Choosing a scar reducing treatment depends on the age of the scar and your preferred application method. Some products are gels that absorb into the skin, while others are silicone sheets that create a physical barrier.
The eight options listed here include various sizes and formats, from small tubes to long rolls of tape. Consider whether you need a product for a specific body area or one that can be customized for different shapes.
Our pick: Mederma Advanced Scar Gel 20g. Mederma Advanced Scar Gel is formulated for consistent daily use on both old and new scars with a triple-action formula.
Our 3 picks for different needs
Mederma Advanced Scar Gel 20g
Mederma Advanced Scar Gel is formulated for consistent daily use on both old and new scars with a triple-action formula.
Read the details
Silicone Scar Sheets 1.6"x 158" Roll
The 158-inch roll of silicone sheets allows users to trim the tape to fit long surgical or C-section scars.
Read the details
Mederma PM Intensive Overnight Scar Cream 1.7 Oz
The 1.7 oz Mederma PM cream provides an extended supply for nightly application on multiple scar areas.
Read the detailsAll products, in detail
Mederma Advanced Scar Gel 20g
This gel uses a triple-action formula with Cepalin botanical extract to lock in moisture and support collagen production. It is designed for both old and new scars from acne, burns, or surgery. The 20g tube is intended for daily application, with a recommended duration of eight weeks for new scars and three to six months for existing ones.
- Contains Cepalin botanical extract
- 20g tube size
Silicone Scar Sheets Medical Grade Tape
These medical-grade silicone sheets are designed for a wide range of scar types, including surgical, keloid, and burn scars. The breathable material allows for 24-hour comfortable wear and is residue-free. Users are advised to apply them for four to six weeks on new scars and two to four months on older scars to improve texture and smoothness.
- Medical-grade silicone material
- Breathable and residue-free
Mederma PM Intensive Overnight Scar Cream 1.0 oz
Formulated to work with the skin's nighttime regenerative activity, this cream absorbs quickly without leaving a sticky residue. It features a Tripeptol Complex containing peptides, collagen, and antioxidants to nourish the skin. The 1.0 oz size is suitable for nightly use on sensitive skin and is eligible for HSA and FSA accounts.
- Contains Tripeptol Complex
- 1.0 oz size
Cicatricure Advanced Scar Gel 1 oz
This lightweight, non-greasy gel is suitable for both adults and children. It uses a Regenerare Complex with hydrating agents to improve the appearance of scars from surgeries, cuts, and burns. The product is applied four times per day and is marketed to show visible improvement in as little as two weeks for some users.
- Suitable for adults and kids
- 1 oz (28 g) size
Mitgary Advanced Scar Gel 50g
This silicone-based gel is preservative-free and sulfate-free, making it suitable for sensitive skin. It is designed to be applied thinly twice a day to areas like the face, ears, and joints. The 50g container provides a larger supply for long-term use on new or old scars, with results expected over eight weeks to six months.
- Preservative-free and sulfate-free
- 50g (1.7 Oz) size
Silicone Scar Sheets 1.6"x 158" Roll
This clear, ultra-thin silicone tape comes in a 158-inch roll that can be trimmed to fit various scar shapes. It creates a protective barrier to shield scars from friction and external irritation. The flexible design is useful for long-term care of C-section, surgical, or burn scars, helping to retain moisture on the skin's surface.
- 158-inch (4M) roll format
- Clear and ultra-thin material
Mederma PM Intensive Overnight Scar Cream 1.7 Oz
This extended-size overnight cream uses Tripeptol Technology to support collagen production and cell renewal. It is paraben-free and non-greasy, designed to be massaged onto scarred areas before bed. The 1.7 oz size offers an extended supply for long-term care or multiple scar areas, with clinical claims of noticeable results in 14 days.
- 1.7 oz extended size
- Paraben-free formula
NUVADERMIS Silicone Scar Sheets 10 ft Roll
Made with premium European-sourced silicone, these sheets provide a protective, hydrating barrier for up to 24 hours. The 10-foot roll is soft, breathable, and easy to cut for different shapes. It is suitable for surgical scars, C-section recovery, and can also be used as forehead wrinkle patches to smooth fine lines.
