Automotive

Vehicle Soft Shell Carriers: 7 Options Compared for Capacity and Fit

This post contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.

Product details come from Amazon listings. Compare the specifications that matter to you, and check the current price and availability on Amazon before buying. How we compare

Choosing a vehicle soft shell carrier depends on how much gear you need to haul and where you can mount it. Roof bags offer the most space without blocking the rear window, while hitch bags keep the roof clear for bikes or ladders.

The options here range from compact 11 cubic foot hitch bags to massive 50 cubic foot roof carriers. Each model uses waterproof PVC or vinyl with welded seams, but they differ in strap systems, hook types, and recommended vehicle sizes. Check your vehicle's roof dimensions and rack compatibility before selecting a size.

AT A GLANCE

Our 3 picks for different needs

Mockins XXL 50 CuFt Car Rooftop Cargo Carrier Bag | Massive 85'x50'x20' Heavy Duty Car Luggage Roof...
04Maximum Capacity for Vans

Mockins 50 Cubic XXL Carrier

The Mockins 50 cubic foot carrier provides the largest storage space in this group, suitable for cross-country moves or large family vacations.

Read the details
FIVKLEMNZ Car Rooftop Cargo Carrier Roof Bag Waterproof for All Top of Vehicle with/Without Rack...
03Compact Fit for Small Cars

FIVKLEMNZ 15 Cubic Roof Bag

The FIVKLEMNZ 15 cubic foot bag is recommended for small cars, offering a smaller footprint that may fit vehicles where larger bags overhang.

Read the details
MaxxHaul Soft Shell Cargo Carrier Bag for Hitch Mount Cargo Rack, Heavy Duty Water Resistant, 47 x...
07Hitch Rack Alternative

MaxxHaul 11 Cubic Hitch Bag

Amazon Prime

The MaxxHaul 11 cubic foot bag mounts to a hitch cargo rack, keeping the roof clear for other equipment or better aerodynamics.

Read the details

All products, in detail

Sailnovo Rooftop Cargo Carrier Bag 21 Cubic,Waterproof Soft-Shell Roof Bag
01

Sailnovo 21 Cubic Rooftop Carrier

The Sailnovo 21 cubic foot carrier uses 1000D PVC with sealed seams and extended zipper flaps to protect gear from rain and abrasion. It includes an anti-slip mat, 10 reinforced straps, and six safety door hooks for secure mounting on vehicles with or without roof racks.

This model is suitable for families needing space for four to six people, provided the roof measures at least 53 inches long and 41 inches wide.

  • 21 cubic feet capacity
  • 1000D PVC construction
CYDDUP Roof Bag, Waterproof Soft Car Top Carrier Without Rack, 21 Cubic Feet Cargo Carrier for Top...
02

CYDDUP 21 Cubic Roof Bag

The CYDDUP 21 cubic foot roof bag features high-density waterproof PVC with multi-stitch reinforced seams to resist wind and rain. It includes an anti-slip mat, six door hooks, and a combination lock to secure the zippers and protect the cargo. This carrier fits cars, trucks, and SUVs with or without racks, using straps tied to crossbars or door hooks under the rubber seals.

  • 21 cubic feet capacity
  • Includes combination lock
FIVKLEMNZ Car Rooftop Cargo Carrier Roof Bag Waterproof for All Top of Vehicle with/Without Rack...
03Compact Fit for Small Cars

FIVKLEMNZ 15 Cubic Roof Bag

The FIVKLEMNZ 15 cubic foot roof bag is constructed from 840D PVC with high-frequency welded seams and a double-layered waterproof cover. It measures 46 by 34 by 17 inches and includes eight reinforced straps, six door hooks, and an anti-slip mat. This smaller capacity option is recommended for small cars, offering a compact solution for road trips and camping gear.

  • 15 cubic feet capacity
  • 840D PVC material
Mockins XXL 50 CuFt Car Rooftop Cargo Carrier Bag | Massive 85'x50'x20' Heavy Duty Car Luggage Roof...
04Maximum Capacity for Vans

Mockins 50 Cubic XXL Carrier

The Mockins 50 cubic foot XXL carrier offers massive storage for SUVs and vans, measuring 85 by 50 by 20 inches. It is built from thick, abrasion-resistant vinyl with heat-welded seams and waterproof zippers under protective Velcro flaps. The kit includes ratchet and buckle straps, eight hooks, a combo lock, and a storage bag, backed by a ten-year limited warranty.

  • 50 cubic feet capacity
  • 10-year limited warranty
FIVKLEMNZ 21 Cubic Rooftop Cargo Carrier Waterproof Soft Car Roof Bag | for All Top of Vehicle...
05

FIVKLEMNZ 21 Cubic Roof Bag

Amazon Prime

The FIVKLEMNZ 21 cubic foot roof bag uses 840D PVC with high-frequency welded seams and a double-layered waterproof cover. It measures 52 by 40 by 18 inches and includes ten reinforced straps, six door hooks, and an anti-slip mat. This model is recommended for SUVs, providing ample space for suitcases, tents, and sleeping bags for four to six people.

  • 21 cubic feet capacity
  • 10 reinforced straps
VENTURE 4TH Rooftop Cargo Carrier - 21 Cu Ft, Soft-Shell, Waterproof | 600D PVC, waterproof SBS...
06

VENTURE 4TH 21 Cubic Carrier

The VENTURE 4TH 21 cubic foot carrier is made from 600D PVC with heat-sealed seams and waterproof SBS zippers. It features a unique six-strap compression system that pulls side flaps tight to seal out water, along with four top-mounted tie-down straps for stability. This model includes a non-slip roof mat, door hooks, and a combination padlock, backed by a lifetime replacement guarantee.

