3 1/2" x 2 3/8" x 2 1/8"
Head-to-Head Comparisons
Carlisle White vs Carlisle Black Sugar Caddies
The Carlisle white and black sugar caddies share identical specifications, including their SAN plastic construction, 20-packet capacity, and NSF Listing. Both are dishwasher safe and recyclable, offering the same durability against staining and chipping. The primary difference is the color, which allows you to match your existing tableware or decor.
If you prefer a neutral, classic look, the white caddy is a standard choice. If you want a darker, more modern appearance, the black caddy provides the same certified performance with a different visual profile.
SOUJOY Acrylic Set vs ELLDOO Acrylic Set
Both the SOUJOY and ELLDOO sets are made from clear acrylic and are designed to be stackable and transparent. The SOUJOY set includes six holders, each measuring 4.2 inches long, while the ELLDOO set includes four holders, each measuring 3.2 inches long. The SOUJOY holders are described as BPA-free, a specific material attribute not listed for the ELLDOO set.
If you need a larger quantity of slightly longer caddies, the SOUJOY set may be more suitable. If you prefer a smaller footprint with a four-pack configuration, the ELLDOO set offers a compact alternative.
BWODYAY Wood Holder vs Libbey Glass Holder
The BWODYAY holder is crafted from solid acacia wood, offering a warm, natural aesthetic with a non-slip bottom pad. The Libbey holder is made of crystal clear glass, providing a transparent, classic look. The wood holder measures 4.9 inches long, while the glass holder measures 3 1/2 inches long.
The BWODYAY option is described as a gift option and multi-purpose organizer, while the Libbey option is described as perfectly balanced for tabletops. Choose the wood holder for a decorative, natural finish or the glass holder for a traditional, see-through design.
Buying Guide
Material Durability and Maintenance
Consider how you will clean your holders. The Carlisle caddies are explicitly listed as dishwasher safe, which is convenient for high-volume use. The SOUJOY and ELLDOO acrylic holders are described as easy to clean with mild soap and water. The Libbey glass holder is made of crystal clear glass, which is durable but requires careful handling.
The BWODYAY wood holder features a non-slip pad to protect surfaces. Selecting a material that matches your cleaning routine and durability needs is essential for long-term satisfaction.
Capacity and Packet Count
Check the stated capacity of each holder to ensure it fits your needs. The Carlisle caddies are specified to hold 20 sugar packets. The other products, such as the New Star, SOUJOY, ELLDOO, and Libbey options, do not specify a packet count in their provided features.
If you have a large number of packets, the Carlisle caddies offer a documented capacity. For other holders, you may need to estimate based on their dimensions, as the exact number of packets they can hold is not provided in the listing details.
Set Quantity and Space
Determine how many units you need for your space. The New Star offers sets of 12 and 24, which are ideal for restaurants with many tables. The SOUJOY set includes six holders, and the ELLDOO set includes four. The Carlisle, BWODYAY, and Libbey options are sold as single units.
If you are outfitting a single home coffee bar, a single unit or a small set may be sufficient. For commercial use, larger sets like the New Star 24-pack provide ample supply for multiple locations.
Certifications and Food Safety
For foodservice applications, certifications can be important. The Carlisle caddies are NSF Listed, meeting standards for quality, safety, and cleanliness. The SOUJOY holders are described as BPA-free, which is a specific material safety attribute. The ELLDOO holders are described as food-grade acrylic. The other products do not list specific certifications in their provided features.
If you are using these holders in a commercial kitchen, look for products with explicit certifications like NSF Listing to ensure they meet your facility's requirements.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are these sugar packet holders dishwasher safe?
The Carlisle white and black caddies are explicitly listed as dishwasher safe. The SOUJOY and ELLDOO acrylic holders are described as easy to clean with mild soap and water, but their dishwasher safety is not specified. The Libbey glass and BWODYAY wood holders do not list dishwasher safety in their features.
Check the specific product details for cleaning instructions.
What materials are these holders made from?
The materials vary by product. The SOUJOY and ELLDOO holders are made of acrylic. The New Star and Carlisle holders are made of SAN plastic. The BWODYAY holder is made of solid acacia wood. The Libbey holder is made of crystal clear glass. Each material offers different aesthetic and durability characteristics.
Can I use these holders for items other than sugar?
Yes, several products are described as multi-purpose. The SOUJOY holders are suitable for tea bags, sugar cubes, and creamer. The BWODYAY holder can organize office supplies, paper clips, and small candies. The ELLDOO holders can store cookies, macarons, and nuts. The New Star holders are suitable for condiments and sweeteners.
The Libbey holder is described as great for organizing sugar packets.
Do these holders come in sets?
Yes, several products are sold in sets. The SOUJOY set includes six holders. The New Star offers sets of 12 and 24. The ELLDOO set includes four holders. The Carlisle, BWODYAY, and Libbey options are sold as single units. Choose a set if you need multiple units for a restaurant or a large home kitchen.
This article is part of our complete guide Home & Kitchen — browse all our comparisons and buying guides.
Last update on 2026-11-18 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API