- 10-foot roll format
- European-sourced silicone
Head-to-Head Comparisons
Mederma Gel vs Silicone Sheets: Application Style
Mederma Advanced Scar Gel is a topical formula that penetrates the skin to lock in moisture, while the Silicone Scar Sheets create a physical barrier over the area. The gel is applied at least once daily and is suitable for areas where a sheet might be difficult to keep in place.
The sheets are designed for 24-hour wear and are residue-free. Buyers who prefer a hands-off approach during the day may find the sheets more convenient, whereas those who want a product that absorbs quickly may prefer the gel.
Mederma PM 1.0 oz vs 1.7 oz: Supply Duration
Both Mederma PM Intensive Overnight Scar Creams use the same Tripeptol Technology and are designed for nightly use. The primary difference is the container size: the 1.0 oz version is a standard supply, while the 1.7 oz version offers an extended supply. If you are treating multiple scars or plan to use the cream for several months, the larger 1.7 oz size may be more practical.
The smaller 1.0 oz size is a good option for trying the product or treating a single, smaller scar area.
158-inch Roll vs 10-foot Roll: Tape Length
Both products are silicone scar sheets in roll format, but they differ in length and material sourcing. The 158-inch (4M) roll is clear and ultra-thin, designed to be virtually undetectable. The 10-foot roll uses premium European-sourced silicone and is noted for its reliable adhesion for up to 24 hours.
The 158-inch roll is slightly longer in total length, which may be useful for very long scars, while the 10-foot roll emphasizes the quality of the silicone for consistent comfort.
Buying Guide
Gel vs Sheet Format
Gels like Mederma and Cicatricure are applied directly to the skin and absorb, making them suitable for areas that move frequently. Silicone sheets create a protective barrier and are often worn for extended periods. Choose a gel if you want a product that does not require removal, or a sheet if you want a physical shield against friction.
Scar Age and Treatment Duration
Most products in this list specify different timelines for new versus old scars. For example, Mederma recommends eight weeks for new scars and three to six months for old ones. Silicone sheets often suggest four to six weeks for new scars. Check the specific duration recommended for your scar type to set realistic expectations for the treatment period.
Size and Customization
Tubes and jars come in fixed sizes, such as 1 oz or 50g, which determine how long the product will last. Roll formats, like the 10-foot or 158-inch silicone tapes, allow you to cut the material to fit the exact shape and size of your scar.
If your scar is irregular or very long, a roll format offers more flexibility than a pre-cut sheet or a fixed-size tube.
Skin Sensitivity and Ingredients
If you have sensitive skin, look for products that highlight specific safety features. Mitgary gel is preservative-free and sulfate-free, while Mederma PM is paraben-free and safe for sensitive skin. Some products, like Cicatricure, are explicitly noted as suitable for children. Review the ingredient list and safety claims to ensure the product matches your skin's tolerance.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I use these products on new scars?
Yes, most of the listed products are designed for both new and old scars. However, the recommended duration of use is typically shorter for new scars, often ranging from two to eight weeks, compared to several months for older scars.
How often should I apply scar gel?
Application frequency varies by product. Mederma Advanced Scar Gel is applied at least once daily, while Cicatricure is applied four times per day. Mitgary gel is applied twice a day. Always follow the specific directions provided with your chosen product.
Are silicone sheets reusable?
The 158-inch roll product is specifically labeled as reusable scar tape in its title. The NUVADERMIS product is described as staying securely in place for up to 24 hours, but the source data does not explicitly state that it is reusable. Check the specific product details to confirm if the sheets are intended for single or multiple uses.
Do these products work on keloid scars?
Several products, including the Silicone Scar Sheets and NUVADERMIS sheets, are explicitly designed to treat keloid and hypertrophic scars. Gels like Cicatricure are noted for improving non-keloid and hypertrophic scars. Check the specific scar types listed in the product features.
This article is part of our complete guide Beauty & Personal Care — browse all our comparisons and buying guides.
Last update on 2026-11-20 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API