  • 600D PVC construction
  • Lifetime replacement guarantee
MaxxHaul Soft Shell Cargo Carrier Bag for Hitch Mount Cargo Rack, Heavy Duty Water Resistant, 47 x...
07Hitch Rack Alternative

MaxxHaul 11 Cubic Hitch Bag

Amazon Prime

The MaxxHaul 11 cubic foot soft shell carrier is designed for hitch mount cargo racks rather than the roof. It measures 47 by 20 by 20 inches and is made of PVC with polyester reinforcement and a UV coating. The bag features welded seams, a heavy-duty zipper with hook and loop flaps, and six polypropylene straps for secure attachment to the rack.

  • 11 cubic feet capacity
  • Hitch mount design

Head-to-Head Comparisons

FIVKLEMNZ 15 Cubic vs 21 Cubic: Size and Strap Count

Both FIVKLEMNZ models use 840D PVC with high-frequency welded seams and double-layered waterproof covers. The 15 cubic foot version measures 46 by 34 by 17 inches and includes eight reinforced straps, making it suitable for small cars. The 21 cubic foot version measures 52 by 40 by 18 inches and includes ten reinforced straps, recommended for SUVs.

If your vehicle is a compact sedan, the 15 cubic foot bag may fit better, while the 21 cubic foot bag offers more room for family gear.

Sailnovo vs VENTURE 4TH: Material and Compression

The Sailnovo 21 cubic foot carrier uses 1000D PVC, while the VENTURE 4TH uses 600D PVC. Both feature heat-sealed or welded seams and waterproof zippers. The VENTURE 4TH includes a unique six-strap compression system that pulls side flaps tight, whereas the Sailnovo relies on ten reinforced straps and an aerodynamic slope to prevent rain accumulation.

The VENTURE 4TH also offers a lifetime replacement guarantee, while the Sailnovo provides a standard support response.

Mockins 50 Cubic vs MaxxHaul 11 Cubic: Mounting and Volume

The Mockins 50 cubic foot carrier is a roof bag measuring 85 by 50 by 20 inches, designed for SUVs and vans. The MaxxHaul 11 cubic foot bag is a hitch mount carrier measuring 47 by 20 by 20 inches. The Mockins offers significantly more volume for large loads, while the MaxxHaul keeps the roof clear and is suitable for those with hitch racks.

The Mockins includes ratchet and buckle straps, while the MaxxHaul uses six polypropylene straps for rack attachment.

Buying Guide

Measure Your Roof and Rack

Before purchasing, measure your vehicle's roof length and width. The Sailnovo 21 cubic foot bag requires a roof over 53 inches long and 41 inches wide. The VENTURE 4TH requires at least 53 inches of spacing for crossbars. If your vehicle has a panoramic or glass sunroof, check compatibility, as some carriers are not recommended for these surfaces to avoid pressure damage.

Choose the Right Mounting Point

Roof bags maximize interior space but require roof racks or door hooks. Hitch bags, like the MaxxHaul, mount to a cargo rack on the hitch, keeping the roof free. If you plan to carry bikes or ladders on the roof, a hitch bag may be the better choice.

Ensure your vehicle has the appropriate rack or hitch receiver for the carrier you select.

Assess Your Gear Volume

Estimate the total volume of your luggage, tents, and sleeping bags. A 15 cubic foot bag fits 4-6 suitcases, while a 50 cubic foot bag can hold a mountain of gear. If you are traveling with a large family or moving items, the Mockins 50 cubic foot carrier offers the most space.

For solo or couple trips, a 21 cubic foot bag may be sufficient.

Prioritize Security and Weather Protection

Look for carriers with combination locks to secure zippers and prevent theft. Anti-slip mats protect your vehicle's paint and prevent shifting at highway speeds. Check the number of straps and hooks included; more straps generally provide better stability. All listed carriers feature waterproof PVC or vinyl with welded seams, but the specific zipper flap design varies by brand.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do these carriers fit vehicles without roof racks?

Yes, most roof bags in this list include door hooks that attach under the rubber seal of the door. This allows installation on vehicles without roof racks, though you should check your vehicle's specific compatibility and roof dimensions.

Are these carriers truly waterproof?

The carriers are made from waterproof PVC or vinyl with welded or heat-sealed seams. Zipper flaps and compression systems help keep water out. While designed for heavy rain, always check the specific waterproofing features of the model you choose.

Can I use these carriers on vans?

Yes, the Mockins 50 cubic foot carrier is specifically designed for SUVs and vans. The 21 cubic foot models from FIVKLEMNZ and VENTURE 4TH also fit vans, provided the roof dimensions and rack spacing meet the manufacturer's requirements.

How do I store these carriers when not in use?

All listed carriers include a storage bag. The soft shell design allows them to fold compactly, making them easy to store in a garage or closet. This is a significant advantage over hard-shell roof boxes, which are bulky and difficult to store.

Last update on 2026-11-19 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Was this article helpful?

Thanks for your feedback!

Thanks — we'll work to improve this article.

Kylan Shields

Kylan Shields

Kylan Shields is the editorial byline of Tossions. Comparisons published under this name are compiled from Amazon listing data (specifications, customer ratings and availability), not from hands-on testing.